User Reviews

Review this title
1 Review
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
Three more aces and more.....
dbdumonteil2 December 2017
1)Jean Grémillon :Bertrand Tavernier fell in love with Grémillon 's cinema since he saw "Le Ciel Est A Vous" in a college art house society.Grémillon ,he tells us ,and so does Charles Spaak (archive) he had everything going for him but the producers ' approval :his career suffered accordingly and after the war ,he was only allowed three movies whereas he had so much to give!

BT focuses on the post 1939 career ,omitting the thirties (with the exception of "Dainah La Métisse " which featured a black doctor in 1931 (which American movie,he points out ,would have done the same at the time?)"Dainah" is certainly attractive ,but so are "Maldonne " (a silent movie in which social relatives ,one of his main subjects,are already present) the raving "Gardiens De Phare" ,"L'Etrange Monsieur Victor" and "Gueule D'Amour".

Minor quibble : all the movies BT chose are great : the "Le Ciel Est A Vous " extracts are stellar : the march of the orphans singing "Le Pont De Nantes" , Charles Vanel abetting his wife in her dream to fly (a very feminist attitude at the time),the same making himself understand without having to spell it out:"your mom may come back,but later,much later".The sublime last scene of "Remorques",in which men fight against a raging sea is worthy of an epic Hugo poem. In Grémillon' s work ,realism becomes lyricism .BT praises the post war efforts "Pattes Blanches " (Michel Bouquet's first important part)and "L'Amour D'Une Femme " (then again, a female doctor on an island in the fifties!)

2)Max Ophuls ;here again, BT's work focuses on one period : the fifties .Danielle Darrieux is the queen of the sequence (she also dominates the third sequence).No static shots ,but film camera in motion , which makes you dizzy when MC Peter Ustinov introduces Lola Montès ,swirling dances in "Madame De ";and the title "La Ronde" (round dance) tells it all.Refined style ,even when he depicts prostitutes coming to a young girl's communion (BT shows us Gabin ,gauche, wooing Darrieux),or the brothel ,filmed from the outside)in "Le Plaisir".

3)Henri Decoin :it took BT time (like for Duvivier,his closest relative in this episode) before he entered Decoin's world ;Didier Decoin ,his son, a writer ,told us he was always a man who was afraid to starve (he did starve when he was young) .That's why he was forced to accept films he did not want (particularly late fifties and sixties).In "Bonnes A Tuer" (not a very bad movie,Monsieur Tavernier,by the way!) Michel Auclair tells us he knows what hunger means.

This is the sequence in which I do not always agree with Monsieur Tavernier:too much time is given over to the anodyne "Battements De Coeur" ;and what? No 'Non Coupable" (with a mind-boggling performance by Michel Simon) ? No "Fille Du Diable "?(unsung Andrée Clément deserves a honorable mention at least!) But all the rest is splendid indeed:the depiction of the lugubrious town in "Les Inconnus Dans La Maison" where rain never stops falling down, the voice over dialogue in "Les Amoureux Sont Seuls Au Monde,predating Resnais by a decade ,the comedy-turned-Film Noir in "Retour A L'Aube" .Decoin's marvelous use of his scores.And mischievous BT reveals us where he found the sentence which introduces all the episodes.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed