Silent Nights (2016) Poster

(2016)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
Misguided idiocy
mamlukman14 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This is just sad, but it seems to be what's happening nowadays.

A Danish girl works at the Salvation Army as a volunteer to help black African refugees. One of them supports himself (?) by collecting empty cans to turn in at local stores. He's turned away from the shelter when it's full. Instead of accepting it, he yell's "F... you" at the volunteers. We see him again the next day, when he's at least smart enough to come a bit early to get a place. He smiles at the Danish girl, she smiles back...she befriends him. Meanwhile we see him making periodic calls to his family in Ghana, where a woman (later we learn it's his wife) keeps urging him to send money home. He can't, of course.

Well, things move along. Before you know it he's helping the Danish girl at the shelter. Now he knows where the cash is kept and where the key is. So he steals the money (which is money to be spent on the other refugees, remember). The girl confronts him after seeing the CCTV footage. He says it was for his father's operation (a lie). She forgives him. Then she lets him move in with her. She offers to marry him so he can stay in Denmark. Then one day when he's taking a shower, his phone rings. She answers, and it's a woman, who hangs up. Then she looks at photos on the phone (this part doesn't hang together, since he had his original phone stolen- -so where did he get the photos? the cloud???) and clearly he's married with three children. She confronts him and tosses him out.

It's over, right? Not at all. She hunts him down and tells him he'd be better off in Ghana. He agrees, but doesn't have the money to fly back, and besides that there is the shame of arriving back a failure without money. He can't do it. So she gives him 50,000 kroner (she got 35,000 from her mother when she died). Before this she has explained she has had a hard life too-- which you can see she did. She's far from rich. So he goes home to his family, and she discovers she's pregnant with his child. She's overjoyed.

Now this get political. I can see where very, very, very liberal people would say, "Oh, she's a saint, she helped the poor guy." But the "poor guy" abandoned his family in Ghana, doesn't appear to be looking for a job, stole money from the shelter, lied about why he did it, took advantage of the girl by living with her and having sex with her, and of course was happy to take her 50,000.

Excuse me, she's an idiot. Worse than an idiot. (Why worse? Because she's now given a wonderful example to other refugees: lie, steal, abandon your family, screw the local women. She has put other women who don't feel as magnanimous as she does in danger. Good work!) But astoundingly you can look up similar stories (real) online of German, Swedish, and Finnish women who have "felt sorry" for refugees, taken them into their homes/apartments, and then--shocker!!--were surprised when the refugees raped them. At the trials ALL of these women said they felt guilty because the poor refugees couldn't help themselves, and the women felt obligated to help them, including offering their bodies. Poor Europe.
17 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A very confusing and muddled message....though it still could easily take home the Oscar for Best Live Action Short.
planktonrules11 February 2017
This film is about a woman who volunteers with the local Salvation Army shelter as well as a man she meets there who is a refugee from Ghana. Although she feels sorry for the guy, she unwisely falls in love with him despite many warning signs that he is not the best boyfriend material. Little does she know that he's also already married and has three children!

This film is 'Oscar bait', as the subject is homelessness and refugees in Europe and it has a reasonable chance to win. However, I found the story and its message to be muddled. In some ways, your heart really goes out to the guy…but he repeatedly also behaves terribly. And, the lady also believes quite foolishly and it makes it more difficult to care about either of them. So viewers might (like me) think that the moral of the story is confusing. Additionally, there are some adult elements that make this one you don't show your kids. I especially disliked seeing the leading lady cleaning up after her mother defecated on herself and felt this scene could have been handled a lot better and not so vividly. Call me crazy, but I don't like seeing images of old drunk ladies crapping themselves.

By the way, this film, despite being Danish, most of the dialog is in English—the only one of the five nominees in English. This is very unusual as most years several of the nominees are American short films.
8 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Only underwhelming if you are too much looking for great depth and messages
Horst_In_Translation9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Silent Nights" is a Danish 30-minute live action short film from 2016. The writer and director is Aske Bang, a Danish actor actually, and it is quite a success for him to get an Oscar nomination while still under the age of 30. Also this film got Kim Magnusson, another Oscar nomination and he is one of the most successful in recent years with the Academy and one piece of evidence of how they really like Danish films in the Live Action Short category. This one we have here also fits in nicely with the big topic of immigrants and refugees that is oh so relevant right now. But what I personally liked about it is probably that it feels really authentic. The film does not try to make a big statement, but tell life the way it is. The male protagonist is not a saint at all. He steals, he cheats, he gambles, he is violent even, even if all this is somewhat excused by how he struggles to fit in and even more so by his sick child. The female is also far from perfect, tends to sacrifice her own life and happiness for others, has unprotected sex with men she barely knows and makes some pretty stupid decisions, but it is somewhat justified by her fear of being alone. So while flawed, the protagonists are likable. Maybe the filmmakers tried to get in too much here with the marriage proposal, the mother's illness etc. into this runtime, but it was still a decent watch and I am perfectly fine with the Oscar nomination. I also liked that it includes scenes with violence between people of different ethnicities and that it does not pretend it's always just the White guys who hate the Black guys. Worth watching, even if I prefer the actual winner (Hungarian) from the Oscars. If you wanna see "Silent Nights", get subtitles if you aren't fluent in the Danish (or English) language.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The worst short to be Oscar nominated in a decade
JohnFilmfreak25 September 2017
I love short movies, and have an annual tradition of watching every short nominated for the Oscars each year. However, this entry was so bad, it has got me wondering if the time has come to stop. Because this film is so abysmally dreadful, that it's painfully obvious the award has absolutely nothing to do with quality any more.

I won't go into much detail about the hamfisted way the filmmakers tries to jam their message down the viewers throat, as other reviewers have written more than enough about that.

But even if you were to take all the clunky propaganda out of the story, and focus instead on the actual filmmaking, you'd still be left with absolutely atrocious craftsmanship. The acting is bad, the directing is bad, the editing is bad and the soundtrack is bad.

But worst of all, is the screen writing. I mean, COME ON! How is it possible to write such drivel, and not have anyone punch you in the face? The only explanation I can think of, is if the screenwriter is five years old. And indeed, there are many scenes in the film which support that theory, most notably when a grown woman brings a grown man home to her apartment, and actually starts running around a Christmas tree singing children's songs! WTF? It felt like it was supposed to be a remake of the Tom Hanks movie Big (1988), where a kid has his body transformed into an adult, but still has the mind of a child. And as fun as that might have been, I'm pretty sure this was not the filmmakers' intention.

Rather, it's just a political piece about a subject which people are so terrified to debate, that they will celebrate an excruciatingly bad film in fear of what someone might say of them if they dared point out what utter trash it is. YUCK!
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Insanity
monkbot28 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
It wants to be a love story about a refugee and an aid worker but it unintentionally ends up being a story about an international criminal conning a mentally handicapped woman into having his baby and giving him tens of thousands of dollars. I wanted to walk out and I honestly wish I had.
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Propaganda
peterbergestein26 February 2017
If you lived during oppressive regime like a soviet block was, you would recognize propaganda movie on 1000 yards. On our equivalent site of movie ratings this has 20%, here its just voted up by blind liberals etc. It is a bad film with bad story and obviously its main goal is political agitation. In the end it completely backfires because people are getting fed up of this.
23 out of 41 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great Performances But Mixed Message
Michael_Elliott26 February 2017
Silent Nights (2016)

*** (out of 4)

A Salvation Army worker finds herself falling in love with a refugee from Ghana even though it means her relationship with her mother might fall apart. Soon as her love begins to blossom she learns a secret about him.

SILENT NIGHTS comes from Denmark and for the most part it's a nice film that contains some very good performances. With that said, there's no question that the message it's trying to give is quite mixed to say the least. The film is about refugees who come to a new country in hopes of making money for their families and we deal with that subject as well as some of the abuse they receive. The film certainly wants to preach about how people should be helped yet the refugee here does some questionable things to where it's somewhat hard to fully like him. With that said, the film is good for what it is and the two lead performances make up for any flaws in the story.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
either so good it is bad or so bad it is good
mrdonleone27 January 2022
There are lots of conflicting messages here: first of all, exceptions don't make the rule. Secondly, the political message of the movie, very left-wing, almost increasing insanity to vote for their party. That is just plain sad. Finally, as movie the thing is fine but only if you'd recognize that romantic movies are just plain nonsense; unless you'd want values to disappear in the West. Altogether, this movie is either so good it is bad or so bad it is good.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed