Carpinteros (2017) Poster

(2017)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Perfect Film
gavin694213 September 2017
Julián Sosa (Jean Jean) finds love and a purpose to living in the last place he imagined: Najayo prison in the Dominican Republic. Through an invented sign language from one prison to another he encounters Yanelly (Judith Rodriguez Perez), separated by 150 meters and dozens of guards; he attempts to win her love while keeping it a secret from her dangerous ex-boyfriend.

First and foremost, the film and its creators must be commended for use of the actual prison locations. The prison in the film is dirty, grimy and we see what passes for a "good meal" is not particularly appealing. The Najayo Women's Center of Correction and Rehabilitation across the way appears slightly nicer, but make no mistake that this is still a prison. In fact, some of the "actors" in the film are real-life inmates.

What makes the choice of filming even more astounding is how not that long ago it was considered one of the worst prisons in the western world. One inmate in 2009 said, "There were people sleeping on the floor all over the place, men sleeping standing up like animals. It was hell." And then you have the case of Rolando Florian Feliz.

In May 2009, Florián was killed by a prison official during an altercation in the yard. Florian, drunk and unarmed, had been shot eight times. The investigation of his death turned up evidence that Florian had been living a luxurious lifestyle granted by the prison staff. Florián lived in a set of cells that had been joined into a single apartment. He enjoyed the use of electric appliances, including air conditioning and a refrigerator. He had fully furnished rooms, including a personal collection of books, paintings, portraits, flat television screen and more. On multiple occasions, guards brought him alcohol and underage prostitutes.

Although "Woodpeckers" is fiction, some of this disparity is addressed, with some inmates clearly getting more privileges than others. Drugs flow freely if you know who to talk to, and even cell phones are smuggled in with relative ease. And then there is the gang factor. In American prisons, gangs are often divided by race; notoriously, there are more Aryan Brotherhood members in the prison system than outside of it. The divisions in the film's prison are more nuanced, with a general distrust between Haitians and Dominicans. I asked the director about this.

Jose Maria Cabral explains that unlike the United States, "I don't think it's a race or class issue; it's more a xenophobia issue. On this small island we're divided by two languages, two cultures, two sides of history and all that becomes really intense when we start sharing space with one another. On top of that the government always uses immigration issues to spread fear in the population. But, as you can see in the movie, all those obstacles are defeated by the main characters through a new language, the woodpecking, stating that not even distance, race, class or background are obstacles for love." The "woodpecking" he refers to here (and in the film's title) is based on reality, and is fascinating in itself. With the male and female prisons separated by a moderate distance, the inmates have developed an evolving sign language. Exactly how it is taught between prisons is unclear, but it is a powerful force. We see entire romantic relationships blossom among people who may never meet face to face or even hear each other's voices. This five or ten minutes a day gesturing is their entire world.

And this dichotomy that Cabral has fictionalized here is so rich with emotion that it succeeds as both a prison film and a romance. (Which is nice, since if it was just a romance it might lose some of the less sentimental viewers.) Dominican cinema is blowing up right now, growing fourfold in the last five years; Jose Maria Cabral is at the forefront of this movement. The evidence is simple: "Woodpeckers" has been selected as the Dominican entry for the Best Foreign Language Film at the 90th Academy Awards.

The film opens at better theaters on September 15, 2017.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A fine example of independent Latin American cinema
jkeen18 September 2017
Warning: Spoilers
While I have seen other Dominican-themed movies in U.S. theaters, this was the first I've seen which is actually set in the Dominican Republic. But the setting is far from the tourist enclaves most non-Dominicans are familiar with.

The movie is set (and was apparently filmed) inside a number of Dominican prisons. For most of the movie it is set in a men's prison which is within sight of the exercise yard of a women's prison. The male and female prisoners in each have developed a sign language for communicating with one another. One male prisoner recruits a new male prisoner to communicate with the first prisoner's girlfriend. The second male prisoner and the female prisoner become attracted to one another and ... need I say that this does not end happily for all? Credit must be given to actors in both lead and secondary roles, and also to the producers and directors for managing to film inside prisons and achieving a high degree of gritty realism. If the Warner Bros. of the 1930s were making a film about the D.R. today, this would be it!

Thanks to the Concourse Plaza multiplex in the Bronx for providing a theatrical presentation of this film.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The best dominican drama genre film so far
EuricSanti9 February 2018
I have always admired the work of José María Cabral, he is the most notable pioneer in Dominican Film industry. But this time he went full international and is awesome.

The filmography, the script, the actors, everything was quite awesome. At first you'll find some over acting, because it was actually filmed with real guards and some real prisoners (which is awesome in a way, because it takes to a reality trip.

No wonder it was the selection for best foreign language film by the academy. If you haven´t been able to watch it, go and do it. At some point you feel like is a documentary about Dominican Republic´s prison system, but while you are involved into the love relation that the two inmates have, is awesome.

The ending, unexpected; a bit predictable the last 20 minutes, but... still you want to make sure is true what you are expecting, because is like... "I think this is gonna happen, but it may go the other way around... I don't know, I will have to wait to the end".

Just watch it and know a little bit more of the Dominican outside the beaches and vacations. The reality of a third world country.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Do you like romantic films without the hyperglycemia factor?
steveo12214 April 2018
I'm reluctant to watch prison films, especially if they are 'realistic'. It is interesting to note that some countries with unimaginably horrendous prison conditions are able to come up with stories that are worth 'getting some on you'. This doesn't go as badly as others in terms of depredations. Do you like romantic films without the hyperglycemia factor? Here y'go. Filmed at the actual prison with inmates making up the supporting cast, the style is 'docu-fiction'.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
reminiscent of UN CHANT D'AMOUR
Henry_Seggerman28 November 2020
Very engaging movie about survival in a squalid prison setting. Intense and deeply emotional. See it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Merits more eyes on it
r96sk5 May 2024
I was hooked!

'Woodpeckers' is a terrific prison flick. I do tend to like movies in such locations, you can create some good drama within such confines. This one is no different, it doesn't necessarily do anything spectacularly unique but it executes the storyline supremely well. The plot moves along at a brisk pace, made so thanks to some interesting subplots.

The acting is very good too. Jean Jean leads strongly, he is supported more than ably by Ramón Emilio Candelario and Judith Rodriguez Perez. The rest of the cast play their parts well too. The way the characters communicate for large periods is expertly portrayed, super well done. Their story comes up big at the end, I like the way they decided to go with the conclusion.

Quality viewing, in my opinion. Merits more eyes on it.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Love in the ruins
dokrauss2 March 2018
Wow. Just wow. What a great movie about prisoners in the Dominican Republic and how they use a self-developed sign language to communicate across fence lines. The stunning Judith Perez plays Yannely, who you really don't want for a girlfriend. Trust me on this. I can't decide if her performance or that of Jean Jean as Julian Sosa is the better because they are both brilliant.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed