The 10s are just ridiculous. Seems like a bunch of people who have never seen anything else but PB. The episode had great moments with the entire Shelby family, especially when Tommy discovers the wall street crash, the pub entrance and the dialogue with the journalist. Two too many cringey slow-motion scenes with weird music in the background. The episode didn't move the story forward enough to warrant a 9 or 10.
What I learnt from this episode? Tommy thinks he's God and orders the murder of a journalist - Godfather style. Linda complains about Arthur's low position in the family to create drama for no reason. Aida is pregnant. The NY SE crashed along with 70-80% of the Shelby Company's shares. Not much insight into the new 'villain'.
43 Reviews
Don't believe the 10s. Don't believe the 3s.
maxglen25 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
This is a really good episode. It's filmed much more crisply and much more sharply and modernly edited compared to previous seasons. This episode despite not having much of consequence happen other than the Wall Street crash of course feels like it's moving at a breakneck pace. But it's not the best episode and I wouldn't even say it's a great episode as I mentioned, nothing (that we know of at least) of great consequence happens here. It feels like they're reintroducing us to the Blinders and setting us up for a much larger scale story than we are used to which was already teased in season 4. Ultimately a decent episode but not a great one and definitely not a bad one. 8 out of 10 from me
Garthy's review
toyandmerchandise26 August 2019
Great at parts
samball-2810425 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
The episode was for the most part a fairly average episode and I felt they were trying to force the cliche on it that "females are strong" by making them outnumber the males for the most part. However the scene between the Tory journalist and now socialist politician Thomas Shelby was very convincing and as per Cillian Murphy performed brilliantly especially in this scene so that adds on a few points and reminded me how much of a fantastic actor he is!
The Wait Is Over
dalefl11 October 2019
I've been waiting for this season for awhile. They weren't sitting on their asses were they? Great episode. They picked up right where they left off. I had to laugh at the misguided soul who said that unions were about flexibility and understanding. That's not what unions are for. But, I digress. Great show. One more thing... Whomever is responsible for plugging that Sabbath in deserves a raise. Brilliant. If you don't know what I'm talking about, think of where this based. If you still don't get it turn off the rap.
It's a ten if you're watching right
shbs-715947 October 2019
There's more than meets the eye....
If you're really watching.
In addition to the amazing actors, plot, dialogue there's a whole layer of artistry to be admired. The heartbreaking arc the horse's body takes upon being shot. The accuracy of the sets (no English wall switches or cords in the "American" living room). The excellent costumes; I've seen that shade of green nightgown from that era in an attic.
The production values are astounding.
In addition to the amazing actors, plot, dialogue there's a whole layer of artistry to be admired. The heartbreaking arc the horse's body takes upon being shot. The accuracy of the sets (no English wall switches or cords in the "American" living room). The excellent costumes; I've seen that shade of green nightgown from that era in an attic.
The production values are astounding.
PB Part 5.1
mtex915 October 2019
Well, here we go again for the fifth time.
I've been an avid watcher of the Peaky Blinders since day one and while this opener wasn't as good as the others, it still was a very good and strong episode.
Has it changed? Yes. Is it understandable that some people don't like the change in cinematography? Absolutely. But compared to all the other shows out there, it's still well above average.
The acting and dialogue were good, although a bit wooden at times. The cinematography is different, but also very refreshing.
On the downside: Too much time was wasted on finding the best camera angles and shots which left the story behind. Since the very beginning, Peaky Blinders has lived from the strong and fast forward moving plot. The plot was there, but as others have already pointed out, the pace was too slow for a six episode season.
I don't mind the new art style from the new director, as long as the plot stays as strong as it was during the last 4 seasons. Hopefully the next episode will have a better balance between the two.
Nonetheless a very strong episode.
8/10
I don't mind the new art style from the new director, as long as the plot stays as strong as it was during the last 4 seasons. Hopefully the next episode will have a better balance between the two.
Nonetheless a very strong episode.
8/10
Great start to long awaited new season.
kmyoutube8 September 2019
I was not dissapointed after the long wait between seasons. Goof... Someone mentioned "The Hollywood Oscars." It's late 1929. Yes the Academy Awards ceremony had already taken place, however, calling the statuette Oscar did not happen until several years after this was supposed to have taken place. Still, great episode.
Good episode, that's about it.
aminrahman-3325828 August 2019
Enjoyed the episode but it felt way too slow for a six episode season. Camera work with the wide angles, the slow motion moments with the musical presence just felt a bit weird and too over the top. Not the greatest premiere.
Wow just wow....
stevepering25 August 2019
Weak Season Opener
toactistolive9 October 2019
This episode lacks the beauty and intelligence that we have all come to associate with Peaky Blinders. The only way such a weak episode is forgivable is if it is laying the groundwork for an amazing season. I'm crossing my fingers that this is the case!
The artsy filming that included slow motion walking, and random angles only works if it is used to exchange a scene; however, I feel these choices were To distract the viewer from the lack of great content. This isn't usually the case for Peaky Blinders. I'm hoping that as the season goes on, this beginning episode is a fluke or there were seeds planted that just need time to grow.
Either way, I have faith in this show and know that even their worst episodes are better than most shows could ever hope for!!!!
It has all become simply embarrassing
matheusmdanjos24 April 2020
It's been a while already since the show started to annoy me with the absolutely exaggerated "style" and the way Polly and Arthur - specifically those two - have become ridiculous cartoon characters.
What they've done to Arthur is basically a crime. The guy was completely turned into the "funny dumb dude" taken out of those stupid American sitcoms. It's EMBARRASSING to watch. Polly acts like she's the queen of England but in the most obnoxious and stupid way possible. Outrageously bad acting by Helen McCrory. She really doesn't know how to portray someone supposed to show elegancy or class, somehow thinking those stupid poses, sunglasses and annoying smoking will do the job. Just try and make it natural, lady, for God's damn sake.
The big meeting scene had me feeling offended by how dumb it was and the scenes with Charlie had me wordless. I really don't know where to begin to describe how bad they were. The kid is like 5 and they're giving him adult lines like "Arthur told me it was God's will, but you're not God!" while throwing something in rage and walking out. Worst acting and dialogue of all episodes so far BY A MILE.
Everything is forced. Everything. Two things about me: I've always loved fashion and have also always been a leftist. Those are facts. Never in my life did I think I could possibly feel annoyed by empowerment of women, by an inclusion of a important black character or by extravagant outfits. Not ever really. Turns out all the three had me rolling my eyes the whole time. It's just not natural. It's there to please dumb folks and it's clear as day. This show is now officially being run by shallow and limited-minded people and I'm out.
2,5/10 because of Cillian Murphy alone.
What they've done to Arthur is basically a crime. The guy was completely turned into the "funny dumb dude" taken out of those stupid American sitcoms. It's EMBARRASSING to watch. Polly acts like she's the queen of England but in the most obnoxious and stupid way possible. Outrageously bad acting by Helen McCrory. She really doesn't know how to portray someone supposed to show elegancy or class, somehow thinking those stupid poses, sunglasses and annoying smoking will do the job. Just try and make it natural, lady, for God's damn sake.
The big meeting scene had me feeling offended by how dumb it was and the scenes with Charlie had me wordless. I really don't know where to begin to describe how bad they were. The kid is like 5 and they're giving him adult lines like "Arthur told me it was God's will, but you're not God!" while throwing something in rage and walking out. Worst acting and dialogue of all episodes so far BY A MILE.
Everything is forced. Everything. Two things about me: I've always loved fashion and have also always been a leftist. Those are facts. Never in my life did I think I could possibly feel annoyed by empowerment of women, by an inclusion of a important black character or by extravagant outfits. Not ever really. Turns out all the three had me rolling my eyes the whole time. It's just not natural. It's there to please dumb folks and it's clear as day. This show is now officially being run by shallow and limited-minded people and I'm out.
2,5/10 because of Cillian Murphy alone.
They got the gang back together
victoriajayne-3328025 June 2020
Season 4 finally hits those not on line and well worth the wait.....amazing pre credit opening inc introduction of young Ruby who will clearly be joining the fabulous band of fabulous snarky Shelby women ...speaking of ..the elevation of Lizzie from office bike to consort is interesting to say the least yet Tommy is still in love with Grace ...the photography ,script and soundtrack is as sharp as ever and the peaky haircut even more unforgiving ...only Tommy and those cheekbones can now pull it off esp now he is in the very murky world of politics ...just fabulous .
Quality first episode!
neonhxed25 August 2019
Damn! What a great start to a new season, and a good return to the show.
madelynmcfly-2027421 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Damn! What a great start to a new season, and a good return to the show. The characters were so good this episode, with Tommy being absolutely cold and badass. I already love the direction that the new season is heading, with most of the characters expressing more and more of their layers. Tommy having visions of Grace is really interesting, and I'm intrigued to see where the show will go with that plotthread. Arthur is definitely evolving, and so is his relationship with Linda. Ada is fierce as always, and I'll admit... I did not predict her romance with Ben Younger. Finn is getting more time to shine, which I like, and I couldn't help but notice... They re-casted Isiah. It's very nice to see Polly in a jovial mood, and Micheal... I'm not entirely sure where his character will go. Side-note, I'm surprised that Anya Taylor-Joy has joined the cast. As for the plot of this episode... Sure, not much happened, but it's a good show that it didn't feel like a problem. The stock market crash is a great place to start the season, and I'm unsure of what Mosley wants. I think Tommy's personal struggles with Lizzie and his children will be interesting to watch, and I think that this episode has some of the best music and cinematography of the show... Great start to a new season.
Just mindblowing
wessamihmaninecassano25 August 2019
Im not god, not yet!
aboalhyjaa26 August 2019
Great start of the season
antoniusmarcus28 August 2019
Why the new director !!
david_a_thompson25 August 2019
Style Over Substance
raccles13 September 2019
Amazing !
sofianeoussaid26 August 2019
Perfection
najehsalah25 August 2019
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
