Tyler and Angel move into a new home only to find two boys, Gabe and Fil, already living there. When they call the realtor to sort out the confusion, they find another disturbing surprise living down below.
Tyler confronts Angel about moving out of the house. But when Angel doesn't agree, she paints a fantastical picture filled with hot guys, ballroom dancing, and chocolate chip cookies.
A handsome unexpected guest arrives before Tyler's worship night at the house. Tyler finds out the hard way he wasn't the only unexpected guest to arrive.