62
Metascore
9 reviews · Provided by Metacritic.com
- 88Slant MagazineDiego SemereneSlant MagazineDiego SemereneBleakness, Arturo Ripstein's film implies, demands different kinds of labor from a man than from a woman.
- 88RogerEbert.comGlenn KennyRogerEbert.comGlenn KennyRipstein, who began his long career working with the maestro Luis Buñuel, has his one-time mentor’s post-idealistic anger but doesn’t adopt an insouciantly ironic mode to filter it through; his perspective is determined but never detached.
- 80Village VoiceLara ZarumVillage VoiceLara ZarumLike his onetime mentor Luis Buñuel, Ripstein favors sparse, naturalistic settings populated by pathetic-yet-zany characters and eschews anything that might be considered traditionally beautiful. Instead, he unearths beauty in the mire of his characters' social conditions and in their dedication to each other.
- 60VarietyPeter DebrugeVarietyPeter DebrugeCertain images...leave lasting impressions, though Garciadiego’s script doesn’t seem to do enough with the story, other than laying it out in linear order for Ripstein to film.
- 60The New York TimesA.O. ScottThe New York TimesA.O. ScottThe film’s enigmas are atmospheric, and somewhat superficial. It solicits the audience’s morbid curiosity rather than gripping our emotions or haunting our dreams. It’s a creepy and beguiling oddity, willfully weird but, at the same time, not quite weird enough.
- 60Los Angeles TimesNoel MurrayLos Angeles TimesNoel MurrayThe grubby melodrama should appeal to adventurous moviegoers — and to the director’s small-but-fervent cult — but even that crowd should brace themselves for something slow-paced and opaque.
- 58The A.V. ClubMike D'AngeloThe A.V. ClubMike D'AngeloNeither Ripstein nor his wife and regular screenwriter, Paz Alicia Garciadiego, succeed in unearthing (or inventing) anything of more than sensational interest from this tragedy.
- 50The Hollywood ReporterBoyd van HoeijThe Hollywood ReporterBoyd van HoeijTruth is indeed sometimes stranger than fiction but Ripstein struggles here to turn his odd collection of two-dimensional characters into real people. What does impress is the gorgeously crisp black-and-white cinematography, which deserves to be seen on the big screen.
- 50New York PostFarran Smith NehmeNew York PostFarran Smith NehmeThe crime and aftermath (based on a real story) are the best parts by far, but these come well after many overextended scenes of selfish, squalid people treating one another like dirt.