The Tree That Saved Christmas (TV Movie 2014) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Not a Christmas miracle but worth the save
TheLittleSongbird23 March 2021
There were quite a few reasons for wanting to see 'The Tree That Saved Christmas'. The title was a little corny but also somewhat appetising. The idea for the story was hardly innovative but sounded cute enough. Lacey Chabert is always a likeable watch, and is no stranger to Christmas films where she has always been watchable. Am someone who has always loved Christmas and has seen many Christmas films as a completest quest for the past year and a half.

While there are certainly far better festive films out there than 'The Tree That Saved Christmas', there are also far worse. Although it may not be a Christmas miracle or classic, and suffers from trying to do too much, 'The Tree That Saved Christmas' is worth saving and watching and is quite charming in its own way. It is one of those films though that one shouldn't expect too much from, and not expect anything that is award worthy. It does serve its purpose quite well on the whole.

Am going to start with the good things with 'The Tree That Saved Christmas'. It looks lovely, especially the scenery which is at its best magical. Lovingly photographed too. The music is nostalgic and has an appropriately festive feel, have seen a lot of Christmas films recently that were overscored and where the music didn't fit but it wasn't an issue here. The direction is more than competent, not exceptional but at least it seemed like they knew what they were doing.

Some of the dialogue is corny, but there isn't the overload of cheese and schmaltz that many other recently seen Christmas films have. It flowed well and is well meaning. Enough of the story was charming and heart-warming and the messaging was relatable and inspiring. The characters had personality and interesting and un-annoying ones at that, finally we have a boss character that was actually likeable. The acting is better than average on the whole, with a charmingly winning performance from Chabert and a particularly strong turn from Jim Thorburn. Nice chemistry between the actors.

However, 'The Tree That Saved Christmas' could have been better if it didn't try to include too much. There are too many plot strands, which makes the story feels over-crowded, and there are a couple of too many loose ends due to not being focused upon enough. Also felt that there were too many characters and some of them are sketchy, while Corey Sevier does decently his character seemed underwritten.

It does tend to be very predictable, there are attempts at doing things differently but with not much unique done with them, with an ending that is too neat and obvious from the title of the film alone. Pacing could have been tighter as well, especially early on.

Overall, inoffensive and sweet but didn't wow me. 6/10
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Every tree tells a story....but will it be interesting?
story_by_corey14 November 2015
Every tree has a story to tell? In this case, Molly Logan and her childhood boyfriend Lucas Bishop come across our subject tree while exploring her family's Vermont Christmas tree farm. The tree is sick and Molly's dad wants to chop it down. Molly bonds to the tree and brings it back to life through her music. After an abrupt and unexplained fast-forward to Molly's adult life, the tree shows up at her posh New York office as a delivery for her boss. Molly immediately recognizes the tree as her long-lost friend and feels compelled to return it back to their home in Vermont so they can share Christmas together. What are the chances of this happening outside of a made-for-TV Christmas movie?

Back in Vermont, Molly discovers the family farm is in foreclosure and Lucas now works for the developer trying to turn it into a "green" golf course. Horrified, Molly gets to work saving the family farm. While the Christmas tree watches all this happen from the homestead living room, Molly's deep-pocket,recently-widowed boss Walter shows up because his kids want to spend Christmas with Molly. A hint of a rivalry for Molly's love ensues between Logan and Walter. Who will win Molly's heart? Will the family keep the farm? Does the tree end up saving Christmas? You can probably guess where this tree's story is going from here.

Un- or underdeveloped characters, mediocre acting and numerous loose ends in the story line turns this tree's saga into something that becomes easily forgettable. Every tree may have a story, but not all of them will be interesting or even well told.
18 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not what I hoped
managementbykristi27 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Wanted her to end up with her boss. He turned out to be a nice guy, had daughters that loved Molly and he bonded with her family.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Nice Film
Christmas-Reviewer18 September 2016
BEWARE OF FALSE REVIEWS & REVIEWERS. SOME REVIEWERS HAVE ONLY ONE REVIEW TO THEIR NAME. NOW WHEN ITS A POSITIVE REVIEW THAT TELLS ME THEY WERE INVOLVED WITH THE MOVIE. IF ITS A NEGATIVE REVIEW THEN THEY MIGHT HAVE A GRUDGE AGAINST THE FILM . NOW I HAVE REVIEWED OVER 200 HOLIDAY FILMS. I HAVE NO AGENDA. I AM HONEST

Lacey Chabert plays Molly Logan, who grew up on her family's Christmas tree farm in Vermony writing stories about individual trees, her favorite being a Charlie Brown Christmas-esque tree struggling to grow. Twenty years later, while pursuing her dreams of a writing career in New York, she learns that the bank is foreclosing on the farm - and that little tree comes back into play.

What is nice about this film is that all actions cause reactions. It also shows that sometimes its "Okay to ask for help". Their also a minor message here about supporting local business's over the big box stores. The film is well made and paced nicely. The film is also family safe and a film you should with your kids. SHown ion the UP CHANNEL NETWORK.
18 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Don't bother watching
msarajoy18 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This is a very strange set up for what I think is a part family and part romance show.

Presumably, Molly's childhood sweetheart must be the male romantic lead, one would imagine, except that for 1/3 of the show, you don't see him at all except as a child and a passing figure in the diner. And turns out, he is not an attractive romantic lead. He comes off as wimpy and as one dimensional as paper. He is expressionless whether happy or angry.

The relationship between Molly's boss, Walter, and his daughters then seem to indicate that the show is set up for Molly to end up with her boss instead seeing as how he came all the way to see her (to oblige his daughters whom he didn't even take the trouble to shop for at Christmas) and then seeing Molly with his daughters, one would think, ah, there's the new Mommy right there because they adore her and vice versa.

And then Walter bonds with Molly's parents, turning to her mother for parenting advice and he even works with her dad on the tree farm all the while going on and on about how wonderful Molly is (so do his kids).

It felt like the writer couldn't decide who the romantic lead was in this show and like the tango, the viewer has to make some pretty sharp turns on the subject. Lame attempt to turn the focus when Walter says "I'd be proud to have you as my daughter." I choked on water. They did NOT look like father and daughter sitting outside the house whilst he was comforting her. It was a very sweet moment that could have ended with a kiss.

Continuing with the strange, what is with the stretch limo going up and down the farm dirt road? It started to feel like the President had come to visit. And why was Lucas always dressed in such a sharp looking suit when he is living and working in a small town struggling to stay alive?

When Lucas professes his undying love for Molly, it's like eating eggs that taste like rubber. Unbelievable. They spent like 5 minutes reconnecting the entire show! Undying love? Hey did we miss out on a huge chunk of the show? We saw more relationship building between Molly and her brother Ryan (!) than between Molly and Lucas. Rubber eggs.

Aesthetically, Molly looks much better suited to be with Walter, her boss than Lucas, her childhood sweetheart who looks so young, he should be the boyfriend of one of the daughters (minus the suit of course)! Very disorientating watching this show.

And this level of disorientation leads straight from the title. There is mention of the tree at the start and then it starts to magically buzz or jingle in her bosses home and then nothing more from the tree other than passing mention at the end. So much for the tree that saved Christmas.

And finally, I don't know what kind of sense of conclusion we are supposed to feel at the end. Nothing has changed with their financial situation!

They are still in debt, just to a different party. It seems like a horribly irresponsible way to live. To be sentimental and refusing to let go when they are so heavily in debt. That did not leave me with a feel good feeling.
10 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very nice!
ssimeonidou110 January 2021
I liked this film very much! It's not the usual story.... Lacey Chabert is excellent again, the cast was very good, the photography, the setting and the story was well written. I especially liked Jim Thorburn as the boss of Lacey. One of the few times that the boss isn't a jerk! His acting was great, his chemistry with his "daughters" felt real wich makes me wonder why they don't give him the leading role??? He is charming, good actor and very good looking.... The characters in this movie interact in a relatively believable manner and the scenery is amazing with lots of Christmas notes and spirit of hope. I will definetery watch this again....
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Save your Christmas and Stay away from this one.
gehewe14 December 2016
Our family loves Christmas movies. This one failed the doze test big time- most of us fell asleep. We will never watch it again. It was painful.

We like Lacey Chabert and hope they give her a good Christmas movie. This movie failed. There were just too many tangents to the main story line. We liked the man who played the father (Lacey's). The mother's role just didn't work. Happy to see Ashley Newton from Heartland. Probably there were just too many characters. What should have been the climax of the movie was left to a note on the tree. Very little true emotion in this movie.
8 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Heartwarming story of fresh hope and love
jagough4919 December 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This family-orientated Christmas movie begins like "Silver Bells", that other great Christmas novel and movie about a Christmas tree farmer and a city photographer. It begins with a vignette about Molly, a girl (who wants to be a writer), and Lucas, a boy (who wants to be a photographer) finding ONE Christmas tree in the girl's family's tree farm, and choosing it to be "Molly's tree". But the tree is spindly, and growing too close to the farm access-road. It is about to be cut down – "weeded" – to give other trees room to grow. Molly saves it, just in time, binding its saw-cuts with tape and tree-balm. Twenty years later Molly (played by Lacey Chabon, the former youngest child in the TV series Party of Five) lives in New York, still writing quirky, unpublished short stories, working as an under-appreciated gopher for a workaholic publisher, a widower who is neglecting his two young-teen daughters. Used as an occasional baby-sitter, the daughters really like Molly. Meanwhile, back in Vermont, Molly's parents have been struggling with hard economic times, fallen behind in payments on a second-mortgage on their Christmas tree farm, and the ruthless, embittered local bank manager is scheming with money-grubbing developers to foreclose, and destroy the farm, to make an Eco-friendly golf resort. Nasty man. His son, Molly's old school friend, gave up his dream of photography to work for his father. But when Molly and her brother (now an architect) come home for, possibly, the last Christmas on the family farm, Molly's banker-photography ex-friend realizes he should never have broken up with Molly, and the loss of the tree farm will damage the whole community. Meanwhile, also, Molly's New York boss comes to Vermont because his daughters prefer spending time with Molly than spending the holidays in a tropical paradise resort. The scene is set for the local community to be rallied by Molly and her brother, for old emotions to rekindle, for a knight in shining armor, and for … Like the best family Christmas movies, this is predictable, sentimental, romantic, and full of satisfying happy endings. It may not be among the truly GREAT Christmas movies, but it is certainly (in my opinion) a good one that will stand years of re-watching!
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Few Steps Above The Typical Christmas Drama
tabuno22 December 2021
This predictable Christmas drama surrounding a threatened tree farm unfolds in a rather intriguing fashion. There is the stern and unempathetic employer. There is the mean Scrooge-like banker. There is the broken romance. There are even the boss's young daughters. What is somewhat different is that the movie magic comes not from a fantasy miracle, but the eventual realism of the practical value of family and social connections. This movie also includes some nice emotional moments even as the movie at times has some rough, edged scenes. Overall, however, this Christmas movie stands out from the typical movie genre with a good effort with a refreshing production using script and scene selections that challenge the typical mold. Not a classic, but worth a one-time experience.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed