I started out excited about this movie. It seemed to be a little different than Hallmark's typical and boring formulaic fare. (Notice how you rarely see a HM movie rated above 6-ish?) The male lead was great. He was likable, genuine, real. Very good and would like to see him in more HM movies. The Nantucket backdrop was great (though we saw very little of it, at least we saw lots of boats.) The bookstore was pretty and inviting and the side-kick Alice was pleasant. Plus, it was great to see TWO pregnant women! Both Alice and the lead male's sister were pregnant. Refreshing!
At first I liked the female lead. She seemed a little different, but cute and pleasant. Sadly, her persona changed and she became unlikeable. So much so that I don't know how or why the male lead could be attracted to her. I'm not familiar with the actress, and maybe the director coached her to be this way, but I found her dull, emotionless, boring. She rarely registered anything other than a blank stare. I think the movie might have had more spark of life to it if she was played with more personality, or by a different actress. Also, what was with the retro wardrobe? Shirts tucked at the front and left untucked everywhere else? That look is at least 15 years old. Come on, Hallmark. Get some better hair, makeup and wardrobe people.
Also, the name of the movie didn't make a lot of sense and no doubt confused viewers as much as the characters in the movie.
Overall, this could have been a really good movie. REALLY good. If not for the lifeless performance of the lead female, the creepy aunt, and the bizarre, poorly-written scene after the book club members review Dylan's book, each of which dragged it down. It could have been so much better. It seems Hallmark never gets it right. I'd love to see them hit a couple out of the park. I don't suggest holding your breath.