Christmas with the Chosen: Holy Night (2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
17 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
The music, the messages and the drama are all excellent and seemed Spirit-filled to me.
actsverse15 December 2023
Never posted a review here before and this is more a response to another negative review. If you are expecting a two-hour movie this is not it. But if you want to view a meaningful, well-produced Christmas event, this works very well.

To those who have seen the previous Chosen Christmas specials, maybe this will disappoint because there is (mostly) material that has been shown before in one form or another, but apart from that, the music, the messages and the drama are all excellent and seemed Spirit-filled to me.

Since the choice of Amanda Jenkins as one of the speakers was criticized by another reviewer let me counter that by saying I thought she hit a home run. Her content and delivery was perfect.

In a sea of near endless garbage and darkness that flashes across movie screens, it is great to see something filled with so much goodness.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
It is a variety show ..
mbleacherjtw17 December 2023
I've been reading other reviews from people who obviously didn't listen to the creators talking about the event. It's two short films with a collection of Christmas music event. It's not a "film". It's a Christmas presentation based on the wildly successful series, The Chosen.

Of course there are previews of Season 4 and of course they're going to try and raise some money to stick it to Hollywood. People got to get paid to feed their families. The first 3 seasons were free!

I can't believe people saying they walked out in the middle of scenes and songs that brought me to tears. Maybe they should watch some Hollywood garbage instead of something so pure and full of Love.

Want Hollywood? Pay them. Want good Christ in Christmas entertainment? See this event and bring an unchurched friend. Or two!
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect
Cgourmet24 December 2023
Music is so uplifting . After losing my mom I needed to hear joy. This filled me. This gave me hope. I didn't expect anything more than to feel again for at least a while. And I did. This is spiritual. This is religious. And it is warming and wonderful. I feel sad for those who were expecting a traditional form of storytelling and felt the need to write mean things. I was told by so many this would sooth me and that's exactly what it did. The voices are just wonderful. If you need some calm this season - or any time- and you just need to feel connected to something bigger than you this will do it.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful , Worshipful Christmas experience!
small-pamela15 December 2023
This is a Fathom event and very well done. The movie itself is less than an hour. A highlight are the seven orchestras and bands performing Christmas music! Well know artists perform including Andrea and Matteo Bocelli singing "Oh Holy Night". Utterly incredibly beautiful! The Christmas story is tokd through the eyes of Mar the mother of Jesus and poor and humbled shepherds. Another feature are the two monologues that explain the reason and details of making this Christmas movie; it is a completely edited and remastered and restored rendition of The Messengers and The Shepherd. Christmas with The Chosen: Holy Night truly offers an enriching Christmas experience that will bless you!
5 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Disappointing
terryflynn-3428514 December 2023
I loved the Chosen Christmas Special last year but this year there was little new. The intro by director Dallas Jenkins, the Bocelli performance, Season 4 trailer, monologue by Amanda Jenkins, and flash forward with Mary M and Mary (Jesus mother) was new, but almost everything else was a repeat from last years special including the musician performances (other than Bocelli). . Why was the monologue done by Amanda (directors wife)? Why not a recognizable and much loved cast member? I wasn't particularly wowed by viewing on the big theatre screen either. It would play just as nicely on home theatre TV's. Sorry but this performance just didn't do it for me.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent Production
dave-7332518 December 2023
It was exactly what I expected based in the description and my wife and I enjoyed it immensely.

Be prepared for a modern church service with uplifting music, information about what's happening within the 'church' (Angel Studios), a sermon, mini-movie and closing music.

For those who didn't understand that going into the theater, it's unfortunate some of you left before the mini production of Joseph and Mary's trip to Bethlehem and search for a place to stay as well as the Shepherd's story.

If you have a chance, it is well worth your time, just understand what you are going to see and sit back and let it soak in.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Exceptional instance classic sans music part
regina-pontes21 December 2023
Christmas With The Chosen will instantly become a new Christmas Classic! I personally cut to the chase and fast forwarded to watch The Shepherd and The Messanger movies interwoven. It was SEAMLESS & INSPIRING. It had it all; past, present & future. All of Dallas Jenkins projects related to this The Chosen effort have been truly divinely inspired. You can literally see and feel it. Goosebumps galore! 👏🏿👊

So glad it was on Amazon Prime so I could get directly to the movie. 😀 Even though I'm a liturgical musician I wasn't interested in the co-mingling of the genres in this instance. There's a time and place to play holiday music but this is not one. I rated 9 out of 10 for that very reason. Fast Forward first 28 minutes and go back and listen at another time.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Holy Night
sharlhill24 December 2023
The wonderful truth about this movie is it's focus on what Christmas is all about...the birth of the Christ child. The night sky effects where the shepherds were mesmerized watching the host of Angels knowing that something miraculous was taking place for all humanity to praise throughout all generations for the common folks and people of all classes and backgrounds is what is so humbling and fulfilling. This miraculous birth took place in common surroundings and not in a five star hotel is what was so beautifully portrayed here. The message is clear that Christ, the savior was born for all men as the three powerful kings came to a humble area to behold the Christ child...King of Kings and Lord of Lords.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Amazing experience
pamjrodriguez18 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
If you want a typical movie experience, this will NOT be for you.

This was my first Fathom event and first Chosen special in theaters. I loved it! I usually do not like to watch music videos but this was amazing because it was an opportunity to worship! There were at least eight music videos that performed wonderful Christmas and worship songs by various music artists.

If you have seen previous Chosen Christmas specials, you may not like this since they mentioned it was a combination of who specials which I thought worked well together.

If you want a different experience from your typical movie screening, this is for you!
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Not What I Expected
msmnm-0982517 December 2023
The intro was the director and wife who ended their annoying dialogue with a nod to a QR code for special deals to be found on an on line store.

Then, the director gave a long over explanation about the film that seemed almost apologetic.

Next, his wife provided an equally long, casual sermon connected to the birth of Christ in the most confusing, round about way.

A slew of Christmas carol and Worship music videos were then delivered in every genre found on the radio. All good, but weirdly inserted. Starting with a Southern rock style version of, 'Go Tell It On the Mountain."

The musicians were all very good, but after 45 minutes it was hard to enjoy the music with distracted thoughts of mine wondering when will the film begin.

I left after the third video to pick up my vehicle, it was being serviced nearby, and walked back in at the start of the actual film!

Great acting, but far too short. It was choppy with an abrupt and disjointed end - more like a series of movie trailers.

The Boccellis followed-beautiful. Would have made a good ending, but..,,,No! Another quasi sermon !

Not to be outdone, more music videos, including a Kennedy Center like stage pile up sing along of all the musicians . One or two more music videos followed before the credits rolled.

That rendition of a traditional Christmas carol was remarkable!

All in all, should have been left as a series with a Christmas music special of songs inspired by and from the series.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A New Christmas Tradition Watch
brandencruz-9249824 December 2023
"A young mother labeled impure. A shepherd boy considered "unclean". A never-before-seen performance from Andrea Bocelli highlights seven music performances and two beautiful new monologues."

I don't get all the review-bombing here considering all the features were spelled out in the tag-line.

Overall, I really enjoyed the films and the musical performances. Even the speaking/monologues were great. I felt they provided great natural breaks to the film that added a different pacing that I really enjoyed.

The messenger has such a unique feel given that it is a short film from years before the show's release. If I didn't know Shepherd & Messengers were separate films, I never would have noticed given how perfectly the two are woven together here. I found it to be an amazing and accurate portrayal on the Christmas story without feeling like an under budget rendition of the virgin birth.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
I was ready to walk out
hello-3870318 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I came to watch the story of Jesus and little did I know what I was coming to see. The Jenkins family (director) and his wife talked way too long to try to tell us why they did this and how it will make you feel, and the story of the story behind the story. Then... made it more a video clip of musicians for most of the 'movie'. Mrs Jenkins I was ready to walk out with you going on and on. Worst experience in the cinema. Finally when the story of Mary & Joseph started it had my attention and sadly that didn't equate too much of a story other than her being pregnant and then giving birth - that is it - oh and more music clips.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
The worst film I have ever seen in a theatre!
chadlegaldefense16 December 2023
I don't frequent the movie theatre and I hadn't been for years. The last film I saw in the theater was the mule and one of the return of the jedi movies. I have to say I could not have been more disappointed with this film, if you can call it that.

My girlfriend/fiancee died last month and I have been trying to connect with religion and I thought I would take our 6 year old daughter for an uplifting experience in all this sadness.

Should have picked something else because we ended up sleeping through a good portion of it, it was so long on blabbing and so light on substance that we couldn't have been any more disappointed.
6 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Tell me when it starts
somedoobie17 December 2023
Took my dad to see this tonight. Movie started at 6:30 pm with the typical 20 minutes of previews. First up, a recap of The Chosen series, then two more movie trailers, then three music videos, then a recap of the first three days of creation, followed by two more music videos, followed by us leaving the theater. I made the mistake of not reading the previews before going to see it. I was hoping for a nice Christmas story and instead felt like bible camp. Some other reviews said that the movie wasn't even an hour long. I mean, we know how it ends but we could have done without the music videos and bible lesson.
5 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Missed the mark. In a bad way.
Not-a-bad-0427518 December 2023
Warning: Spoilers
First off, I will say I am a big fan of The Chosen series. But here's the problem. This was billed as an awesome combination of The Messengers and The Shepherd. As I am familiar with both, I agree, this sounds great. In fact I bought tickets for my whole family thinking this would be a lovely Christmas experience, like going to a living nativity.

Now, the movie itself was great. I would have given it 9 stars. But the rest of the "production" was filler. I don't know if they were trying to give you your money's worth or what. But they didn't need to. In fact, the movie itself was probably 1:30. That's PLENTY. Ok, so for the fillers, I pull my review down to a 6. The music videos on the front end went on for too long. After the 4th one, my family is like "is this all this is?" Guys, I'm losing them. I enjoyed a couple of the videos, but geesh it went on forever. And the dudes at the end singing opera in tuxedoes. I was tapped out. And then, they had to add even ANOTHER one during the rolling credits.

So now you may wonder why I pulled it further all the way down from a 6 to a 1. It was the speeches. First it was Dallas and Amanda telling how excited they are for what we are about to watch. Then it was Dallas telling us, "there will be tears. It really came together nicely." I'm down to a 5. Then there was Amanda before the movie on the Jordan, and one of the writers after the movie at the dead sea. Both of these speeches were completely contrived. So contrived that I cut the last 4 stars.

You know when you listen to a qualified biblical preacher, and he consults the bible, and puts it into words that really touch your heart, and you feel that feeling of awe and amazement, and conviction, and JOY overtakes you, and a tear wells up in your eye? Yeah, it's as if Amanda loves that too, and she covets what the preacher does, and wants to do that to too. But unlike a qualified preacher that frames the word of God with his words, she framed her own contrived words of "awe inspiring" drivel about the molecules of water flowing blah blah blah. And the whole speech was delivered as if the audience was going to get that joyful feeling. But it did not "work". And there's a reason it didn't "work". Because it was contrived. Contrived with that goal, and not simply letting the Truth of God do the work.

The writer's speech after the movie was in a similar vane. At one point, I even felt like I was being hit with a "cold-reading" technique. Something like, "that dark feeling looming over you that you don't know where it comes from, or maybe you do know."....Ok man. Just stop.

Look, I am not writing this to be harsh. Or maybe I am. I was disappointed in how it came across to my guests and had the exact opposite effect I was hoping for. But I am also writing it to be instructive, that perhaps it makes it back to the team. You need to humble it back down. Take yourselves off the screen. It isn't about you, is it? The ride home from Christmas movie night with my family was not, "how lovely was that"....it was, "what the heck were those speeches going on about?". It was a turn-off, to the point of quite honestly overshadowing the lovely movie completely and entirely.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Horrible
Moviegoer-1944816 December 2023
Please, dont waste your time on this horrible movie. This is arguably the worst movie i have ever seen in my life. This was an absolute waste of money and of my time. The people just yap away and the music is the same as last year. The theater i was at sold 6 tickets. This is a waste of money and i feel bad for those of you who had to learn that by paying for ut. Take this as a warning. Beware of this movie and do not watch this. We need to stop supporting trash like this and get movies that are actually etertaining as opposed to this thrown together hunk of garbage. This movie absolutely sucked.
5 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Short film was decent, but way too short and sandwiched between ads, promos, and music videos
rwithammba19 December 2023
I thought the short film was okay, although the accents are cringe worthy considering the characters are speaking English. If the show/series is in English, just speak standard English sans exaggerated accents, as opposed to English with some supposed Hebrew or Aramaic accent.

The short film on the Christmas story, and the music video by Andrea and Matteo Boccelli were well-acted and the Boccelli and Maher performances were good. Other than that, this is just a waste of time: Dallas Jenkins is pushing season 4, which apparently can only be viewed in theaters and then his wife gives a long sermon on the bank of the Jordan River. In between all of this, there are continuous promos and music videos.

It just was not a true movie.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed