The Matthew Shepard Story: An American Hate Crime (2023) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Remembering Matthew Shepard and the legacy that came after his tragic death
Rodrigo_Amaro12 October 2023
Here's a poignant look back, 25 years later, at the brutal murder of young Matthew Shepard just for being gay and how his assassination by two homophobes changed America's view on LGBT rights, widened the debate about the issue and then a hate crime legislation was signed in 2009.

Almost everything anything I needed to know about the Shepard case I got through the great HBO film "The Laramie Project" which had a stellar cast and it was a very special movie even though the story presented about the details of the crime and then afterwards with the WBC homophobic protests on his funeral makes for a harsh experience to be seen and I never went back to see anything related with, except reading on the internet.

I don't usually shy away from movies of any topic but for a little while I almost decided to not see it. But I got myself into it just to see what more could be added to Matthew's story and it was worth seeing it since it puts into a wider context of our current times and everything that happened, of good and bad, 25 years later after his killing.

And it turned out to be a really great, informative documentary.

For the generation that came after him or haven't heard about the murder in 1998, this is a really important and well-made TV special that presents a little about who was Matthew, as a son and as a friend, moves to the night of the attack and his death a couple of days later. It also covers the media frenzy in covering this murder in Wyoming and how people reacted to it, the whole commotion in showing that LGBT people matter and they don't have to be murdered just because of who they are and whom they love.

But a lot more than the violent act, it's also a story of hope for change, to address issues that weren't fully discussed before and how gay people fought for respect and visibilty, and when it comes to show Shepard's mom Judy creating the foundation on his name to take a legislation to congress against hate crime is that the film finds a great heart in how courageous she was and patient as well, since the bill was introduced in 1999 but only got passed in 2009, after a whole decade being tossed around, vetoed and shut down.

The final minutes is one of those things that you have to brace yourself for a while since it deals with the many challenges faced by the LGBT community after Matthew's death, with the countless political debates over gender discrimination, the local governments introduction of anti-gay legislations, and even hate crimes as well such as the massacre at Pulse nightclub.

It's hard watch, quite sad in many ways but one that is necessary to understand that the long good fight for equal rights isn't over yet, and there's plenty more to be done despite some good progresses that came in the past 25 years. And we came a long way after Matthew's death, we learned a lot, and it's fundamental that people out there hear his story even though as dark and sad as it is. 10/10

In Memoriam Matthew Shepard (1976-1998)
8 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
A Documentary Derailed
taticat16 February 2024
Unfortunately the makers of this documentary have chosen to allot only a portion of the documentary to Matthew Shepard and his story; the second half of this documentary is spent on talking about trans issues, current politics in Florida and Texas, and bringing on a host of random people who have no relation whatsoever to Matthew Shepard's story or life to talk about current political events like how upset they were when Trump was elected, moves to prevent children from taking puberty blockers, and basically everything under the sun that has nothing to do with Matthew Shepard; it's a tragic waste of bandwidth that should have belonged to Matthew.

Matthew wasn't trans. Matthew wasn't politically involved. What happened to him was a travesty, and the whole story deserved more attention than it was given - about thirty minutes. Why the documentary makers didn't let people get to know Matthew as a human being, didn't discuss the perpetrators of this murder, and didn't even try to interview the perpetrators, their friends and family, or the people of Laramie is a strange and negligent decision.

Matthew still deserves his documentary.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
why? Slowly turns into a political movie and less about Mathew
reachamr22 November 2023
Very sad to remake this movie and add nothing new. No new interviews with anyone. No update on autopsy that was released or rumors of drugs and or sexual relations with murders. Very sad to tarnish mathew's name for a narrative. Do not watch. Not sure why this was produced - after all these years people will talk and yet nothing new. Very sad how all the evidence is being suppressed. Mathew rest in peace and let's hope justice will come to those two men. Twenty Years After His Brutal Murder, Matthew Shepard Will Be Buried at the Washington National Cathedral - this could have been covered but was not.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed