Benutzerrezensionen

Absolutely stellar 3 part documentary that was filmed for a decade following Teddy Hart, what a narcissist evil vile lying thieving scumbag. It amazes me how long this guy has gotten away with all of his horrible crimes.

As a documentary it is truly magnificent because the man making this documentary gets sucked into a whirlwind of absolute insane behavior by Teddy.

It gets more dramatic and bizarre as it goes along which makes it super compelling.

I am a huge wrestling fan and that aspect of it was also interesting to me.

I truly hope there will be justice for all of the innocent people that this piece of garbage has destroyed.

10/10.

I viewed this documentary, as I was under the impression it was about Mersh's investigations into the seedy aspects of humanity, dealing with death, murder, rape, and cats. However, I did not receive what I expected; instead I was met with a dreamlike narrative of non-sequitur content, which is extremely engrossing. It is essentially a compilation of stock footage, intercut with interviews that are seemly about subjects unrelated to its title or description.

For an example of the abovementioned dreamlike structure: Early in the first episode, after footage of a forested area with some figures walking about, we transition with sped up footage of a metropolitan area going from night to day, and then are shown a short interview with a fat woman describing her finances. Following this, we cut again to what I can only assume is stock footage and transition again to more stock footage, and again to an interview, this time concerning the dangers of everyday objects. This same scene-transition-interview-scene-transition pattern is followed almost to a tee. Most of the show is--apart from the interviews--unnervingly silent.

Through the ambiguous meaning of this artistic masterpiece, it provides something interesting for all that endure it. I could watch the entire three episode series dozens of times and come away with something different each time.

The most interesting part of this documentary comes in the third episode when, in the last few minutes of the entire show, Mersh is finally shown in all of his glory. His small part in the documentary is especially evocative because of his jovial--perhaps even gay--nature, as well as his gaudy--perhaps even gay--attire. The entire segment featuring him could, and should be, watched frame-by-frame, the viewer making mental and/or physical note of all the nuances in his performance. With his every movement and utterance an entire work comparable to any great artist's oeuvre is produced.

I went into this viewing experience expecting Mersh to appear consistently throughout the episodes, and though I was disappointed by the lack of him in 98.33% of entire series, I nevertheless watched what could be the best short series of this decade. This documentary is a masterpiece of subversive art, showing how even the mundane and unimportant matters of life is, in itself, a story. I applaud Fred Kroetsch and NBC for their bravery in releasing this surreal and enigmatic "documentary" and look forward to what they provide in the future.

Being a fan of wrestling, and in recent years, the Indie scene of wrestling, Teddy Hart's name was thrown around here and there and I never quite paid much mind to him. It wasn't until 2019 that he was in an affair with wrestler Maria Manic, and their YouTube channel was gaining equal parts views and infamy. Then at the start of 2020, an interview on Nightwave Radio (a podcast I have supported since) made me more curious about Teddy Hart. Needless to say, the YouTube channel combined with the discussion from "Mersh" definitely caught my eye.

Once this documentary was announced, I was all in on learning everything known about the self proclaimed "Greatest Wrestler of all time". A guy who used the name of one of his deceased uncles (Owen Hart) as a Patreon Tier when he needed money. A guy who bedazzled a Rolls Royce, who bought pink & black beanie babies at a 7/11 and said on camera that he would sell them as exclusive Bret "Hitman" Hart items.

Watch this documentary though. End the mystery. Try to help find Samantha Fiddler.

The curse of this generation and of modern day documentarians. They make themselves a key component of the subject's life as well as making themselves a key component of their film. The film series is too repetitive. I feel a lot of this is put on for the cameras. Enough with the documentarian saying "I worked so hard on this project". No one cares. It could have been way better if the singular focus was on Teddy's lunatic ways and the crimes he is accused of committing. Much like Tiger King, it's loses. Steam very quickly. It would have been thrown in the heap of stupid reality shows if someone bought it. Not worth watching.

I really enjoyed watching this. Great drama, wrestling, and crime. A very entertaining mix.

Teddy Hart has been on my radar for a few years. He is not a good guy. I am not sure if he killed Sam, but I am sure he could have. I really felt for Sam's family. They seem like genuinely good people and it was kinda hard to see their pain I just hope this does not help Teddy Hart get more bookings for more money. I would hate to think he benefitted from this whole messed up situation.

Also, it was pretty cool to see Mersh in this. He has a couple talk shows, Revenge of the CIS and Nightwave. Both shows are worth checking out.

So I had the fortune of time to watch a documentary and a docu-series this long weekend....and I just had to shake my head at both of them.

Just for reference, I taught documentary film making for several years, I've been working in film, television and advertising for 20 years now. So when I talk about documentaries, I'm not just looking at it for entertainment value as most user reviews. So some of the things that bother me, might not bother you.

First off, knowing some of this was shot over 10 years ago with a minimal budget, the post-production processing is great. The director was moving from news tv to documentary, and he had some nice lighting set ups early on. So many props to him.

The subject matter is stellar. The whole persona and history of Teddy Hart is veryy compelling. He is absolutely a character and that's why I watched the series, because something that unique, even in a bad docu-series is entertaining.

It really all falls apart after that.

First off, the director puts himself into the documentary, which by definition makes it investigative journalism not a documentary. (If you're influencing the film or show and producing it, you simply can't say you're documenting it, you're an active part of it.) I understand this is common. I also understand it can be very entertaining for example, Michael Moore, Kevin Spurlock and recently Matt Walsh. This director, however, is not compelling, rather he's just whining and complaining. He feels sorry for himself more than he assists the story.

If you take out the director, you have a, for the most part, a very solid documentary, however, they went for more money and made a series. So when it feels like it's dragging on, and they're repeating things and giving you information that is pointless....that's because they're trying to fill time. It hurts the product.

Now the main point of the series is the missing girlfriend (Samantha Fiddler), who we don't even meet until 15 minutes into episode 2. Now, with respect, the investigative journalism is lacking. You walk away saying "There's a lot of speculation...but there actually isn't any proof." I'm not defending Hart or his associates, they're pretty crummy, but the girlfriend wasn't a saint and could easily have been mixed up with other people (which is something the director never explores. He seems committed to prove it was Teddy, rather than being open minded exploring different avenues.) So there's no resolution, you're just screaming "What is your obsession with this guy, go look for evidence."

Lastly, I have to criticize the director. This is someone who does not have the personality and leadership traits to do these types of documentaries. He's a sad, dishonest, pathetic person. (My opinion.)

Sad, because he seems more fixated on wallowing in his own self-pity than his documentary. (He literally asks people "Do you think my documentary caused all this?"...dude, get over yourself and do your job.)

Dishonest, because in spite of the fact of his wanting to feel sorry for himself, he certainly seemed eager to get shots of the girls naked and exploit them.

Pathetic, because any producer or director knows, you can't let the talent walk all over you or push things in the direction they want it to go. The director is a pushover. That's why his reality show didn't get made. Executives saw he was weak and despite the compelling subject, they knew he was getting pushed around. That's why there's no evidence of any crime in his footage, because he wasn't asking the right questions, he was just doing what Teddy told him to do. He even admits he was "under Teddy's spell"...yeah because he was so desperate and pathetic he couldn't command the situation.

If you're a wrestling fan, I imagine this is good stuff. If you love crime docu-series and can't find anything else (I would honestly suggest, the first 48 or forensic files before this, but whatever) I can see value. Otherwise, you'll be disappointed.

Also, very strange, but literally in the last 3 minutes they present this one guy and try to make you think he had something to do with the murder. I had to research him, but it was really, really dishonest. They present him like a republican, white-supremacist (maybe he is, IDK, but none of that had anything to do with his involvement.) I watched the podcast they referenced, and he's accusing Teddy Hart of the murder, and frankly doing a much better job at asking questions about the murder than the director of this series and he even lays out evidence. So I kind of feel like the director wanted to put something on him because that podcast was far more interesting this series.

What an absolute misfire. The story telling in this show is so muddled and convoluted. It's like they're just throwing in stuff to fill time. I can see how with the material they had to work with it could have been great, but it has been horribly executed. You had a genuinely interesting story and failed to make something that captures the attention of the viewer.

And that trailer... wow... just bad. Why are you trying to make this look like it's Tiger King when it's so far from it. As a true crime fan, I was very confused as to what the trailer was trying to sell me. I think the trailer perfectly incapsulated the hodgepodge execution that was the series.

As others have mentioned, I had Huge Hollywood expectations of this. I was told this would be the biggest documentary of the year. When I heard my boy Mike Mersh became Hollywood and was appearing in this title, I gave him my entire disability check for the month. I thought Mersh would be appearing in all 3 parts, but instead it was just 3 minutes.

Mersh brought the entire case together though... Noir Mersh brought the entire case together, was really close to having Teddy admitting to the Nightwave Audience he did it. Perhaps if Mersh was featured more heavily, like the time he featured Dough Stanhope, Teddy Hart would be in prison now.

Frederick Kroetsch YOU'RE DONE!

As a long-time Mersh fan, I was personally recommended by him to watch this documentary. I was told he would be heavily featured here and that they had paid him considerable money to star in and promote this documentary. Imagine my shock when I watched this show and there's no Mersh anywhere. As a long time fan and representative of the Nightwave community, I can speak for all of us when I say that we are very unhappy with all the cut Mersh footage. Release all, unedited Mersh footage to Youtube and we will all upvote you. Otherwise, suffer under the 1 star reviews from the Nightwave community!

I invested alot of time watching this 3 part "documentary" (being bored through most of it) all for it to climax with a cross eyed right wing spinster muttering incoherent plugs for his "show" probably no one listens to. Absolute garbage. This entire project could've and should've been left on the cutting room floor of ideas. I always suspected the wrestling world to be......non hetero, but WOW the extent of it surely is highlighted here. Everyone involved seems like a drug addicted nobody doing whatever they can for the smallest morsel of so called fame. Well, i guess take your 15 seconds but this was NOT GOOD.