The Staple of News (2013) Poster

(I) (2013)

User Reviews

Review this title
10 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Uncompromising Tale of Growing Up
l_rawjalaurence20 October 2015
Set in Marseilles and its environs, SUZANNE is a family saga taking place over a quarter of a century involving the eponymous central character (Sara Forestier), her sister Maria (Adèle Haenel), and single parent father (François Damiens). We first encounter Suzanne as a little girl preparing for a dance display; she thoroughly enjoys the experience of performing in front of an audience, but the smile on her face freezes as the jamboree comes to an end. There is something not entirely happy about her existence.

This is a telling moment, as it foreshadows the turbulent progress of Suzanne's development from childhood into womanhood. Her father is a truck-driver, which necessitates his being away from home for lengthy periods at a time. The two sisters do their best to look after themselves, but it seems unsurprising that the adolescent Suzanne should end up pregnant. She subsequently falls deeply in love with petty criminal Julien (Paul Hamy), an affair that puts her family loyalty to the test. Torn between love and duty, Suzanne eventually absconds and ends up in jail.

SUZANNE might be described as the antithesis of the growing-up movies of the mid-Sixties, which celebrated the new-found freedoms of the teenage generation. GEORGY GIRL (1966) might be considered an example. Katell Quillévéré's film includes at least one sequence where Suzanne and Julien display that freedom; but it is set within a framework that is decidedly prison-like. Even before Suzanne serves her sentence, she has to cope with life in a series of poky apartments and/or hotel rooms, all of them dingily furnished. Hence it's hardly surprising that she should desire some form of escape through love.

As the narrative unfolds, so Suzanne's plight becomes more and more desperate. Yet nonetheless we have to admire her for the way she resists all that life has to throw at her. In the end she achieves some kind of emotional fulfillment, even if her immediate surroundings seem less than prepossessing.

SUZANNE is very much a character-focused piece of work, with the camera being particularly adept at portraying the depth of Suzanne's relationship with Julien and her son Charlie (Timothé Vom Dorp) through tight close-ups and two-shots. The action ends with Suzanne's father driving away with the adolescent Charlie (Jaime Da Cunha) across a bare landscape at sunset to the strains of Nina Simone's "Suzanne" (1969). This is an apt choice of song, drawing attention to the character's virtues and her stoicism, despite everything that happens to her.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Beautifully done, but fragmentary
paul2001sw-115 October 2016
There's a lot to like in Katell Quillévéré's film 'Suzanne', the story of a woman who's life drifts out of control: its great sense of natural warmth and emotion, and the delicate, poignant soundtrack. Credit should go to the two young actresses at its heart. But the film lacks the intensity you might expect in a story of self-destructiveness: it's episodic nature spares us from the gloom of Suzanne's lowest moments in a way that doesn't feel wholly honest and undermines the context of the happier scenes. Another way of putting it is that the film lacks a fixed perspective: we see Suzanne's life neither quite as she sees it, nor as anyone else does. But Quillévéré is clearly a natural talent: she will make great films in future, even if this one isn't quite there.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Some very good moments but too much of a patchwork
edouardmacre18 January 2023
The story: Suzanne (Sara Forestier) is a French working-class girl raised by a loving widowed father (François Damiens) along with her sister Maria (Adèle Haenel). A single mother at a very young age, she meets the wrong guy in town, a seductive petty criminal (Paul Hamy) she immediately falls for. She soon leaves her job to spend more time with her lover, starts to neglect her son... Suzanne's life is about to sink really hard.

The story behind the story: Suzanne is Katell Quillévéré's 2nd film after Love Like Poison (Un Poison violent) in 2010. Since then, she has directed an outstanding drama about heart transplant, Heal The Living (Réparer les vivants).

The pluses:
  • A couple of great (and I mean really great) moments: when Suzanne's son calls her by her name rather than Mum (those who saw the film will understand what sequence I'm referring to), the way she hears of a bad news within her family...
  • Solid acting from lead role Sara Forestier, and even better one from Adèle Haenel as Suzanne's faithful younger sister.


  • Very original if not always compelling storytelling, letting the most spectacular events offscreen and showcasing more mundane but still very evocative moments of Suzanne's life.


The minuses:
  • The downturn to the fragmented & elliptic storytelling I mentioned before: jumping from one vignette to another, I had the feeling of missing too much of the characters' lives & interactions to root for them as much as I should.


  • While the film spans over 25 years or so, the depiction of the 80s or 90s is rather poor: the clothes, the cars, not to mention François Damiens' ludicrous fake hair when he's supposed to be young. This may sound like a detail, but I thought it undermines the veracity of it all.


  • The story is rather interesting, but I'm still not really sure what point Katell Quillévéré wanted to make here (if there was ever a point to be made).


Verdict: Overall, I enjoyed watching this touching family saga, but I felt Katell Quillévéré's unquestionable talent may have been better served with a more focused story such as in Healing The Living.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Family life
dbdumonteil31 October 2014
Warning: Spoilers
No French user has commented this movie yet.It seems that movies which take place in simple milieus do not attract the audience .

"Suzanne" ,although realistic to a fault,has a melodramatic screenplay;the story could have been filmed in the French thirties:the bad gal who plays around whilst her virtuous sister takes care of her family.

But "Suzanne" is a movie of the twenty-first century :its treatment is contemporary ,the director refusing the show .The scenes which would pass for "commercial " are not in the movie :Suzanne and her boyfriend's wrongdoings (and cowardice:assaulting an old lady is not that glorious ),we learn them through her lawyer;when she visits her child in his host family ,the scene is worthy of Bresson:no act of defiance,resignation,she gives him a box of chocolate ,he takes one and that's it:the boy seems satisfied,or worse,indifferent to the situation.

The way Suzanne learns her sister's death is rather spooky :such a scene could be in a thriller!but then again,filming a car crash would have been spectacular .

As her father and her son are driving home,they do not say a word.They are not angry,they are not sad, because they know that love runs in their family .There's no explanation for Suzanne's behavior:her dad is a good man ,the first scene takes place in a cemetery where his dead wife is interred .

This film continues with a tradition,that of Bresson,the Dardenne bros and Kenneth Loach;but it adds a female touch :a sense of decency.

Only one sour note:Cohen's eponymous song does not belong here ;and with a "modern" horrible cover at that!
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
as life itself
axapvov21 May 2023
Excellent tearjerker, presented in episodes of one life (Suzanne's, duh) in the course of many years, from childhood to motherhood, etc... What makes the film special is how wisely those episodes are chosen, exposing a great deal of information in a very effective way for each case, and this is sustained throughout the entire runtime, right until the end. It is effective as we learn both what is shown and what underlies it, with precise cinematic language, and the accumulated emotional charge is never excessive, there is no fanfare but a gentle, deep and steady melancholy. I was engaged and this 90s minutes telling of half a life passed me by like a teary breeze, every scene matters. Researching Adèle Haenel's filmography is a great idea, highly recommended, she doesn't do bad films.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Suzanne-Katell Quillevéré has succeeded in showing the true value of family. It is one of the best French films made in recent times.
FilmCriticLalitRao11 January 2014
Time and again French cinema has made it loud and clear that family is a sacred institution which must not be harmed at any cost. This is the reason why several films based on the theme of family life continue to be made in good numbers in France. Although director Katell Quillevéré's second film is about a girl Suzanne, it is her father Nicolas who is the "real hero" of the film for a lot of sacrifices are made by him. He is the one who sees all the transformations which have taken place in the life of his daughter Suzanne. It is Nicolas who has always been there for Suzanne despite his professional limitations as a truck driver. Belgian actor François Damiens shines in this role as his performance is so rich, natural and incredibly real that one cannot help feeling that in real life too he might be a real father with real children. It is with a lot of subtlety that Katell Quillevéré drives home the message that a family cannot do much for one of its members if wrong personal or professional choices are made. Lastly Suzanne is one of the best French films made in recent times for which if viewers wish to shed some tears of sadness then it must be for Nicolas who plays two important roles for his daughters : a father as well as a mother.
25 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A life in fragments
ReganRebecca5 February 2017
I had heard so many wonderful things about Suzanne and so I went into it with great expectations only to have them dashed.

Suzanne is less of a movie than a series of vignettes. I don't have a problem with unstructured or loosely structured movies, but with Suzanne the movie covers such a broad amount of time (over 20 years) and is so short (90 or so minutes) that it feels jolting to watch as children bloom into adults abruptly with no transitions between scenes.

Loosely, the film follows the Merevsky family which consists of a father and two daughters after their mother dies. The family is working class, and the father works as a truck driver with long absences, but they are close knit. Suzanne is the eldest and she falls pregnant with a son that she raises as a single mother with her family. Sometime later she falls in love with a low-level drug dealer and things go south for the two of them as they can't keep away from one another, nor can they find a more lucrative means of employment.

The acting is very good and director Quillévéré has a beautiful eye for making the movie feel cinematic despite the very basic subject matter, but again, the plot is so scattered and he vignettes go by so quickly it's hard to care.

A missed opportunity, especially with so much talent behind and in front of the camera.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Portrait of a Lady on Fire brought me here...
SimonRocque7 April 2020
Stunning film. I'm speechless. The acting is so raw and present. My heart broke over and over again.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
French cinema is capable of a lot better
Cinebuff387 January 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Let me start by stating that my one star rating is meant to indicate poor rather than awful. By poor, I mean by French cinema standards, compared to its films of years gone by.

Suzanne is about two sisters,(Sara Forestier and Adele Haenel) and their father (François Damiens) who plod along enjoying a normal family life without the company of a mother.

Suddenly, out of the blue, we see Suzanne in court being sentenced for breaking and entering and stealing valuable property.

I had to go back to some points in the film to see if I missed anything and what led to Suzanne committing the crime and if there was a scene of the crime being committed. But no. As far as I can make out, that was totally uninspired. How does someone who appeared to have had a happy go lucky childhood end up being a burglar?! If all this was explained, they must have made a very quick job of it.In fact it was either very quick that if you blink you missed it, or no explanation was offered at all.

I am a huge fan of French cinema, but it would appear that the latest ones pale in comparison to those of yesteryear by such directors as Truffaut, Demy, Rivette,Luc Godard Etc., all of whom have masterpieces under their belt.

The main reason that films with sub titles tend not to get a big audience is that most people don't want to watch a film and read at the same time which is a shame as such films are usually much better than Hollywood and British films by a million miles. Unfortunately, Suzanne is not a good example of this or of French cinema as a whole. Anyone wanting to get into World cinema would be better off checking out those of the 60s, 70s 80s and 90s and perhaps the early noughties because there really are some excellent works and masterpieces out there.
2 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Must see for French cinema lovers
gphgrm0126 May 2020
Well if you don't like French cinema's style, you will probably not like this one either, bit its your loss. Its a really good movie, I loved it. Very human, about a young girl and her sister who lost their mother when they were babies, and who fell into many difficulties of unpredictable, passionate life. Two working class girls and their father love each other enormously, but the life is not sparing them, with all its turmoils.I actually love the script of this movie. While it seems that everything which is happening is caused by the older sister's unfortunate affair, its just simply their honest, simple, non-calculated nature that is ruining all of them, but also give them some strength in difficult moments. I also see why Adele Haenel got the Cesar for the supporting role, her performance is heavenly in this film. All the cast is really good. Corinne Masiero showing up in a small role, for me that is always a plus. I love this. One of the better films of French cinema in the last ten years.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed