Bottled Life: Nestle's Business with Water (2012) User Reviews

Interesting insight into the modus operandi of a food company

[Horst_In_Translation · 6/10 · 27 September 2013]

And as with pretty much every other huge company, it doesn't come even remotely as a surprise that their actions are not only the exact opposite of sustainable, but downright ruthless to the point they could almost be considered illegal. What I liked most about the film is that it also scrutinized the positive efforts of the company such as supplying water to fugitives in Ethiopia or investing into the infrastructure of areas where they target the water supplies.

Apart from depicting how Nestlé operates exactly (obtaining private property and using it to get a hand on the water), the most interesting part was the depiction of how Nestlé changed society in Pakistan and how "Pure Life" has basically become a crucial part of how to define one's lifestyle. It's a truly sad state of affairs when water is considered no longer a basic good, but a commodity and what's even worse is that we've probably reached a point where greed and the desire for profit are so much advanced that it may very well be too late to change things for the better. In any case, the makers of this film succeeded mostly in their endeavor and props to them for being brave enough to go up against a Goliath like this company. And of course, the lack of response from Nestlé speaks more than a thousand words, just like every questionable organization who has a lot to hide. "Bottled Life" is a documentary worth watching.

Blame the politicians too!

[pmshah1946 · 6/10 · 6 September 2014]

I don't have much to say about the documentary itself but quite a lot about the business.

Here in India we had a big controversy about Coca Cola corporation's water bottling business. In Kerala they extracted so much ground water for their purpose that it created almost drought conditions in the surrounding areas on Kerala.

City of Chennai has had perpetual shortage of potable water. A little while ago a million liters per day desalination plant was installed on the outskirts. The total cost of the process amounted to to a mere US$ 1.00 for 100 liters. What is being sold in the market costs around US$0.20 per 1 liter bottle.

I would most certainly blame the politicians too for granting industrial licenses to big time companies, multinationals and local variety, for this catastrophe. If I had it my way I would grant licenses for setting plants only for bottling desalinated purified water at least located at least 100 miles away from any populated area!

Sad commentary on human rights vs. corporate greed.

[iraz · 6/10 · 6 November 2013]

I've seen a number of documentaries on this issue and it underlines how little these large worldwide corporations care about the lives they affect. This is an important documentary about an issue that is life and death for many people.

It actually deserves a slightly higher rating but there are no subtitles and even when an individual is not speaking English, no subtitles are provided. So quite a number of sections of the film are useless unless you happen to speak all the languages spoken in the film. Even many statements from the Nestles CEO are wasted in the film.

Nestles says its concerns are humanitarian, but as evidenced in the film, its only concern is money and making a profit. Once an area is dry, they move on to another area.

A Damning Report On Modern Greed

[dcarroll74 · 10/10 · 7 October 2021]

When I saw the opening few minutes of this documentary, I thought it was going to be a back slapper, and nearly turned it off. I'm glad I didn't.

It turned out to be exactly what I expected it to be, a damning account of one of the greediest corporations on this planet. I wonder if, in the interveining years (I'm viewing in 2021), have they classified air as a foodstuff, and found a way to steal it and sell it?

I would gladly invite them to my country (Ireland) and steal all my water. The only price they would have to pay? Drain Lake Geneva and Lake Constance.

They can leave the rest of their lakes alone, I wouldn't like the Swiss Nation to die of thirst, or burn alive because of forest fires; unlike what has happened, and continues to happen worldwide, because of Nestle's unwanted intrusion.

Flushable

[timlin-4 · 1/10 · 13 November 2013]

I would not be surprised if Nestlé engages in shady business practices or environmental damage, but this "exposé" actually substantiates nothing. Rather than interview hydrologists, lawyers, economists, and whistle-blowers, activists and random people are interviewed. Most just present NIMBY blabbering or rants against "corporate exploitation". Nestlé invested enormous labor into building an organization that produces profits, and that is "unfair". 3rd world countries lack clean water, and it's "unfair" that Nestlé's excellent product costs money. A weak effort to appear unbiased is made by mentioning the jobs and taxes Nestlé generates, though any benefit is dismissed as a capitalist trick. Certainly there are questions raised about water access and corporate taxation, but those are not Nestlé's problems to solve. There are hints in the documentary that Nestlé might be depleting water supplies, undermining the democratic process, etc., but nothing more than hints, because the documentary lacks any reason for being made other than to obstruct business, apparently so that the water can peacefully live underground. Technically, the documentary is mediocre at best, and the director's repeated attempts to get a statement from Nestle are amateurish. Nestle doesn't owe anyone its time, just like it doesn't owe anyone water.

Great Expose

[Paul1984 · 10/10 · 16 December 2022]

This is a great expose, which looks to have been review bombed.

This gets a 10/10 from me for exposing corporate greed. I will never buy another Nestle product in my lifetime and tell everyone I know about their horrible business practices.

If we let these companies succeed then the future is bleak for us as consumers or even as inhabiltants of the Earth.

The fact that they have been taking more than 60 million gallons of water per year from the San Bernardino National Forest, which amounts to billions of gallons of water stolen over the past 68 years. Without any valid basis of right to the water and selling it on for profit, is disgraceful.