Lesson in Murder (2022) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
No lessons learned
soeprijo1921 February 2023
This movie 1st act promised a lot of things. A serial killer got caught, trialled and sentenced to death. But he refused one killing among others. A young law college student was mailed by him and over time agreed to help him. Sounds really exciting for a thriller movie, right?!

But it went downhill after that. The 2nd act especially was the weakest. Unnecessary side plots and characters, confusing characters development and many loose end that made viewers scratched their heads. And don't ask me about the ending, cause it really put the last nail in the coffin. Such a shame, it could have been a great thriller movie.

Disappointing 6/10.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
I wish I could unsee this movie
kagalliano8 July 2023
Warning: Spoilers
There were much more graphic scenes than I expected from watching the trailer, some people even left the theater right after the movie started.

Aside from that, some parts were confusing (why that photo of Eriko and Yamato was among the grandmother's things? Kaoru was the victim who first escaped? She looked like an adult when she was "picked". Wouldn't she be able to identify him?) and it wasn't very clear how police began to suspect that Yamato was the killer.

Overall, the movie kept us on the edge of our seats and had a few surprising plot twists but I wish I could unsee the torture scenes.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Abe's performance was just wonderful
niimiya23 May 2022
The film lacks a sense of reality, as many of the developments are not unlike those of the Japanese justice system. Also, many of the developments are predictable and not surprising, but I still thought this film was great because of the excellent performance of Sadawo Abe in the lead role. Mr. Abe did an excellent job of playing an orderly pleasure killer who skillfully tames abused and emotionally traumatized boys and girls. As an audience member, we were relieved that he had already been arrested and imprisoned in the film, but Mr. Abe's performance was so excellent that even our relief was threatened.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The murderer abdicates his sadism, redeeming himself in the pedagogy of his crimes
figueroafernando14 February 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Risky psychodramatic noir that affords the luxury of playing cards superbly with the spectator's expectations (as is, between bluff and immediately an ace, bluff and aces, bluff and aces), subjecting it to a twisted process of retracting the possible motives or the benefit of the doubt of the serial killer Yamato Haimura regarding the innocence of only one of the 23 victims; The young Ma Say a is the pedagogical coronation of the tired murderer who needs redemption in successors of his nameless crimes, that's why Kazuya dismantles the myths of the sociopath, beats up the stereotype of the serial criminal-Pavlov, you know, the simplification of the psychopath whose " "stimulus" from the past -violent or unfortunate childhood- make him want a ruthless and sordid "response" in the form of a cunning murderer; instead, Yamato admits not knowing why he is sadistic, but also add the social representations of S. Moscovici, it turns out that there is a clear interest in this confessed murderer for the pedagogy of potentially evil children, violent or cruel infants who he has within reach and those he understands, so Yamato's common sense - sick, if you will - is flammable to institutions like the family in correspondence with Mrs. Kirie's Home for Children with Discipline Problems where he worked and encouraged, and he fueled the confrontational and fighting tendencies in the 10-year-old children under his charge, up to the point of flogging between brothers; in fact, Ma Saya himself, too late -but no more so than for the viewer of the film-, will learn that he himself, like Itsuki Kanayama, has been "educated" and manipulated by years of affection for Yamato, not only since he he does the whole investigation again, following the arrest of the asshole, but almost beating the stranger he bumped into on the street to death, not to mention the ending seeing Akari Kano's beautiful nails; Yamato, as if they were his children, almost orgasmically enjoys the teaching of cruelty in his pupils, this is clearly disturbing; That's why from the start, isn't it easier to think that someone wanted to incriminate the perfect murderer, so that Yamato Haimura would be discovered despite the impeccability of his modus operandi? Or why would a competent authority assume that the corpse of 26-year-old Kaoru Nezu -found in plain sight on the defendant's property- is the work of the same criminal who has cajoled, tortured, burned, and buried in his garden the other 23? Victims? I mean, why would the serial killer betray himself by breaking his own pattern of order, almost giving himself away? Unless whoever tortured with germs of mud and moisture, and killed Kaoru with the obvious phobia of bacteria and fungus, was nothing but someone from Yamato's past, that is, a putative son before whom the king abdicates his crown. Sadist, Itsuki; incidentally, in which Eriko, Ma Saya's current mother, is the girlfriend of the murderer and thus, while the plot bluffs about the possibility that the murderer is Ma Saya's father, he hides the letter about the didactics of the pain and the acceptance of cruelty as something natural and inherent in Itsuki and his brother whom he hurt encouraged by the tutor at that time, Yamato. I insist, the open ending, without knowing whether or not he will become a putative son of Yamato, due to the reference to Akari's nails, is the icing on the cake and in any case confirms that the bad guys won, Yamato. Postscript, this disturbing film is too well made, like it was made by someone who has been watching and making movies for at least 40 years. Kazuya Shiraishi has a job, I hope he doesn't waste it.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Solid mystery thriller by the always reliable Kazuya Shiraishi
alain-kapel527 February 2023
A riveting mystery thriller by Kazuya Shiraishi, one of Japan's more prominent modern directors.

It's surprisingly emotional as it proceeds about its plot in a procedural fashion. Lonely teenager receives a letter by convicted serial killer who claims one of the murders wasn't actually done by him. Great premise for a thriller, isn't it? But there's more than meets the eye here. There are complex family dynamics and child abuse present in the background, constantly putting this in a more challenging and demanding territory than if it was a standard mystery.

Shiraishi ably directs this film, giving his actors plenty of opportunities to show their worth, and they do. Kenshi Okada as our protagonist, student-turned-sleuth Kakei Masaya, is capable of holding his own even if he isn't actually the main draw in the acting performances here. That would be Sadao Abe as the chilling serial killer. He steals almost every scene he's in, sporting a lot of charisma but always off as a person like that probably would be. He's alternately sinister and calm, sometimes revealing his utter lack of morality and emotion. Those sequences, often stylishly juxtaposing his image with Kakei's during his prison visits, are the film's most effective.

The visuals are quite atmospheric and appealing too. The overall production value, in fact, is at a high level all around. There's no shortage of style or substance. Compared to another recent Japanese serial killer thriller, Missing, this one is more straightforward, but provides plenty of quality content of its own. The downsides aren't numerous, but one of them deserves a mention, though. That would be the film's insistence on drawing out the ending until it starts souring the film's impact a bit. There were scenes which would have perfectly bookended the story, but they kept on revealing more unnecessary twists and turns. You would hope they'd know better than that.

Overall, though, I was pretty satisfied with this rainy mystery. It's one for those cold evenings with a hot drink by your side. :)
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed