BBC Scotland's comedy Unit has a pretty good track record - with Rab C Nesbitt its shining star - but rarely if ever has it come up with anything as original and subtle as this. The military setting is completely convincing as are all the characters. The officer figure is the only one to be caricatured; all of the others are exactly how one imagines a group of young, often bored, soldiers to be. The story lines are fanciful enough to allow for situations to develop which give full scope for Gary's sense of fun, and his one-liners are terrific. The plots break off from time to time - either for a supposed video clip of the lads fooling about off-duty in Iraq, or for one of Gary's philosophical monologues to camera. When we are accustomed to hearing only West of Scotland accents on Scottish comedy programmes, Gary's Edinburgh accent is a joy. What a pity not all of the cast could manage an east coast accent - Julie in particular leaves us wondering how and why she made the trip east. But that's a minor irritation. Gary Tank Commander is a joy to watch - let's hope we see him again.
5 Reviews
A dram of 'curb your enthusiasm' with a Scotch flavour
gilmoresque9 December 2009
Like all comedy on the edge, it risks alienating those who are fearful of laughing in the 'wrong place'..for those that get the joke, this is as contemporary and topical a treatment as its likely to get...I think those that will write this off, and don't get the funny are sadly unaware how polished this is....there's a lot of subtlety in the writing (and acting)...leaving the audience to get the joke...so much better than having it lazily spelled out....the characters, whilst caricature, are never extreme to the point they are unrecognisable, and their range and purpose are spread wide, covering all bases so that plots can become more farcical, whilst always having a point. There's a lot of dry, sardonic wit, but it never falls into meanness or bullying, with much of the relationships portrayed with affection and camaraderie as you might expect from an army team back from tour. The one-liners are choice, and delivered with a comic timing that double their efficacy. I think there's a strong Edinburgh cadence here, not just in the literal delivery of the dialect and affectations, but also of characters and relationships. Time will tell if this will be difficult for those not from the city, or indeed country, to appreciate. As I write, I am sure that there will be those who will dislike this as much as I liked it. That pleases me somewhat, for, we cannot all like cannedllaughcom-central.
As funny as sticking pins in my eyes
wakster16 January 2020
My god this show is annoying, Gary is not funny whatsoever in fact he's one of the campest soldiers I've ever seen since it ain't half hot mum. I didn't laugh once, but cringed a thousand times at the terrible acting and useless humour.
Ye gods!
Rabical-918 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
'Gary - Tank Commander' has got to be one of the most annoyingly unfunny sitcoms to come out of Scotland in recent times. It has all the entertainment of stepping on an unexploded land mine. Greg McHugh is no actor and the irritating effeminate voice he adopts for the character makes you want to punch him right on the nose. The rest of the cast are dreadful too, most especially Leah McCrae. User 'sanz1820' describes the show as 'subtle and original'. What is so original about a military themed sitcom? Has the user never seen or heard of 'Dad's Army'? BBC Scotland's Comedy Unit should now rename themselves 'The Torture Unit'. After all, 'torture' is the only thing they seem to be inflicting upon us these days.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
