The Nine Kittens of Christmas (TV Movie 2021) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
28 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A warm, cute, and fun Christmas movie...
toddsgraham13 December 2021
Given that 'The Nine Lives of Christmas' is a Hallmark fan favorite, and I did enjoy the movie myself, I naturally was looking forward to seeing this new installment, knowing full well that sequels rarely meet fans' expectations. So, how was it, you ask? This Christmas movie (for cat lovers) checks all the boxes for, what I like to call, a classic Hallmark movie: a warm and cute story with a decent script, strong performances all around, and plenty of Christmas spirit and festive cheer (arguably, it's more Christmassy than the first). That said, though enjoyable, 'The Nine Kittens of Christmas' had less of an impression on me than the first, I'm afraid. Our protagonists in this sequel are again Marilee (played by Kimberley Sustad) and Zachary (played by Brandon Routh). Marilee, who has finished veterinary school and started her own practice since we saw her last, takes some time off to visit her family this Christmas. Zachary, who has been coming into his own at the firehouse, is looking forward to a ski trip this Christmas. His plans, however, change when he finds a box of abandoned kittens. Shortly thereafter, Marilee and Zachary are thrown back together, and then, join forces to search for new homes for the kittens, who are named after Santa's reindeer, of course. And so, our story begins as we watch these two begin to reconnect and rediscover their love for each other. Unlike some viewers, I didn't mind the unexpected shift in the plot at the start or the backstories that set this up. I thought the writers did a decent job of capturing much of the dynamics between Marilee and Zachary from the first film. Moreover, the dialogue and interaction between the two were strong. There were a few noticeable shortcomings, however. The writers could have done a better job of developing Routh's character (Zachary), especially regarding his lack of confidence (in relationships). I enjoyed the bonding between Marilee and Jaclyn (played by Stephanie Bennett); it is clear the writers were keen to develop this. Unfortunately, the inclusion of the advent story seemed forced. There was potential here that was never really developed, I thought. The acting, overall, was strong, and the chemistry between Sustad and Routh was good (believable). Sustad, in particular, had a brilliant performance. It pulled me in. For example, you could feel her struggling with her feelings for Zachary on-screen. Routh had a strong performance, though he could have given us a bit more emotion (and passion) at times. The supporting cast was excellent, and it was great seeing them on-screen together again. And then there are the kittens (aka Santa's reindeer), Ambrose, and Duchess (Marilee's new cat). Very adorable performances all around. The scenes where Zachary and Marilee talk to Ambrose and Duchess are fun to watch. Really enjoyed them. All in all, 'The Nine Kittens of Christmas' is a warm, cute, and fun movie. Maybe not as good as the first, but entertaining nonetheless. A nice new edition to Hallmark's 2021 Christmas movie line-up.
32 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Sequel
Jackbv12326 November 2021
I am not a big fan of redo sequels. The beautiful ending in Nine Lives of Christmas is undone. Marilee is across the country in a relationship with a different guy with whom she is sharing a vet practice. After Zach's beautiful grand gesture in the first movie, somewhere in the 5 years since he got commitment phobia again and now they are no longer together. That saps my faith a little in terms of the chemistry between Kimberley Sustad and Brandon Routh. Oh, it's definitely there,, but it's tainted just a little bit.

If two cats were cute before, two cats plus 9 kittens is even cuter, and they spread that cuteness all through the movie.

The story wasn't bad even if it did use the well worn old ploy of one person misunderstanding what they see.

Both Sustad and Routh continue from the previous movie with great delivery of mumbled comments to themselves or talking to their cats, Sustad especially.

Really not bad for a sequel.
35 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
good enough
montgomerysue28 November 2021
It took seven years for Hallmark to finally show us what ever happened to Zachary and Marilee from one of its most beloved Christmas movies, "Nine Lives of Christmas." Was it worth the wait ? Well, in a way, yes.

The movie starts off with a couple of real surprises that leave you intrigued, and then it goes on to resolve those matters in a very interesting way. Sustad, as usual, is wonderful, and her portrayal of Marilee is honest, forthright, and endearing just like in the original movie.

Routh has matured as as actor and seems more comfortable in his role as Zachary. His scenes with Gregory Harrison as Zachary's mentor/father figure are quite good and realistic. The only problem is the script. It tries too hard to draw parallels to the original story and it contains what I call "filler" - a subplot that is intended to give the actors something else to do - that is unimaginative. Here, it is a silly advent calendar that Marilee's sister "found" after 20 years in their deceased's mother's lake house before it was "finally" sold. It's just uninteresting hokem that adds nothing to the story, which good filler should do. Nevertheless, it is nice to see these two characters back together and there is a really sweet pay off at the end. There's some good "extras" here, too. No one makes an entrance into a scene better than Sustad and here she does it again - this time in a stunning green dress. And keep your eye open for a little cameo appearance by the wonderful Paul Campbell, Sustad's frequent co-star.
16 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Christmas movie with kittens...
paul_haakonsen20 December 2021
Well, upon seeing the cover for this 2021 Christmas movie, I have to be honest and say that I immediately thought that I would be in for a traditional all-out sappy romantic Christmas movie that only Hallmark can produce. Yet, I opted to sit down and watch "The Nine Kittens of Christmas" on the notion that I hadn't already seen the movie, and also I am on a Christmas movie bender this year.

Sure, there were the traditional romantic cheese in "The Nine Kittens of Christmas", just as you'd expect from Hallmark, but luckily it wasn't over-the-top and it wasn't the sole focal point of the movie. So I will say that "The Nine Kittens of Christmas" was actually a nice sort of break away from the usual formula, which made for an enjoyable and wholesome Christmas movie with something for the entire family.

So writer Erinne Dobson actually managed to put together a wholesome script for the movie, based on the book by Sheila Roberts - not that I can claim to have read said book, much less even heard about it.

"The Nine Kittens of Christmas" stars Brandon Routh and Kimberley Sustad, and they actually carried the movie quite well together.

And there is just something about cats in movies that work out so well, so if you enjoy cats and kittens, then you are in for a treat here.

While "The Nine Kittens of Christmas" is not going to become a Christmas classic for me, it is certainly a movie that was well-worth taking the time to sit down and watch.

My rating of director David Winning's 2021 movie lands on a six out of ten stars.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Nine adorable kittens named for Santa's reindeer.
cgvsluis17 December 2021
Our handsome fireman Zachary is back and trying to find homes for nine abandoned kittens and he calls on the help of his former love and veterinary Marilee for help. Marilee just happens to be in town visiting family...her boyfriend who was supposed to come bails on her and they end up breaking up leaving room for a second chance romance with Zachary.

Our two main characters have wonderful chemistry and the kittens, who get named after Santa's nine reindeers, are the most adorable kittens and make this movie.

If you like kittens and miss Zachary and Marilee from The nine lives of Christmas, don't miss them getting their second chance in this Hallmark holiday romance.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The kittens are cute, so is the film
TheLittleSongbird23 December 2021
Haven't seen 'The Nine Lives of Christmas' for some time, but do remember liking it a lot and considering it one of the better Hallmark Christmas films that year. Although Hallmark really do vary when it comes to their sequels, it is always a little more promising when the same leads and cast return in the sequel which helps give continuity. Which is what 'The Nine Kittens of Christmas' does. Also saw it as someone who likes Kimberly Sustad, both as a lead and supporting actress.

While not as good as before, 'The Nine Kittens of Christmas', once you get past the off putting beginning that makes one unsure of whether to continue, turned out to be a worthy sequel and a quite decent film in its own right. Sustad and kitten fans will be in heaven and it is interesting seeing how much Brandon Routh has matured as an actor. 2021 was very hit and miss with its Christmas output and 'The Nine Kittens of Christmas' is one of the high middle ones in my view.

'The Nine Kittens of Christmas' isn't perfect. Wasn't overly impressed by the start, after such a beautiful ending in the previous film it is agreed that the circumstances set at the beginning rather undid it and it was like it didn't happen. It did make me think is this going to be another sequel that messes around with continuity in a mean spirited way.

Did also find Zach less likeable as a character here, here he seemed too passive and his indifference to the emotion spilling out from Marilee towards the end was something of a turn off. Will agree too that the advent calendar subplot was not necessary at all in the story and felt like padding, especially when very little is done with it.

On the other hand, Sustad is truly charming and heartfelt throughout and apart from at the end (which was a character writing thing at a guess) Routh looks more comfortable here. Their chemistry is as fresh and sweet as it was before and it was like the seven year gap had not happened. Gregory Harrison is distinguished support. The kittens are absolutely adorable and hug-worthy, though the film just about avoids sugar overload territory (which could easily have happened when reading the synopsis).

Production values are slick and attractive and the music isn't sickly or melodramatic. The dialogue doesn't come over as cheesy or schmaltzy and has a nice light hearted tone. Despite starting off unsure, the story is immensely charming and heart-warming. Really loved the development of the sister relationship, which was beautifully done and very relatable. The ending did move, namely because of Sustad, if not as much as that of the first. Most of the characters are written well and are worth caring about, the only reservation being with Zach.

In summary, worthy and a decent watch. 7/10.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Nine Kittens of Christmas
JoBloTheMovieCritic11 December 2021
7/10 - this sequel 7 years detached from the original is a nice return to one of Hallmark's best Christmas movies to date, but still can't quite match the quality of its beloved predecessor.
9 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Bad Idea to make this one
hhutton-25800-9772428 December 2021
Absolutely loved the first Nine Lives movie. This one has completely ruined the first one for me. While I love the actors and animals in this one, what is with Marilee being with a different boyfriend in a whole other town? Completely dismantles the love story of the first movie. While I was extremely excited to anticipate the second when I heard it was coming out, I was equally disappointed with the second from the opening scenes. Trying to watch the first one again as I write this, can't enjoy it anymore. Don't do sequels if this is the best you can do.
13 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
So cute
LtlHippo19 December 2021
Love the kitties. This movie had several things going for it. #1 Kittens and cats #2 No "Royal" storyline and #3 None of the overused trio, Candace, Danica and Lacey. Really liked this actress.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A waste
readrer26 November 2021
Ruined the great ending of the first movie. There was no reason for this movie to be made.

If they had continued with a story with the main characters still together it might have had some merit.
22 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Lovely, but not really needed.
adamjohns-4257517 November 2023
The Nine Kittens Of Christmas (2021) -

I'm not sure I can give the best review for this film, because I was completely distracted by the cats and kittens throughout. They were adorable and in my opinion none of them had enough screen time, which was a shame, because we'd actually seen Zachary (Brandon Routh) and Marilee's (Kimberley Sustad) story before.

I didn't actually think that they needed to have broken up for the rest of the story to work anyway. They could instead have been the cupids for another couple who were brought together by adopting the kittens.

However, I could see why they brought them back for another film, because they did work well together and they are at least capable actors. Ambrose, played by Trace, was the best actor of them all however.

I did of course like Brandon for his handsome face, but he needed a better hair cut.

So apart from the fact that they used some really bad fake snow and it probably wasn't totally necessary to make this film, it was definitely one of the better produced ones, as was its predecessor.

710.09/1000.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Purrfect movie for any cat lover.
amandatyke26 November 2021
I was so ecstatic when I found out there was going to be a sequel to one of my all time favorite Hallmark movies "The Nine Lives Of Christmas". Let me tell you.. "The Nine Kittens Of Christmas" did not disappoint. First off, I'm so happy the original leading cast, Brandon Routh, Kimberley Sustad, and Gregory Harrison came back to reprise their roles as Zachary, Marilee and Chief Sam. Also Trace came back the cat who played Ambrose. This is a heartfelt movie that tugs at your heart especially if you're a cat lover. The nine kittens that were in this movie were all adopted into loving homes by the crew members. That alone is a good enough reason to watch this movie. I highly recommend it.
25 out of 31 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
So happy!
nancy-149-4532227 November 2021
I'm so happy for this sequel. Hoping to get a number 3!! The returning characters and adorable kittens helped to make this worth watching. The two leads have so much chemistry.
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Good Enough
PennyReviews27 December 2021
The best thing about this movie is obviously the kittens. They were adorable and gave some cute note to this sequel that was okay, the chemistry was there, but the romantic scenes were few and the whole romantic drama was idiotic. The family dynamics were cute though.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
The nine lives of a romantic escapade.
gfrasmd26 November 2021
Seven years ago, Hallmark produced a cute movie involving two cats. In that, Marilee, a gentle, considerate and loving woman found love with firefighter Zac, who won his commitment-phobia and, like a mountain lion, climbed the highest peak and reclaimed her, his eternal love. It was not a teenager, puppy, love, as both were well into their thirties. Now, Hallmark transport us to five years later, when we find their "eternal" love has lasted no longer than the holidays cheer. For unclear reasons, Marilee had soon moved to Miami, to complete her vet school. She has completely turned the page, started a business and lived for three years with her partner- boyfriend. Meanwhile, Zac has lived in limbo, still chasing his fears, and done nothing to claim her again. Marilee decides to go back home to visit her family for the Holidays and they meet again. With the help of nine kittens, they are ready to rekindle their previous ephemeral story. With typical TV movies logic, she has no qualms turning the page on her three-year commitment and he miraculously discovers the backbone he never had. Christmas movies are magic in that they make us believe there are good people, with all of the qualities we admire and inspire us. In this instance, Hallmark expects us to be idiots, supposed to be moved and inspired by two characters that have proved to be flaky, shallow and and clueless, at best.

Honestly, why should anyone give a hoot about their new fling and how long it is going to last? But...., do not worry, we are likely to find out soon, whenever Hallmark is short of ideas for a new show. With a masterful stroke, Hallmark has managed to ruin the appeal of their former creations, to provide a nonsensical, vapid new chapter. Such is the glory of most remakes. On the plus side, the nine kittens are very cute. Wish they had been given a larger role and spared us the uninspired love story.
30 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The best Hallmark movie in years!
brookenichole-9805428 November 2021
This movie is great! It didn't feel slow and the acting was decent. The romance between the two leads was perfect and cute. And for them to make a sequel that's just as good, if not better, than the first is amazing. Hallmark really stepped it up for this movie. I hope we see more of this in the future!
21 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
I'll pretend this one didn't happen...
bojojoti-971-1301315 January 2022
Don't you hate it when a sequel tarnishes the love you have for the original? Zachary and Marilee's happily ever after is revealed to be temporary when early in this movie Marilee is shown kissing another man. I wish the writers had watched the original. They'd know Sam's wife was terribly allergic to cats and couldn't possible adopt a kitten. And what happened to Jaclyn's four dogs? Were they all euthanized or were they swapped for a daughter? For someone who was as animal crazy as Jaclyn, it didn't ring true that she didn't have pets. I enjoyed watching the four main actors again, but I'll watch them in the original and skip this next time.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This stays on the DVR
bmiller5916 December 2021
WOW, seven years went by so quickly, but I'm sure we didn't watch the first one in 2014 when it was filmed. Being cat owners as we are, this was a must to see, and we loved it. We have a Tortie, and the two Torties in The Nine Kittens of Christmas were so cool looking, Torties do not look the same.

Kimberly and Brandon were great as the leads, no wonder they were brought back after seven years. Great chemistry and Kimberly can make anyone look great.

Sooooooo, does this movie mean there will NOT be a sequel?...we hope not.

Great movie!!!
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
This Is One Sequel That Should Not Have Been Made
clm196215 June 2022
The sequel absolutely ruined the great ending of the original. I was so exited to hear about the sequel and so disappointed when I watched it. Sometimes it's best to leave well enough alone.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Make another one
bwebbga14 April 2022
I waited years for this new Nine Lives sequel and absolutely enjoyed it. It's funny; some things I imagined might happen actually did- others totally surprised me. I love all of the characters.

Keep it going?

Thanks!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Hallmark Became Hollyweird in 2021: This Movie is Everything Wrong With Modern Movies
Dark_Lord_Mark26 December 2021
I LOVED the First Nine Lives movie. It was fantastic, great chemistry, good plot, good cinematography and great supporting cast.

This is an unnecessary sequel to a great movie. It's basically what EVERY Hollyweird property is doing; sequels, remakes and re-quels full of unnecessary forced inclusion and modern sensibilities.

Like all of Hollyweird movies post 2012 or so, it is made to subvert expectations and ruin the original(s). They ruined the first movies happy ending and just had an unnecessary plot where things didn't work out because reasons.

Yeah, not kidding. Just move on with your lives and don't even attempt to watch this garbage sequel.

In 2021 there was no good Christmas movie on Hallmark Channel. I am such a big fan, but Hollyweird has infected Hallmark Channel. It's one less thing I need in my life I guess, at this point.

I am a loyal or was a loyal Hallmark viewer. Heck I am on of the 2 people who respond to every HAllmark Twitter post....or was as of 2021. Goodbye Hallmark.

Not recommended; 3 out of 10. Sorry Brandon, shame this script let you down.
13 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Better than the first one if that's possible!!
smithduke20 February 2022
The Nine Kittens of Christmas made me smile the entire time! Kimberley Sustad is one of my favorite Hallmark actors because she's just so natural, funny, and believable. She and Brandon Routh have great chemistry. Everyone in this movie was enjoyable to watch, and the kittens were adorable!! From the title, you would expect this to be a silly movie but it was heartfelt and romantic.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The cast is great
txharrington9 December 2021
Love the cast and all the cats!!! The sisters are sweet and love hearing their past with the advent calendar. The couple are sweet but just not my favorite movie... just trying to figure out why others rated it so highly but I'm just missing the spark or romance or.... I can't put my finger on it!
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very good, but nothing compares to the first
MickyG33314 December 2022
7.9 stars.

The first of the these two movies was one of the greatest romances I've seen in years, so this sequel had no way of measuring up. I never intended to even conceive it would be as good, and didn't go into it with any expectations of the sort. However, this is still an awesome movie.

Female lead: I love Sustad's quirks and comedic slant on acting, so already she makes this a great experience for me. She doesn't put quite as much passion into this as the first.

Male lead: As usual Routh is great here, and he always has screen presence and decent skills.

Chemistry: theirs is hard to top in this Hallmark x-mas universe. Not as tangible as the first one though.

Supporting cast: Are all really good in this, and it is apparent they have a good sized budget for this film to pay for a stellar cast. Fire chief and wife are great, sister of female lead and daughter are extra special. They actually make this a better experience overall.

Writing, directing, and cinematography: all average for Hallmark.

Music: the usual high quality music.

Entertainment value: the bread and butter of my whole journey with these films is the pure EV. It was not as good as the first one, of course, but it was above average.

X-factor: yes it was present. The special feelings that we get with the kitties, and some of the ambience and general emotions evoked due to the overall chemistry between all cast members.

The end was great, setting us up for another sequel?
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Bad. Really bad
Jennyy219 December 2023
This movie had some incredibly bad acting. Especially from Brandon Routh. Everything he did and said felt super forced and awkward and there was 0 chemistry between him and the woman. Normally I'm a sucker for Christmas romance movies, no matter how predictable, but the only redeeming quality this movie had, were the kittens. If it wasn't for them, I would have stopped watching after 10 minutes. As it was now, I definitely did struggle to finish it. So if I can give you one tip, don't wast your time on this garbage. It's an hour and a half of your life, you're not getting back. Hopefully Brandon Routh will stay out of Christmas movies in the future.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed