"The Closer" Strike Three (TV Episode 2009) Poster

(TV Series)

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
No Way Out
ttapola7 April 2011
This is a counterpoint review. Though at the time of writing, only 3 out of 11 people found the pre-existing review useful, I think there is a need to state why it is not useful. Also, despite an 8.6 rating, this episode is underrated.

Now, the reviewer gives this episode 4/10 and writes, "(Captain Raydor) is unbelievably annoying. Ms. McDonnell portrayal of this character is wooden and one dimensional." He confesses to "fast forwarding through the scenes involving this character". So, how exactly is he then able to form a *proper* picture of the character? Had the reviewer actually listened to all what Raydor says, he might have a better understanding of this episode. Also, "one-dimensional" can only be a *line*, something needs to be two-dimensional to constitute a flat surface.

Why do I consider this episode underrated? It is already a phenomenal 9/10 because it deals objectively with the US legal system's political correctness that has gotten out of hand, meaning that criminals hide behind the very same Constitution that the founding fathers drew and which most Americans consider the very core of what makes America great. But never has it been bluntly stated as clearly as in this episode that the American Dream has become the American Nightmare. This is not just *fiction*. This is a horrifying look into how the American legal system works.

Accidents happen in conflict situations where a split second might make the difference between a police officer's life and death. And in this day and age they all have to consider the possible lawsuits against them if they accidentally shoot the wrong person. Upholders of the law like Captain Raydor have made it clear to them. As a result, they might hesitate and get themselves killed. Thus, criminals have the edge. On top of that, all kinds of fortune seekers look for the opportunity to suck money from the system that is supposed to protect them though money never helps with grief over the loss of a loved one. How will the system protect them if they win in court and diminish the system's budget?

Captain Raydor and Brenda's final scene together is, in its unwavering look at the gargantuan problem, a scene the viewer will be going through in their heads over and over again. It is what earns this episode the tenth star. When those who single-mindedly uphold the law obstruct those whose duty is to administer the law, they are also as a side effect tipping the scales of justice in favor of the criminals. This is not how it is supposed to be. Evil knows how to turn nobility and integrity of Good against Good itself. At the end, you are left wondering, is there no way out? Is the game already lost but Good just doesn't realize it?
43 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great episode
jeff6813720 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Watching nazis go down makes me feel good. They are a disgrace to this country
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I agree
flaysour11 April 2021
With the reviewer who criticized the FID chief Raydor. The first principle of screenwriting is conflict, but it is here taken to a terrible extreme .Maybe since Taylor was neutralized as Brenda's antagonist they wanted another. It wouldn't be so bad if the actress didn't look like she's from the planet Wodenfroz. I assume that the very good McDonnell, whom I loved in Passion Fish and Sneakers, was in a horribly disfiguring accident, and while thankfully completely recovered, needed a face transplant. Seriously, I did not recognize her. NOT saying this to be mean. And while I don't FF her scenes, I look away.
1 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
They're going to hurt this series
Bronco4625 July 2009
The addition of the Captain Raydor character has made watching this show almost impossible. I find myself fast forwarding through the scenes involving this character. This character is unbelievably annoying. Ms. McDonnell portrayal of this character is wooden and one dimensional. It seems the producers aren't satisfied with the criminals being the only adversity for the detectives, they needed to add this character that might have worked out if it weren't for the way Ms. McDonnell chooses to portray the character. This series has a knowledgeable and experienced technical adviser/ producer in Gil Garcetti. But it's hard for me to believe an individual like this could actually survive in this setting for long. Please Gil kill off this character, quickly!!! By the way I give the series a 10, but the two episodes so far, with this character have been a 4 or less. It would be less then that but the regular cast help keep my rating from being 0.
9 out of 54 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed