"Mad Men" Meditations in an Emergency (TV Episode 2008) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The best episode of Mad Men so far
pjgs20015 August 2018
So far, I've liked almost every episode of Mad Men, but there aren't many that really stand out to me. I wasn't a big fan of "The Jet Set," but I think I've enjoyed this season a lot more than the first. This episode in particular was very good, with strong performances, good writing, and great direction. The last ten minutes of this episode were gripping. 8 out of 10
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Best Since "Nixon vs. Kennedy"
borowiecsminus7 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This episode, and I do not say this lightly, is one of the best so far from "Mad Men," and that is a very big compliment, considering the worst of Mad Men is still very, very good.

Everything about this episode works. The episode is premised by the Cuban Missle Crisis, something some of the viewers (not including myself) will remember. It's the perfect way to set up a season finale. A national emergency. Death could be actually around the corner. So the idea is to make haste while your heart is still beating. This creates a rush in the characters and exposes more hidden truths. It signals Don and Betty's iffy reunion, Peggy's outburst (can you call it an outburst?) in front of the priest, and the haste with which Sterling Cooper is bought.

Because of all this, the acting is the best it has ever been (again, SO FAR). And for once, between the three leads, it's very difficult to choose a stand-out performance. Jon Hamm, Elizabeth Moss, and January Jones seem to all be operating on full talent capacity, and I can -almost- say the same for Karthieser (Peter Campbell), but his character, at least in this episode, doesn't require the same amount of grit.

The best episode of the second season and a perfect way to go out until the next.

Over all, the second season is better than the first, albeit not by a lot, and it proves that this is show that gets better, not worse.
11 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Season 2: Emotionally engaging
bob the moo21 April 2010
Shortly after finishing season 2 of this show, I went and reread my review of the first season just to get my head right for doing this one. It was as I recalled – I had liked the show to a point but not to the depth that I had listened to others boast of and it had been interesting but not as engaging as I would have liked. In my review I mentioned that I was watching season 2 of The Sopranos at the same time and it is telling that I have reached season 6 of that show before getting round to watching season 2 of Mad Men – but get round to it I did.

It took a couple of episodes but there does seem to have been some improvements made to the show because this season worked a lot better for me than the first. I'm sure part of it is that I'm already familiar and invested with the characters to some point, but this season does a much better job of engaging the viewer and producing stories and characters that engage emotionally. In terms of the appearance of the show, it is as it was in the first season. The atmosphere of the time is there, with the inbuilt bigotry and sexism of the time and place laid out but this time it is not a matter of these things being whacked down on the table as an obvious thing but rather something that is engrained in everything to a point. Likewise the "times they are a-changing" moments are part of season-long threads rather than specific "look at this" moments in the plot.

All the characters from the first season are here but this time I did seem to care about them a lot more. They all seemed to be used much better than they were and be much more human, which improved upon the situation in the first season where the writing kept the majority of them at the same level as the sets and costumes – important and well done, but still a little superficial in terms of providing more than a bit of colour. This widening of the show and improving of the emotional depth drew me in as it went along and produced some very strong episodes indeed – a nice surprise considering that I spent the first season "interested" more than "engaged".

In the first season I felt the cast were all good and that they were not the ones limiting my engagement in the show, and season two sort of confirms that as they all continue to be good again, just this time with improved material. Hamm continues to be a charismatic focal point and he does well with the complexity of his character and the fact that he is not particularly likable. Moss is my favourite character and her rise within the company is cheering to watch, just as it is contrasted with Hendricks' secret frustration and feelings of losing her worth (she is acting with more than her figure this season). Jones benefits from much better material thanks to the way the plot goes for her. The show is stronger for having better material for the supporting cast such as Staton, Gladis, Batt, Sommer and others, while Slattery and Kartheiser are both good again.

The second season of the show appears at first glance to be the same as the first – the place is the same, the characters are the same, the costumes etc but the writing makes for a much better season as it has more going on that engages emotionally across the whole season.
28 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Season Two
zkonedog4 July 2019
The first season of "Mad Men" contained some of the greatest character drama I had ever seen on television. This second season, while not becoming totally irrelevant by any means, severely lacks the "punch" of that original slate of episodes.

In terms of the overall plot, this second season focuses on pretty much the same characters as the first. Donald Draper (Jon Hamm) is always at the center of things, while secretary-turned-copywriter Peggy Olson (Elisabeth Moss) gets a lot more screen time in this season. Up-and-comer Pete Campbell (Vincent Kartheiser) and dutiful (but frustrated) Draper wife Betty (January Jones) also garner major plotlines of their own. The usual supporting cast is present, augmented by new ad man Duck Phillips (Mark Moses).

The trouble with this season is that whereas the previous season emphasized the period (1960s) and the location (Madison Avenue ad agency), this season focuses almost exclusively on the characters themselves. That first season was just so slick and allowed the viewer to feel as if they truly were living in that 1960s time period. In this second season, though, that period luster seems to wear off in the face of almost a soap-operatic slew of plotlines.

Though disappointed by the sophomore effort of "Mad Men", I'm not giving up on this interesting show quite yet. It still intrigues me just enough to keep clicking the "PLAY" button again and again. In the third season, though, I just hope that the focus shifts again to the time/locale (what I feel to be the hallmark of the show) instead of trying to be strictly about the individual characters.
8 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Ideological entertainment
bridgestone4 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
A season end crescendo is always well written. Most fans will be happy about a soft reconciliation between the Drapers.

What I object to is the Feminist agenda that the producers allow and the writers frantically pursue...

Yes some comparisons can be made in the era but it is constant and the themes by Season 3 have become preachy.

The direction Ms Draper takes is one of an empowered woman with new information so she now has moral leeway to also commit adultery. We had a chance for a real hero to emerge instead we got an obvious plot.

There was no build up of an neglected house wife who develops serious feelings for an acquaintance instead a numb woman sleeps with a stranger within minutes of meeting him. Something her intimacy seeking cheating husband still never did.

No orgasmic experience or shame, its rather useless story telling, just simple juvenile revenge. Instead of employing the right to act as bad as a man how about a story that places obligations on both!

I'm getting tired of the heavy stereotypes, there's no doubt that a Gender studies 20 something is on the writing team with little lived experience.

I'm bowing out and having a break from Netflix.
6 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Surprises
vivianla9 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Betty eyes the cute picture of two young fawns. Her face looks so small and elegant. The doctor comes in and tells her the spotting she had (blood on her pants) was not because of horseback riding. She is pregnant again. The doctor asks her to undress so he can analyze her. This doctor had helped the Drapers with their first two pregnancies. Betty says she cannot have a baby right now and the topic of abortion comes up.

Betty is horseback riding and thinks she sees Don in the distance. It is him - he came back and was there for 30 minutes waiting for her.

The Cuban Missile Crisis has everyone concerned and scrambling. Don watches Kennedy talk with a concern look.

Don strides into the office and people notice but are distracted because of the Cuban Missile Crisis. He wears a cute grey coat and his voice as he greets Tildy, Joan and Peggy is pretty hot. Joan welcomes him back and Peggy perks up and is happy to see he is safe. Peggy + Don are so cute in this scene. Don notices Peggy's new office that is next door and her haircut.

Don has a ton of paperwork to look through on his desk and compliments Peter on his work. Peter came in with resentment towards Don but leaves with good feelings to Don.

The guys try to fix the television as they are watching the news. I like the vibes in this - a group of guys who are silly.

At the end of the episode they wrap the season up well with the topic of pregnancies amidst a terrifying world event.

Trudy is concerned about Peter's safety being left in Manhattan as she goes to join her parents. She leaves him money.

Betty receives an apology letter from Don and Joan lets Don know at the end of the day that his wife called. The whole office is scrambling to get out and there are only a few people left.

Peggy and Peter linger around the office as Peter offers a drink at the end of the day and the windows show a dark sky. Peter tells Peggy how he knows Peggy truly cares and he would have picked her first to marry. Peggy said she could have shamed him into marrying her and announces she was pregnant and gave up the baby for adoption. Peter cannot believe she is serious.

Don goes home to find Betty and they sit down. Betty tells Don she is pregnant and they hold hands. They gaze into each other's eyes and season 2 is done.
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed