Tomie vs Tomie (2007) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
4/10
WARNING: Some of the Other IMDb Comments Here Are Completely Misleading
ebossert24 September 2009
It's very difficult for me to maintain my composure right now while writing this review, because I've never been so misled by IMDb comments as I was with this movie. I've seen Tomie (1999), Tomie: Rebirth (2001), and Tomie: Forbidden Fruit (2002). I disliked all of them, so I never planned to see another movie in this franchise ever again.

Then, I saw the overwhelming glorification of Tomie vs. Tomie on IMDb through both the rating and user comments. After reading the content of the comments, I decided to blind buy this movie online. All I can say is that many of these user comments are completely MISLEADING regarding the content of this movie.

Let me offer some specific examples to support my case, because I honestly could not believe the outright LIES that have been spouted on this website. I'll try to avoid spoilers, so I'll make my statements vague, yet specific enough to compare to the other user comments.

"It's intensive and action packed." This is an outright lie. After a brief, 30-second verbal spat as children, the Tomies don't even meet each other until 50 minutes into the film. There is literally NO ACTION WHATSOEVER for that entire period of time. At that moment, we get the "action", which consists of half a dozen badly choreographed moves. THAT'S IT! We are then treated to another 20 minutes of boredom until the finale, which consists of – get this – a single strike.

"So of course there is a lot of things getting blown up." What a joke. Not one explosion in the entire film.

"The car chases are just fantastic." I kid you not. There is not one single car chase in the entire film. Not even one! "The end climax is the most awesome special effects action sequence ever put together on film." After the one-strike finale, there are two very short SFX scenes involving fire and some blood. However, they are NOT action scenes, just background effects or slight gore enhancers.

"Like 'The Host', but far superior…You are frantically trying to build a picture in your head of what the thing looks like…" Completely inaccurate comparison. There are no monsters in this movie that are even comparable to The Host. Nor are there any monster chase scenes. The only "monster" is Tomie. And if you've seen any of the other Tomie movies, you know what her occasional regeneration is like. (There are only one or two in this movie, by the way.) This reviewer is trying to mislead you into thinking that there's this giant beast that the camera only shows portions of. Not true, at all.

I'm sorry, but many of the current reviewers on IMDb are either Studio Plants who are trying to sell this badly made film by LYING to the general public, or they're fan-boys of the other Tomie films who are attempting to do the same.

I've had suspicions of Studio Plants with various Hollywood films, but I've never seen it so obviously implemented as it is with Tomie vs. Tomie. If it was a matter of subjective opinion, I'd be fine with it. If all 10 of these guys gave accurate descriptions of the film and gave their opinions, I would respect them for it. But making FALSE and MISLEADING statements regarding the content of this movie is morally wrong.

Yeah, you were able to swindle me out of my hard earned money, because there's no way I would have purchased this film without the references to "action packed", "car chases", "explosions", and "monsters" because my gripe with the other movies was the horrendously slow pacing and their overall boredom. I had no idea that I was being lied to. If I knew, I would not have purchased the movie.

I highly recommend that IMDb users disregard most of the glowing reviews of this film, as they are obviously planted.
24 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Yet more Tomie
BandSAboutMovies9 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The seventh Tomie film, this one is directed by Tomohiro Kubo and based on Junji Ito's story The Gathering, which appeared in the third volume of the manga.

For some reason, someone thought that it would be a good idea to inject two kids with the blood of Tomie. This meant that they would grow up into two full Tomies, but flawed as they need the blood of pure Tomies to sustain themselves.

In case you're wondering if this series has gone on too long...

So where does the male love come in? Well, there's a factory worker who is pining over his dead girlfriend and can't move on. Because of that, he won't fall for the Tomies, who soon get angry about why he won't fall for them and they begin to fight one another. You know, when two unkillable women go to war over a man showing no interest in either of them, it isn't pretty.

So yeah, somehow Tomie has moved from being the cannibal queen of a snowy mountain to running a mannequin factory because, well, Japanese horror movies. And as she lurks in the shadows, you know that by the end of the film she'll be set ablaze and probably eat her way through a man's body. Both of these things happen, so if you're a Tomie fan that has stuck around this long - this series is becoming my Japanese Amityville - then you kind of have to watch this. Right?

The subtitles on my copy are beyond bad on this and are barely even intelligible, even renaming Tomie as "rich river." Yeah, maybe they actually make this one better. Or funnier, at least.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Amateur direction
ashfordofficial7 September 2022
1. The eighth installment of the Tomie film series. The story had so much potential but they ruined it with that half baked screenplay with poorly written dialogues.

Even with two beautiful Tomies, this film couldn't escape from it's amateur direction and incoherent storytelling.

2. The eighth installment of the Tomie film series. The story had so much potential but they ruined it with that half baked screenplay with poorly written dialogues.

Even with two beautiful Tomies, this film couldn't escape from it's amateur direction and incoherent storytelling.

3. The eighth installment of the Tomie film series. The story had so much potential but they ruined it with that half baked screenplay with poorly written dialogues.

Even with two beautiful Tomies, this film couldn't escape from it's amateur direction and incoherent storytelling.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Generally inferior
Leofwine_draca5 November 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Another cheapie in the TOMIE series. The twist this time around is that there are two Tomies for the price of one, but for the first slow-moving hour they don't get to meet up, which tests the viewer's patience somewhat. Eventually things improve towards the climax for a few gruesome and icky moments, but generally this is just as cheaply made and uninteresting as the preceding instalments in the series.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed