"Dirty John" Perception Is Reality (TV Episode 2020) Poster

(TV Series)

(2020)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Season Two Review
southdavid30 December 2020
With the first season wrapping up it's story nicely, the "Dirty John" producers have decided to go down the anthology route, with this second season involving entirely different characters, a new story and even a different time period.

Having raised several children together and supported him as he completed both medical and law school, Betty Broderick (Amanda Peet) is devastated when her husband Dan leaves her for his secretary Linda Kolkena (Rachel Keller). As Dan is prominent in the legal community and is Betty's primary financial provider he's able to manipulate the separation and divorce to his advantage, something that the increasingly unstable Betty reacts to badly, beginning a campaign of abuse and damage that escalates to the darkest of places.

Before I talk about the season, it's a little hard to define what the "Dirty John" brand of is actually about. The John Meehan case is clearly one of a profession con-artist defrauding a naive woman, you might anticipate that the series would continue to highlight real life con-artist stories, but instead the Betty Broderick story us much more a case of two people, each of which try to damage the other that escalates to a tragic conclusion for all involved. There's not much of a link between the two seasons.

That said in an of itself this was an excellent portrayal of a marriage that was unequal from day one and the performances, particularly from Amanda Peet are really strong. The series jumps around in time, showing us a younger version of the couple, meeting and starting their lives together, right up to the trial that explains to us early that the story ends in murder. The recreation of 80's technology and fashion is pretty well done and the show does a good job of explaining the nuances of the story, without categorically judging either main character as being "the bad guy" - although perhaps it's better to say that they neither is the "good guy".

Interested to see if a third season does happen, and what story is chosen.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Disappointing follow-up to Season 1
boomer-kris3 June 2021
The Betty Broderick story has been made into a TV series several times already. Having already watched this craziness a couple of times before, this was a rehash. I also remember the actual events, having lived in Southern California at the time.

Betty did a lot of bizarre things during her breakup with her husband, but there was not enough to fill out 8 episodes. I'm hopeful season 3 will be more exciting.
4 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Could've told it in a lot less time and with better acting...
elb1116 July 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I have to say that after watching the whole season 2 (I watched season 1 when it came out) this one had horrible acting considering who the actual actors are or maybe it was the writing, really could be a combo of both, just not sure. I was interested in the story and thought it would pick up the further it went along, but nope! I understood what the story was trying to tell or rather the point it was trying to get across about the mental and psychological abuse she underwent over the years and how it made her how she ended up, and how she felt about her marriage being undermined and her purpose as his wife destroyed by this man she vowed to love etc, all the while he was just using her for his gain, truly from the beginning of their time together, but she was too blind in love to be able to actually see it sadly...but the acting was just as if it was kids in drama club putting it on. I got the message of what was behind the story because I've been in her shoes, except I didn't kill anyone, not saying I didn't want to, I just wanted to be there for my kids more. The positive note is at least the set designers got the clothes, hair and cars right with the era lol, '70s, '80s gotta love the clothes lol. The best part in this whole season for me was the last 8 minutes or so, not because it was the ending, but what actually happened in that time, it was very heart wrenching, she was very vulnerable and it made me cry because I felt her pain. If they do a season 3, I hope its with a different writer and hopefully better acting, at least season 1 had somewhat of a more exciting storyline and the acting was better than this one but not by much.
8 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
If that was abuse...
dierregi5 October 2022
The moral of the last episode seems to be that it's OK to kill people who abuse you, and perhaps it is... when it's real abuse. My point is that most of what Betty considered abuse was such only in her deranged mind. As shown in this episode, Betty got the support of many other women scorned, "scorned" being key word here, not "abused".

Abuse refers to sever mental and physical violence, inflicted willingly. It seems like most of what Dan was guilty of was greed. His actions were motivated by his attempts to improve his life, keep most of the money he earned and go on living with his new love. His actions were not motivated by a desire to inflict pain to Betty. As hurtful it is to be rejected for someone else, younger or otherwise, we've all been there at some stage and the vast majority of us does not act on the impulse of killing the straying partner.

The vast majority learns to move on and think about something else, instead of obsessing and navel-gazing. Despite a huge effort from the writers, I just don't buy into the "poor abused Betty" theory and the pseudo-feminist stance of the victimised woman who did the only thing she could, short of suicide, to survive in a man's world.
0 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed