Dummy (2008) Poster

(2008)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Touching story of 2 boys managing grief
wrxsti5412 July 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Dummy covers the tragic circumstance of two brothers 18 year old Danny (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) and 13 year old Jack (Thomas Grant) whose mother dies of an accidental cancer pain killer overdose. However the situation reveals itself only gradually. The movie begins with a Child Protective Services worker allowing Danny custody of Jack providing he can cope so we first learn they've been orphaned as there is no father in their life. How the mother (Terese Bradley) dies emerges when she and the boys are at their holiday cottage. The family appears prosperous living in a beautiful restored Victorian 4 story terraced house on the promenade in Brighton, England and owning a cottage further up the coast. The CPS lady acknowledges that money is not an issue.

Gradually the dysfunctional ways these boys respond to the sudden loss of their mother unfolds beginning with Jack's denial of the mum's death, lying next to her now blueish body for days until Danny summons a doctor who in turn summons hazmat covered workers to take away the body over the emotional protestations of Jack.

As is not unexpected, the teenage boys can't cope and find their own ways to deal with their grief, Danny is an aspiring DJ and descends into a world of heavy drinking, drug taking and casual sexual encounters and Jack becomes the responsible one keeping the house tidy whilst still at school but he keeps a manikin of his mother dressed in her clothes, daubed in her makeup and perfume with whom Jack sleeps each note. A bit ghoulish and creepy but understandable given his very vulnerable age.

They meet Zoey on the beach, she moves in with Danny initially with Jack's encouragement but soon realizes how messed up both boys are and she escapes. The lack of coping comes to a head when Danny tries to leave for a DJing gig in London but Jack sneaks along and must wait in a room at the nightclub, not a good place for boy his age, and he wonders off. Danny frantically searches for him abandoning his post for which he is fired. Jack is falling asleep at school, realizes he's holding Danny back and reaches out online to an unknown person who persuades him to hang himself and Danny just manages to rescue Jack. Jack calls the CPS and says he'll go into foster care because Danny is too young and too messed up to cope. Jack then has to process the truth which is that his mother overdosed on the pain pills and he is so angry he ditches the dummy over a cliff.

The movie traverses all these extraordinarily difficult situations with a high degree of sensitivity and authenticity. The two teenage boy actors are raw, real and superb in their individual uniquely intense roles aided by the fact that they are the same age as their roles - Johnson has gone on to bigger things but it appears Grant did not despite a most convincing performance. Despite the subject matter, this movie is not maudlin or hard to watch and handles the sensitive subject matter well.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Dummy Is Me
clintstevens15 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I must be a dummy because I found this movie extemely hard to follow. Was it symbolism I didn't get...or bad editing? I was hoping to read a review that would shed some light on just what was going on but there are no viewer or critic's reviews on IMDb.

Basically, this is a tale about the bonds between two brothers and how they cope with loss. The two boys lose their mother who kills herself because she is ill and enduring extreme pain. To cope with his loss the younger boy substitutes a mannequin for his dead mother, but there are scenes of the mother's corpse, so what is it, a dummy or a rotting body laying in bed for what appears to be days? (Wasn't the smell unbearable at some point?) Apparently the younger brother gets involved with a predator online who encourages him to take his life. This subplot did nothing to enhance the story.

The older brother can't carry the burden of raising his younger sibling, so he makes arrangements to have his brother placed in a foster home. He then changes his mind, but it's too late. The younger boy becomes the stronger brother and consoles his sobbing brother, telling him he'll be fine when he leaves with Child Protection Services. At the conclusion, the two brothers walk off into the sunset with the dummy mother. Wow,, WAY too complicated for THIS dummy!

The movie is a tearjerker in spite of all the confusion and is too intense for children. Also there is adult language and a few short scenes of male and female nudity.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Two boys managing grief - exactly
rooster_davis19 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Another review was titled much the same as this one. I have to admit I had a hard time knowing exactly when things were taking place between the dead mom and the dummy. Eventually though I think I figured out the timeline. The older brother Danny is trying to move on but without dealing with his grief, while the younger brother Jack is a slave to it. He can't put his mom's memory to rest. In the ensuing time after she passes Danny tries to look after his brother but their lives don't exactly mesh. Eventually Danny tries to get Jack placed in a foster home where he can be looked after better - which leads Jack to try to kill himself. At that point Danny realizes how much Jack needs him, and also how much he needs his brother. At one point Danny tells his brother that not only is their mom dead but that she took an OD of pills due to her unbearable pain from her illness.

Once he understands better the circumstances of his mother's death, Jack is able to process his feelings and decides to go to a foster home after all, as Danny has decided he doesn't want Jack to go. But Jack does, and we get a glimpse of him in his new 'family', apparently doing all right.

I enjoyed this movie. The roles of Danny and Jack were very well played and the story was engaging.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed