Hollywood Chinese (2007) User Reviews

Both informative and very entertaining

[Michael Fargo · 9/10 · 13 April 2008]

This film, at it's heart, is an expose on America itself and how it both exploits and rewards minorities, ever so slowly adding them to the mix of the American experience. The pay-off's come at the end with frank testimonies from Joan Chen, B.D. Wong, and the amazing Ang Lee. The final topper comes when the multi-faceted (and talented) Justin Lin laughs that once he broke through the Hollywood "ceiling" he couldn't get his films released in Asia because they weren't about white people.

Loads of archival footage surround the interviews (none expressing much bitterness) with Nancy Kwan's beauty ever-shining, she is surprisingly self-aware and candid about the negative stereotypes she was accused of perpetuating. But this is less about the Chinese in Hollywood than America itself: "...as long as you make money" is the creed, no matter how damaging or ridiculous the job.

An excellent doc

[doug-697 · 9/10 · 14 September 2007]

This is a fascinating documentary on Chinese people in Hollywood movies from the earliest silent to present day. From incredible scenes of a silent movie directed and acted by Chinese sisters to the making of Joy Luck Club.

The Chinese actors and directors who talk about the depiction of Chinese people throughout the history of Hollywood talk with intelligence, compassion and anger. They don't hold back, but they are also even-handed. For example, there was resentment that Charlie Chan was not played by an Asian and that he spoke in "pigeon-English". However, they also said that Charlie's family was a very positive representations. The family as a whole was presented as warm and loving, but especially that his son spoke perfect English, was college-education and an Olympic athlete. But then there's Joan Chen describing how she was given a dialogue coach in The Last Emperor to help her speak English with a Chinese accent.

Also in the film, Christopher Lee talks about the Fu Manchu movies and there's a segment which, if you're a Roger Ebert fan, you'll want to see.

Diverse Screen Representation

[Cineanalyst · 8/10 · 26 March 2021]

I'm happy to have found out about this apparently little-seen documentary. It's a concise history of Chinese-American filmmaking and screen representation in Hollywood, as told through talking-head interviews and lots of clips. And, they got the right interviewees--not something I might've once thought needed to be pointed out, but there are too many docs where they just seem to put whomever they can get in front of a camera, it seems noteworthy. So, we get the acting and directing likes of Joan Chen, Tsai Chin, James Hong, Nancy Kwan, Ang Lee, Christopher Lee, Justin Lin, Luise Rainer, Wayne Wang, B. D. Wong, and others and clips from early cinema to 21st-century blockbusters and such notable relevant films as "Lotus Blossom" (1921), those from star Anna May Wong, "The Good Earth" (1937) and many other examples of yellowface, the Charlie Chan and Fu Manchu franchises, Richard Loo playing Japanese villains in WWII features, "The World of Suzie Wong" (1960), "Flower Drum Song" (1961), "Chinatown" (1974), Bruce Lee and Jackie Chan martial-arts flicks, John Woo action movies, "The Joy Luck Club," "M. Butterfly" (both 1993), "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" (2000), "Better Luck Tomorrow" (2002), "Brokeback Mountain" (2005 and even "The Fast and Furious: Tokyo Drift" (2006).

I discovered "Hollywood Chinese" thanks to the notes on the Pioneers: First Women Filmmakers home-video set for "The Curse of Quon Gwon" (1917), credited as the earliest (partially) surviving example of independent Chinese-American filmmaking, as directed by, written by and starring Marion Wong. The documentary's maker, Arthur Dong discovered what remains of the title in the possession of Wong's descendants during his research for "Hollywood Chinese." That alone, of discovering such an important piece of film history, recommends this. Everyone would learn something from it, as at least that 1917 feature hadn't publicly existed for some 90 years, and here it is now on the 2-disc "Hollywood Chinese" set, as well as the Pioneers one.

The debate that emerges among the individual interviews is more interesting than one might find in more-academic writings, too, on topics of representation and yellowface and the nature of acting of inhabiting various characters versus respect of other cultures and political correctness. Rainer, for example, defends her and Paul Muni's roles in "The Good Earth," while Christopher Lee questions his own Dr. Fu Manchu roles, and Hong comments on how he's imitated Peter Lorre's Mr. Moto for some of his grand master type parts. An especially laughable scene revolves around pointing out the different and non-Chinese accents in a scene from "Dragon Seed" starring Katharine Hepburn and other actors from different parts of the world not including China in yellowface. Wong, especially in discussing his homosexuality, and the discussion around prostitute roles like Suzie Wong, brings up some interesting reflection on sexuality and East Asian stereotypes, too. The overall picture is broader than the usual, yeah, the past was offensive, but look how far we've come, although there's some of that, too. More people should see "Hollywood Chinese." It's a good overview and celebration of Chinese-American filmmaking and screen representation. There's even a clip of Roger Ebert yelling down a stupid comment from the audience at the Sundance panel for "Good Luck Tomorrow."

Brilliant --

[JNagarya · 10/10 · 23 November 2012]

Brilliant film history revealing that there was a thriving Chine film industry, alongside -- and outside -- the Caucasian Hollywood film industry. One is angered by the exclusion -- not only because non-white, but also by the casting of others than Chinese as Chinese.

And one is moved by the dilemma of contemporary American-born Chinese filmmakers: Chinese audiences want to see White folks; American audiences want to see Chinese folk -- but from China.

A must for those interested in film history, and larger cultural history, and how money is more important that talent, than life itself.

Not to be missed for those who are held by the view that these sorts of issues are "no big deal" for those affected by them. And those affected by them are all of us.

Before everybody was kung fu fighting

[fablesofthereconstru-1 · 9/10 · 22 June 2008]

Paul Auster wrote a novel about an Argentinian-born silent screen, comic star named Hector Mann called "The Book of Illusions"(published in 2002) that haunted me for days on end after I reluctantly turned the last page. A contemporary of screen legends such as Charlie Chaplin, Buster Keaton, and Harold Lloyd; Auster, with his usual expert cageyness, adroitly blurred the line between fact and fiction, making the reader lose sight of Hector Mann's fictitious non-existence. When the South American slapstick comic actor left Hollywood, he continued to make films in secrecy at his own private movie studio. It was the notion of a film history unbeknownst to the public sector that drove my imagination, like an alternate universe.

In "Hollywood Chinese", the Auster novel came rushing back to my head with an almost visceral immediateness, as this smart, incisive documentary discloses the existence of a Chinese female director named Marion Wong, who made silent films which accurately depicted Chinese-American life at the advent of commercial motion picture exhibition during the early tens. Clips from Wong's "The Curse of Quon Gwon" possess an uncanny look of otherworldliness, like something that shouldn't exist at all. What's truly remarkable about this lost film is that it has value beyond its ethnographic qualities; Ms. Wong was clearly an accomplished filmmaker in her own right.

"Hollywood Chinese" is admirable for its balance in representing both sides of the controversy behind the creative casting procedures that Hollywood regularly carried out in such films as Sidney Franklin's "The Good Earth"(Caucasians playing Chinese) and "The Flower Drum Song"(Japanese playing Chinese). On one hand, there's the reminder that Hollywood is an industry, a business whose only goal is to turn a profit, so it's nothing personal, asserts the interview subjects from this camp, when a Anglo-American actor like Paul Muni puts on a yellow face. But then there's the other camp who take issue with being misrepresented, especially by Japanese actors, for instance, Miyoshi Umeki in Henry Koster's "The Flower Drum Song", especially during the post-WWII period, when the Chinese were subjected to Japanese domination. Although there is anger, most notably by "M. Butterfly"-star B.D. Wong concerning Gedde Watanabe's performance in John Hughes' "Sixteen Candles", the anger is mostly held in check(there is a little bitterness from actress Joan Chen when she recounts her lack of film offers after Bernardo Bertolucci's "The Last Emperor").

The filmmaker shows tremendous restraint in not making mention of the obvious irony behind Rob Marshall's "Memoirs of a Geisha", in which Chinese actors played Japanese actors. Or maybe it's bias. "Memoirs of a Geisha" strengthens the argument that Hollywood is about box office receipts, and not cultural sensitivity, since the casting of Zhang Ziyi and Michelle Yeoh as Japanese geishas was clearly a business-based decision born out of economic necessity. There are simply no bankable female Japanese stars.

Incidentally, Paul Auster co-wrote the screenplay for Wayne Wang's "Smoke". "Hollywood Chinese" is a must-see for anybody who has an interest in cultural studies.

A fine documentary

[gbill-74877 · 9/10 · 15 September 2023]

In this documentary, Arthur Dong presents much more than just a dry accounting of the history of Chinese Americans in film. We of course see the highly problematic early decades, the struggle to achieve authentic representation, and the pioneers along the way, leading in to the films of the (then) present day, but what brings the documentary to life is the collection of celebrities who offer their clearly unscripted commentary. We see a breadth of opinions, sometimes contradictory, and Dong does a great job showing clips that support what is being said.

It's also quite balanced in the sense that opinions are expressed that explain old films in the context of the period they were made, and even though I didn't always agree with some of it, found it refreshingly far from being a heavy-handed polemic. With that said, some of the best bits were the more pointed things James Hong, B. D. Wong, Tsai Chin, Wayne Wong, and Amy Tan had to say. There were many others, and without producing a long list, I'll just say it's always delightful to see Nancy Kwan, who radiates such positive energy.

Speaking of Kwan, I found the discussion on Flower Drum Song 1961 fantastic, as I've always thought it an underrated film for how progressive it was at the time and how entertaining it still is today. At the same time, aspects of the film which were unfortunate are mentioned, like the Chop Suey song, and the casting of a Japanese American (Miyoshi Umeki) in one of the lead roles.

Another great discussion was on the Charlie Chan series of films from the 1930's and 40's, pointing out more than the obvious things like Warner Oland being in yellowface, but how his pidgin speech and silly aphorisms were completely inauthentic to how Chinese Americans speak. At the same time, there are comments about how progressive Keye Luke's character was as "number one son," being intelligent and fluently bilingual among other things.

Many other landmark films are covered, such as Chan is Missing (1982), Joy Luck Club (1993), and Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (2000). There were also great points made about what it means to be a Chinese American actor, needing to take parts to survive, feeling an erosion of self-worth when roles continue to target specific or stereotypical aspects of cultural identity, and how actors coming over from Asia did not have these issues. It's significant that there was almost always a dearth of parts following any major breakthrough.

The very earliest Chinese filmmakers are covered, and Arthur Dong should be commended for having discovered two reels of Marion E. Wong's The Curse of Quon Gwon: When the Far East Mingles with the West (1916) while making this documentary. We hear from Wong's children, as well as the son of James B. Leong, who produced, wrote, and directed Lotus Blossom (1921). Unfortunately after these initial forays and financial disappointments, the equivalent to, say Oscar Micheaux and the "race films" for African Americans did not develop. Dong did a great job in his excerpts and I loved seeing bits from films I haven't seen, but thought he might have also included something from the truly heinous Old San Francisco (1927).

My biggest complaint, however, was in the treatment of Anna May Wong, who is mentioned, but in too small a way for my taste. There was no descendant or biographer there to take her place and speak for her. There are some pointed comments made about the casting of The Good Earth (1937), but there is a surprising level of rationalization for the decisions MGM made. We hear that Anna May Wong got an audition for the part, but not at all the incredibly racist argument that casting director Albert Lewin made, that "despite their ethnicity, they (Chinese American actors) did not fit his conception of what Chinese people looked like." We're kind of left with the impression that Wong was too idealistic in thinking she could have gotten the part, and that she was auditioned and somehow failed. The criticisms of MGM, Irving Thalberg, and Sidney Franklin are "too nice," something which may have been different had this been made in 2023.

On top of it, we have several clips of 90-something year old Luise Rainer, justifying the decision-making - my god, Anna May Wong must have been rolling over in her grave. Frankly, there was also too much of Christopher Lee as well, much as I like him. To hear explaining how much of an ordeal it was to have his eyes being made up to appear Asian was ridiculously off point.

We see Joan Chen (somewhat curiously in my opinion) praise Bernardo Bertolucci's The Last Emperor (1987), and then explain how out of a lack of parts, she had to break with Hollywood and go to Tibet to make Xiu Xiu: The Sent Down Girl (1988). We hear Nancy Kwan and several others say that they were actors and had to take the parts that were available them to stay in the profession. It would have been nice to hear how Anna May Wong faced the very same issues, getting criticized by Chinese American intellectuals and people in Chinese for the servile parts she took, and then broke with Hollywood by traveling to London to make the landmark Piccadilly (1929). It felt like there was an interesting layer of history as well as the debate within the community missing here.

Overall, however, this is a great documentary, brimming with positive energy despite the struggle, and filled with insightful commentary. The accompanying book, published twelve years later, is also brilliant.