Trama

In this Christmas-themed episode, Sam and Dean follow the trail of an "anti-Santa" that abducts its victims by using their chimneys. Dean tries to get Sam to celebrate Christmas like they used to but Sam doesn't want to accept that it could be the last one they'll spend together.—gautamshub

Sam and Dean follow the trail of an Anti-Claus when victims are apparently pulled up the chimney never to be seen again. After a lead goes nowhere, the Winchesters learn the Anti-Claus is in fact a pair of old pagan gods who have assimilated into society and have found a new way of getting their yearly sacrifices. A flashback to Christmas Eve 1991 reveals how Sam found out for the first time what their father really did and where Dean got his gold amulet.—Derfel85

Santa's been naughty this year. Reports of family members getting dragged up the chimney call the Winchester's attention to Michigan, where they try to determine if Santa really does exist, which would allow for the possibility of an Anti-Santa. Meanwhile, Dean decides he wants to celebrate a Hallmark Christmas this year since it's going to be his last, though Sam is very resistant.—Anonymous

One year ago, in Seattle, a man is pulled up the chimney. When two other men are also dragged up the chimney in the present days in Ypsilanti, Michigan, Dean and Sam head to the city to interview their wives. Sam raises the theory that they might be chasing an Anti-Claus, the evil brother of Santa Claus that limps and smells sweet. Furthermore, Sam notes that in both houses there are meadowsweet wreaths bought in the same place. They follow a false lead first, but then they discover that a woman named Marge Carrigan had donated the wreaths to the store and they might be chasing Holdenacar, the god of the winter solstice.—Claudio Carvalho, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

Dean tries to convince Sam to get a tree, presents and a special dinner to celebrate Christmas right, like they did when they were kids. We see flashbacks of a young Sam and Dean in Nebraska on Christmas Eve in 1991. Sam begs Dean to tell him why they move so much and what their father does and when Sam brings up their mother, Dean yells and storms out. That is when Sam reads their father's journal for the first time and learns of the monsters he hunts. When their father doesn't show for Chistmas, Sam is convinced the monsters got him and gives Dean the gift he got from Uncle Bobby, the amulet necklace, to give their dad. In the present time, Sam and Dean investigate an evil Pagan couple and end up tied to chairs in the couple's kitchen. The couple tell them they are Pagan gods and that killing and eating the people they do is their right.