Badland (2019) Poster

(I) (2019)

User Reviews

Review this title
141 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Slow burning western
debsmontague16 May 2021
Deep down this is a love story which was sweet.

The violence is typical of a Western and this is a slow burning story.

The detective is very Rick Grimes in his acting.

If you want to watch something on a rainy day that doesn't need all of your attention or you want something that doesn't need loads of concentration then this is perfect.

No swearing and no nudity.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Low budget oater with starry cast and good action
loloandpete16 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
There is no doubt this is a low budget independent Western. It is evident sometimes in the production design and first and foremost in an often clunky sounding and amateurish script. That it deals in clichés is less troublesome because aficionados of oaters, in which I count myself, not only don't mind cliche in this genre, they positively welcome it. And in this piece, you can tick them off easily, bad guys greedy for land, a corrupt sherriff, backed by an army of deputies, holding down a town by provoking fear with violence, gunfights (complete with close ups of eyes and henchmen who break cover to put themselves in the line of fire) , fist fights, wise native Americans and of course a protagonist that speaks low, speaks slow and doesn't say too much, rather letting his prowess with firearms, do the talking for him. In this role, Kevin Makely is channeling Clint Eastwood all the way down to his cheroot, albeit not as convincingly or as effortlessly coolly. He is the star and essays the role of a Pinkerton detective, sent by a governor, to bring Confederate war criminals to justice, played by respectively Trace Adkins, Bruce Dern and Jeff Fahey. The cast is packed with name actors, nearly all of whom have previous western form and/or make their mark in this one. The big, gravelly voiced country and western star, Adkins, makes an immediate impact in an exciting prologue which ends in a gun battle. Wes Studi brings gravitas to a bounty hunter that is set up as a potential nemesis but becomes a Samaritan, James Russo glowers as a bad guy and Candyman's Tony Todd is wasted in an extraneous role as a senator. Given slightly more to do are Dern and the Oscar winning Mira Sorvino as a father and daughter, the former, part of the hero's quarry and the latter, a romantic interest for the said hero. Both bring depth to the proceedings and manage to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear of a script. Jeff Fahey, too, as an evil sheriff, brings presence in the form of insouciant menace and deadly proficiency with firearms. His finale duel with Makely, refreshingly sees them both hit the deck as they discharge their pistols simultaneously on target. To summarise then, an excellent cast and good action manages to save a poor script. Director Justin Lee is clearly a fan of the genre and makes it all very watchable. Not the best Western you will ever see but it will fill a gap for fellow horse opera followers until the next one comes along.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
B rated. But still enjoyable
grlym-4684911 December 2019
It is a bit slow. Very predictable, but nice to watch nonetheless. I compare it to a hallmark movie
21 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Enjoyable
muchocabrio12 January 2020
I don't understand the poor reviews. Not the best western of all time but very enjoyable.
36 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Don't believe super low reviews. Wasn't that bad.
gonzodave-7929627 April 2020
After reading all of the pompous low reviews I had to review. OK, to start off with, Tombstone, it is NOT. But neither did it have the budget for the actors, good writing, time, etc. But if you can stomach the melodrama, if you can get past the "supposed" proper English of the late 1800s, and get past the cliches (but let's face it, there's hardly anything truly original nowadays), if you can get past these, then it's actually not too bad of a movie. Yes, it's a cookie cutter western, but no, it's not a horrible one either. But if you're into flying hero's, exploding heads and zombies, please stay away from this movie and keep your comments to yourself.
21 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Because dialogue and delivery matters
Troubladore30 March 2020
Have you ever seen someone ride their bicycle straight into a wall for no apparent reason? That's this movie, but in slow motion. You feel awkward watching it happen, you wonder why you're still watching as it happens, and you feel compelled to fast forward through the experience just to confirm, "Yup, they crashed alright."

The death of this movie is the dialogue. The premise was fine, the setting was fine, the actors seemed like they were capable of so, so much more. I literally cannot comprehend how someone can film actors delivering such awful dialogue in the most wooden, uninspired, and awkward ways. I kept watching just because I couldn't believe someone would go to the trouble to create a whole movie like this. Didn't anyone think, "You know, this might play better if we spoke like human beings?" Actors were going in and out of period, the language almost never fit the people or the situation, everything was drawn out without drama.

I actually wondered, at one point, if the whole screenplay had been written by a machine learning algorithm.

Ugh. Skip this movie, forever. I watched it for you, and you didn't enjoy it.
36 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Morality Play
edgardovilas18 April 2020
When I enjoy a movie, I like to read what the haters say about it. No movie is worth a one, two or three unless it is really bad. So don't go by the haters. They say anything just to trash a movie. They act a bit like our president sometimes. The movie does work in the area of cliche, but it also goes to places that are different enough for me to make it enjoyable. The main character is consistent throughout, so much so, that he might lose out on some peace in his life. Plenty of action and credible characters with simple scenic vistas. Well done for a budget Western.
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Slow and sweet till chapter three.. then formulaic.
sparecrow-8778525 April 2020
Although this movie has three western heavies in Jeff Fahey, Bruce Dern and Amanda Wyss. It seems that the movie's heart fell out of its chest after the beginning of chapter three. Too much reliance on a predictable western routine and cliche scenes makes the second half of this movie fall apart. The first half had actual heart and interest, but then it feels like a different movie and forced one at that after the third chapter.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Badland = Good western
markfpiggott8 December 2019
Badland is a tinge of the old spaghetti western mold. Makely plays Matthias Breecher: think Eastwood, Bronson, Stallone and Wayne mixed together. Bruce Dean and Wes Studi provide solid performances. Jeff Fahey and Makely have a great old fashioned shoot out at the end. I'd be willing to buy the dvd.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
More of a "WORSTern" than a western
Wizard-830 March 2020
As you may know, new westerns in this day and age are kind of hard to find, and most of them aren't very good. "Badland" is a western that unfortunately falls into the bad movie category, even for someone like me who really loves the western genre. I knew this was going to be a bad movie when I saw that the Cinedigm company was the distributor, and shortly afterwards when the first scene started to unfold, I instantly saw how incredibly cheap and tacky the production design looked like. But that was small potatoes compared to the real problem with the movie, which was how utterly slow and boring it played out. There's no grit, no energy, and no clear love of the genre. Instead, we just get a collection of various western clichés and dialogue executed in the flattest way possible. The presence of the charismatic Bruce Dern managed to lift my rating to 2 stars out of 10 instead of just one star, but only barely. Not recommended even as a movie to play in the background while you concentrate more on another activity in your home.
42 out of 67 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not that bad a movie
omgakeem10 November 2020
Watched this on Netflix and I enjoyed the movie, just a good western. I didn't think anything was wrong with it. Some good shootouts a good fight or two what more do you want from a western. I thought all the actors did a fine job.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Wow all the hate
schlagzeugplayer10 April 2020
Its not bad, a confederate general , Pinkertons, bad guys want the farm , dialog tries to be in that formal western style, which I like. A sort of wild west victorian . The only thing I noticed was how much the main character resembles Rick Crimes from TWD. I know nothing to do w this but he is a shoe in for a Andrew Lincoln clone. Anyway not a bad western at all. A bit slow but all happens in due time. Wes Studi btw is a cool person to see again. Sure there is some cliches but give it a try. It's not Tarantino but then does it have to be?
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Great Cast!
ghdennis15 April 2020
With so many experienced actors in this film, one would have thought they would tell Justin to "StFU!" and just directed their own scenes. But that ain't what happened in this waste of cellulose. The first black senator was Hiram Revels who took his seat in 1870. So this story had to have taken place after then. Lee could have given a 1866 Winchester to Sorvino and she wouldn't have looked so awkward handling a rifle. Nice lookin horses though and Mira Sorvino definitely put the weight on in all the right places.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Be still, young man
ferguson-61 November 2019
Greetings again from the darkness. Westerns are always a risky proposition for a filmmaker, but some are drawn to the genre and seem to thrive on the intricacies that fans have come to expect. Justin Lee is one such filmmaker. He wrote and directed this film and follows the familiar tropes: a quiet, proud protagonist; the strong, lonely woman; the corrupt gunslinger - maybe wearing a badge, maybe not; and of course, the battle of good versus evil.

Kevin Makely stars as Matthias Breecher, a Civil War veteran and now Pinkerton detective carrying out the orders of Senator Benjamin Burke (Tony Todd, CANDY MAN, 1992). Senator Burke has pledged to track down war criminals and hold them accountable by administering justice. Breecher is the Senator's hired hand who travels from town to town, serving warrants and dealing with those who refuse to abide

Mr. Lee's film is divided into four chapters. Chapter 1, "The General", finds Breecher face-to-face with tough-talking General Corbin Dandridge (Trace Adkins). It's here where Breecher first flashes his impressive gun skills, and it's soon after where he crosses paths with Harlow (recent honorary Oscar recipient Wes Studi), a competitor in the "bounty-hunter" game. Chapter 2, "The Cooke's" has Breecher tracking down Reginald Cooke (played for all it's worth by a finger-wagging Bruce Dern), a sickly old man dying slowly from pneumonia and living with his daughter Sarah (Oscar winner Mira Sorvino). Local bad guy Fred Quaid (James Russo) is trying to seize the Cooke's land (apparently this is the possessive apostrophe in the chapter title). During this segment we get a nasty fist fight, an ugly shootout, and Breecher falling for Sarah and actually shushing his horse. Chapter 3, "The Sheriff", brings us to the terrifically named town of "Knife's Edge" where equally terrifically named evil guy Huxley Wainwright (Jeff Fahey) wears a badge and rules the town with a reign of terror, and with Old West waterboarding. There is even a double-tap grave side shootout. It's an old mining town and the citizens live in fear - especially the good-hearted barkeep Alice (Amanda Wyss). The segment ends with a 'high noon' duel in the dusty street.

Chapter 4, "Breecher", acts as a finale for our hero, a man we are told was "born to violence." His dreams of owning land may have faded, and soul-searching has him reckoning with the man he's become. Mr. Makely reminds of actor Anson Mount in his ability to hold a scene, and we can't help but think that in his younger years, Mr. Fahey could have easily played the Breecher role. Despite the out-of-place linguistic stylings, director Lee proves the lessons of the old west never get old, and it leaves us with the message ... 'Be still, young man."
26 out of 45 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Fistful of dollars
fmwongmd29 March 2020
Written and portrayed in the Clint Eastwood style spaghetti western with tongue in cheek, epic like presentation. Kevin Mameluke and Mia Sorvinodo a good job of acting.
11 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
If the Hallmark channel asked a 12 yr old to write a western
badappl29 March 2020
Yikes pard. The acting is more brutally wooden than Neegan's baseball bat.

The "story" is basically every cliché you can think up. Sadly it has a few really talented actors you probably like, and they are stuck in this tumbleweed of a movie.

Since it blows anyway, just let it blow away.
19 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Very good contemporary western
voicesofthewest28 March 2020
As a contemporary western, this film excels. It basically is the story of a Pinkerton detective searching for three former Confederate Army officers. They must be brought to "justice" for their war crimes, according to a newly-elected black senator. The dialogue reminds me of the dialogue from "Deadwood" in that the speech is more formal and the characters do not sound like a bunch of country bumpkins. Breaking up the story into four chapters is a good move. Keeps the story from wandering too far off course.The actors portraying the "bad guys" were very good. I even felt sorry for Bruce Dern's character! Good movie all the way around!
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Good sleep aid!
mxsuba2631 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Well buffed out Pinkerton Detective/Cowboy - Mathias Beacher - who says little, wears all black and hunts down fugitive Confederate war criminals with his two Colt Peacemakers and Spencer carbine with the intent of hanging each one. His two bosses are both former slaves. First he offs fugitive rebel Trace Adkins and all his bros after a bizarre conversation in his barn. Then he tracks down one Confederate Capt Cooke on his ranch in the desert - played by an ancient looking Bruce Dern who is only shown in a white nightgown in every scene. Not a good look Bruce. Given that Bruce is already dying he spares him and at the same time falls for his sexy middle aged daughter - Mira Sorvino, looking pretty cute in her cow girl duds. She does not seem too bothered that Mathias came to kill her dad and falls for the guy. The bathtub scene is a bit much where Mira walks in on Mathias cleaning up his body builder body. But I guess she wanted to check out the merchandise before buying so to speak. Finally he tracks down a war criminal turned corrupt sheriff running the quaint little town of Knife Edge, a town filled with old geezer cowboys and surprisingly attractive prostitutes. The Sheriff even shoots one of the hookers over a $12 debt she owed him. What was that about? While Mathias manages to dispatch the sheriff and all his posse in a classic gun fight in the middle of the street, he ends up gut shot - basically a fatal wound. But that does not stop him from riding all the way back to Mira on her ranch. No real ending to the film to see what happened to the happy couple.

A good combination of a dumb story, bad acting, and unbelievable characters. And what is with Mathias's unusual affection for his horse. Not going there.
18 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Better than expected
Gazoopi23 March 2021
Having seen the previous reviews, I expected this film to be less than mediocre. They were deceptive. Badland is not amongst the western greats, but deserved better. The storyline is good, a touch of Shane, and well worth watching.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Confederate War Criminals
nogodnomasters26 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Mathias William Breecher (Kevin Makely) is a fast drawing Pinkerton agent hunting down Confederate war criminals out west. This is something I question if it actually happened. They were typically brought to a tribunal and ended up acquitted or in jail. The film is divided into chapters with each one being a new victim. Tony Todd is in the film in a useless role. There is a scene early on involving a Native American bounty hunter who took way too many pauses when he talked, making William Shatner sound fluid. There is a climax high noon gunfight that was overly cliche as was much of the film.

Guide: No swearing, sex, or nudity.
15 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not Bad
dfohner9 May 2020
Although I watch movies for entertainment and not snob appeal. I enjoyed the context of a dedicated detective trying to complete his mission of justice with some compassion. It wasn't as bad as most of the reviews indicate but was an exciting entertaining western.
18 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Badland
cobe_btc11 November 2019
We saw Badland at the Canton,MI Emagine theater. It was a very good western. We enjoyed meeting Kevin's in-laws that we're also in the movie. We actually went home and watched "Any Bullet will Do", another good Kevin Makely movie. Keep acting Kevin.
8 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Badland... so bad, but coulda been good
jaysonprovidence28 January 2021
Yes, the dialogue is... well... it is what it is. However, the over acting was what sealed its death. This script was excellent had the acting and directing didn't sadly reach for overkill. Delivery and movement matters, even with a script like this. I get the wording was focused on how conversations were back then... but... the over accentuations of words and movement totally cheese a film that had so much more potential.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Not great but certainly not bad.
PapaKiloPKDS22 September 2021
Melodramatic, slow, plays out like a fairy tale, low budget, but it looked authentic for the period and was enjoyable to watch.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Better than most reviews.
patherwill5 October 2022
Like most genres of movies there are fast/slow/romantic/ violent/good story or none/ comedic etc,list is endless and to me this film falls into slow/only violent when necessary/good story, Pinkerton Detective hunts down 'war criminals' - first time heard this phrase in a western. Stars include Mira Sorvino, Bruce Dern, Wes Studi and Kevin Makely who I've never heard of but................. Very nice locations and the film is set in 4 different story's and has a very good support cast. Many reviewers have seemingly based theirs on the fact that the film was "slow" or 'has no story' and while the first may be true when Badland is compared to say The Long Riders, Unforgiven, Glory or virtually any Clint Eastwood western, the film definitely has a story and I think many are mixing that up with the fact that people aren't bleeding out or being gutted all through it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed