Housewife, 49 (TV Movie 2005) Poster

(2005 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
30 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Perfect Sunday evening TV
keysersoze1315 December 2006
Written by and starring Victoria Wood, 'Housewife 49' was a lovely one-off drama that was perfect for a quiet, winter Sunday evening. Its broadcast also signifies that ITV may be moving in the right direction with its drama output; which has been truly awful this year, with embarrassments such as the ludicrous 'Bon Voyage'. However, the future looks promising as their winter schedules are packed with drama and improvement has been shown recently with 'Mysterious Creatures', the acclaimed final 'Prime Suspect' and this wartime tale.

The drama followed Nella Last (played by Victoria Wood in a nice change from her usual work in comedy) through the Second World War as she, against the wishes of her reserved husband, volunteers to aid the war effort with other housewives. Nella is initially ignored or looked down on by the other housewives, but, battling depression and low self-esteem, slowly gains their respect and admiration.

The performances are first-rate, from Wood's sympathetic portrait of a woman who is eager to please all, to David Threlfall (of 'Shameless' fame), who is magnificently restrained as Nella's husband, and when he finally shows some love to his wife it is irresistibly joyous. Excellent support comes from Stephanie Cole as an uptight housewife, and Ben Crompton and Christopher Harper as Nella's sons.

Overall, a very entertaining, tender and heart-warming piece of TV drama.
20 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
"We knew we weren't forgotten."
SteveSkafte31 October 2010
"Housewife, 49" is a remarkable film in how it captures a picture of life that commonly goes unseen. Victoria Wood, the star of the film, is quite good. She offers a performance that's very easy to get into, full of emotional complexity and human depth. I was quite impressed by David Threlfall, who plays Wood's husband here. He convincingly captures a certain generation and personality of man that you don't often see on film. Not abusive or offensive, but emotionally distance and overly self-controlled. Stephanie Cole is good, but she isn't given much to work with here. The script tends to wander a bit too much at times. The entire subplot revolving around people reading the letters seems tacked-on and ultimately unnecessary.

I'm glad I saw this. It offers up a close human insight. The TV movie format holds things down a bit, but the best is made of it. "Housewife, 49" is a good film.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Real real Life
zorro2a10 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Maybe Spoiler I had no intention of watching this drama but l had fallen asleep and woke up just after it had started and stayed with it, what a wonderful piece of writing this play was by the star Victoria Wood and what a great bit acting by the same lady, as Nella she shows fun, sadness, joy, upset all in the space of a few minutes, as the war goes on she becomes more and more her own woman, David Thewlis was superb as Nellas staid husband, the impression one gets is that they don't love each other but just stay together, then there is Cliff, Nellas son who turns out to be gay but you never are told that it was the great acting and script that leaves it to yourself to imagine, there was the nosey neighbour, the posh WRVS ladies, and the sets showing WWll bombed houses, all in all a great piece of television and l give it 9/10
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Superb acting
belisanda18 March 2008
Nella Last's story deserved to be told even if in adapted guise long since. My greatest praise goes to Victoria Wood. As a comedian I always understood and was revived by her humour, wit and writing. But as a "so called serious actress" I was totally blown away by her performance in this. Far more so than in the delightful "Pat and Margaret". Stephanie Cole is up to her standard of excellency on this one, too and then some. The period art direction is almost flwaless. For a non-Britain it actually feels flawless...

Also: I simply adore the NOT-Hollywoodesque-nonsense ending.

Definitely 10 out of 10 for this one
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wonderful acting, funny and poignant
whistlestop11 December 2006
This was a real treat last night on TV, and I hope they repeat it soon for all those who missed it. Victoria Wood proves again what a wonderful actress and writer she is. The great Stephanie Cole is formidable as the WVS boss, and David Threlfall is superbly restrained as Nella's emotionally repressed husband. Nella's wartime experiences mirror those of many ordinary housewives I am sure. An emotional roller-coaster! It was a joy to watch; sometimes we laughed out loud, especially at the jolly neighbours, and sometimes we had tears in our eyes. The costumes and props all looked very authentic; as Victoria herself remarked, it was hardly a glamorous role! I'm looking forward to a DVD....
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Victoria Drake
paul2001sw-119 December 2006
Comidienne Victoria Wood makes a surprisingly good straight actress in this drama, which lovingly recreates the atmosphere of the 1940s. Based on the real diaries of a depressed woman unexpectedly liberated by the war, it is, however, possessed of a certain slowness and obviousness, although the individual scenes are immaculately constructed. Overall, it lacks the human depth of Mike Leigh's 'Vera Drake', another portrait of the same times, as well as that film's dramatic intent. But it's funny to see David Threlfall playing a very different, but equally useless, man of the house, following his turn as Frank Gallacher in 'Shameless'.
12 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best I've seen for a long time
Mark Price22 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Now I am not one to go overboard when reviewing anything but this you have to see. In an interview earlier this year Victoria Wood said she has a few things "in the fire" but she wouldn't elaborate. Comedienne, comedy actress & writer, singer of comedy songs she again writes herself, but this is something special. I have seen her act in non comedy roles before but this has such a range with her initially frightened of the world outside her home,naive, not daring to contradict her husband over anything to later taking charge in all aspects of her life and improving the lives of those around her. Set in the 2nd World War it is not a "feel good" drama and I was close to tears more than once. But you go through the journey she does and you come out the other side uplifted. Well I did, maybe you will too.
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good in its own way
enochsneed13 February 2008
Warning: Spoilers
'Housewife, 49' is a very good period drama. It is well-written, well-acted and well above the standard of most other television productions.

One note of caution, however. If you have seen this, don't think you have seen a true adaptation of Nella Last's diaries. Only a couple of the incidents dramatised here actually come from the book it claims as a source. It seems Victoria Wood started with the premise of writing the story of a downtrodden woman whose horizons were broadened by the emergencies of war. So much is true, Nella Last did seem to find a meaningful rôle in her voluntary work. However, Wood seems to have been so determined to bring out this aspect of the story other elements have been invented and changed.

Most significantly, the diaries for the last part of 1943 and the whole of 1944 are missing. This is the period in which Nella's son Cliff was wounded and brought home for recuperation. In the film Nella visits Cliff and he rejects her. This makes for poignant drama but we have no evidence at all that this ever happened (Cliff died in 1991 so obviously couldn't advise on the production). There is also very little evidence from the diary that Cliff was gay (although he did have a friend, George, who was killed while serving in the Fleet Air Arm).

Nella never went to her old home by mistake when she was on the verge of a breakdown, and she never walked out of her job in the Red Cross shop.

Worse still, the personalities of other characters have been distorted. Her husband is particularly badly served. Will Last was rather dour and undemonstrative, but he was not the unfeeling man depicted here, dismissive and even resentful of Nella's voluntary work. Nella's sister-in-law of the diaries was not the rather vindictive person shown in the film.

The look of the film is very authentic, and the air-raid scenes give a real sense of what life must have been like for ordinary people living in those claustrophobic conditions with no certainty they would live to see another day - a welcome change from the 'Britain can take it' tradition.

So: enjoy the film on its own merits by all means, but read the book if you want to know the real Nella Last story.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Accurate portrayal of wartime civilian life
philphoto12 December 2006
Warning: Spoilers
I enjoyed this drama very much. The language , turn of phrases, and mores were of their time . Many wartime dramas are ruined by bad research and a tendency to modernise the script to 'make it appeal to the younger folk' a habit I abhor but seen a lot in the 70's and 80's.. One suspected that the son was 'gay' (a term never used in this context at the time) and I thought oh, here we go, they are making it trendy, but Nellas incomprehension when her Son tells her that the love of his life was a sailor (Fleet Air Arm) killed in action shows. These things were 'never discussed ' in polite circles in those days. Very good, historically accurate drama.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Understated view of ordinary folk under the German bombs...
secondtake28 September 2012
Housewife, 49 (2006)

The idea here is to make the fear of German bombardment in London during WWII as real as possible. And the focus is an extremely ordinary family--in particular the woman of the house, but also her low-key husband and two clever and fighting age boys.

The best of it is really amazing at recreating the feel and look and fear of the times. The character actors are wonderful, even if they must be a bit exaggerated. The slang and whatnot is a total joy, even if at times there is a feeling of pushing that too hard.

There is a deflating feeling that all this possibility and gorgeous period set-building is supported by a somewhat flat plot. It's not that the bombing and the deaths are a bit unimportant, but rather it is laid out with a kind of plainness that should have been compelling but in fact ends up being just plain. The writing makes sense--perhaps it's some combination of acting and camera-work that lets it all just happen too often.

The music, I have to say, is horrible, a kind of television soundtrack that is out of place, almost patched in by a hack studio orchestra that hadn't even quite seen the film. It's surprising how much this alters the feel to it all.

The leading woman, the housewife in the title, is a sympathetic character and, and the actress is compelling. She is a woman caught between all kinds of pressures, family and civic duties all around (and without always appreciation). And this pushes her to her mental limits (even seeing a doctor about it). The demands on the part, on the actress, are a bit too much for this production, and for this actress, Victoria Wood. The final outcome and maybe the larger point of the movie is something more than civilian life in wartime. It's about futility and sadness and perseverance. You might find the last scene comforting for its notion of quiet survival, or depressing for its lack of joy.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Insight Into A Lost Generation
nturner7 November 2008
Victoria Wood is a famous British comic actress who has surely shown that she also has a superior for drama - both writing and acting - in this excellent made for television film based upon a real person. During World War II in England, housewife, Nella Last's experiences were recorded by the Mass-Observation organization founded in 1937 to record the daily experiences of British citizens for social research.

The film starts with Nella as being almost complete frustrated with her role as housewife. She is a middle-aged woman who has devoted her entire self to the care of her husband and their two sons. The war has just started, and her sons are leaving to serve in duties other than combat.

Nella's only connection with anything creative is her younger son. He is the one who encourages his mother to go beyond the confines of the house in order to seek fulfillment. Nella begins to blossom when she volunteers for the Women's Voluntary Service and starts to submit her observances of daily occurrences to Mass-Observation.

Over the objections of her husband - a joiner - Nella volunteers for the WVS. There she must face the insults of the women in charge for she is merely the wife of a laborer whereas they are wives of members of higher classes. With spunk and wit, Nella forges ahead and becomes an invaluable member of the organization.

At home, Nella receives almost no support from her husband - a man not able to express emotion. Because of this weakness, he appears to be somewhat of a villain, but there are a few touching scenes in the screenplay where the viewer is able to see past his hard surface to a man who genuinely loves his wife.

Nella's son, Cliff, may be the most complex character in the film. Clifford Last who eventually entered battle was wounded and after the war, moved to Australia where he became a well-known sculptor.

This is a fine film that gives insight into the lives of women of Nella's generation and invites the viewer into an "everyday family" that is certainly far from that.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Housewife, 49
Prismark1027 May 2020
Victoria Wood plays a straight role as a downtrodden middle aged mother and housewife.

In the bittersweet Housewife, 49. Nella Last has recovered from one breakdown and seems to be heading for another one. She is alone, her husband and his sister are not sympathetic to her plight. Her husband is domineering and rather introverted himself.

Nella feels stigmatised by her social superiors in Barrow in Furness.

When the war starts Nella is nervous and uncertain. Afraid to go out in the dark alone. She reluctantly takes part in the woman's voluntary service, by the end of the war Nella is the backbone of her community. Someone people could rely on.

The drama is based on Nella's wartime diaries written for the Mass-Observation project set up in 1937 to record the lives of ordinary people.

It is wonderfully made but it also wants to feel too much like a Victoria Wood drama and too many characters are one dimensional. No one else seems to develop much.

It needed to be spiky for dramatic impact. Nella at last confronts her husband for his behaviour but we are only see Nella toying with the idea whether she should leave her husband. Her husband's sister is let off scot free for her rude behaviour.

Even the scenes with her older son Arthur. I am not sure how much more he could had telegraphed he was gay but it seems to have gone over his parent's head.

Housewife, 49 tries too hard to be a pleasant drama when it could had been more with the actors in it.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
social propaganda and not faithful to the book
mccoppeto22 September 2008
Warning: Spoilers
When one has at hand an ostensibly honest diary of domestic life under trying conditions, a screenwriter might feel the obligation to mine it for some moral or psychological truth. But that would be work and not for today's screenwriters, most of whom seem to have signed a contract to insert gratuitous homosexuality, infidelity, feminism, and hyperbole into every story they adapt. They rewrite history as a kind of affirmative action to advertise their social values. Someone should tell them that beauty doesn't have to be meretricious and truth doesn't have to be juicy. Thus Nella Last's Diary is ravaged in being brought to the screen. The recent Miss Marple movies, among other recent adaptations to the screen, suffer from the same contrivances of the screenwriters. I can't wait until these hacks get hold of Dickens - Miss Havisham will be a heroic madame pimping out Estella to lesbians and to a married Pip. In the case of Housewife 49 the magnitude of the sin is squared because history, which should be sacred, is what is being falsified.
2 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brilliant
RobToseland10 December 2006
They story was brilliant and Victoria Wood's acting, along with the rest of the cast was amazing!. Two minutes in and i was hooked.

If you happen to see it on DVD, buy it, its a very good story.

It tells us the story of Nella Last, as it was taken from the diaries she kept during the war right up until her death.

I really cant explain too much about it, you have to watch it.

Housewife, 49 was a good drama, and i was surprised at how good it was.

It was a story about a housewife during WW2 and it was motivating!

I just saw it tonight on ITV, hopefully they will bring it out on DVD very soon.

Enjoy Watching it

Rob
13 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Meek Shall Inherit the Earth
robert-temple-15 July 2009
This superb film was made because of the remarkable personal qualities of the British television comedienne and comedy writer, Victoria Wood, who has always had her serious side as well, as she shows here. Wood wrote and starred in this film, which was brilliantly and sensitively directed by old pro Gavin Millar, one of British television's most famous drama directors. Victoria Wood has always enjoyed an enormous popularity with the public at large because she is so 'down to earth' and so 'real', and her quaint folksy approach to humour, drawing upon her northern roots, expressed sardonically in her northern accent, is dear to the hearts of the British in a way which no foreigner could ever understand. She has always refused to do anything about her appearance, and the public have lived through her stages of being too fat, then being less fat, along with her, as if she were a family member of everyone's. She would never allow a surgeon anywhere near her face. She is what she is, and 'you can take it or leave it'. Her excruciating honesty is much prized by everyone except the phonies and the pseuds. Here, she has chosen to dramatize the story of a shy, excessively meek and self-effacing, ordinary woman during the Second World War. The story is drawn from the extensive, poignant, and revealing diaries of this woman who lived in the north, and were submitted to Mass Observation over many years, and whose name was Nella Last. She was identified as 'Housewife, 49'. It is necessary to explain how these diaries came to be written. In 1937, a small group of writers and artists in London (several of whom I knew towards the end of their lives, namely Kathleen Raine, William Empson, and Julian Trevelyan), decided they were fed up with the inadequate press coverage of the public's true reactions to the abdication of King Edward VIII. They decided to set up their own amateur opinion-gathering project, and they called it the Mass Observation Movement. One of the three main driving forces behind this was the poet Charles Madge, whom I never knew, but Kathleeen Raine was his widow, and she used to talk to me a lot about Mass Observation, on which she had once worked indefatiguably herself, so I have some understanding of what those people thought they were doing. They solicited diaries from ordinary people, over 500 of them around the country, who supplied them on an unpaid and purely voluntary basis. One shy and thoroughly obscure person who did this was Nella Last. Her story grew and grew, and from her seemingly drab and ordinary life, a vast and moving drama grew, like a poppy appearing on a desolate battlefield. Victoria Wood has crafted an amazingly moving and fascinating film based upon this tale of someone who was not merely ordinary and obscure, but meek and retiring. Nella Last opened her heart, and recorded all the things which most of us would be too intimidated to relate, about who really did what to whom in her town, and how she and they felt about it. The result is an absolutely astounding revelation of just how interesting the lives of seemingly boring people can really be, when examined in depth and with compassion. This film is a testament to the rich and intensely-lived lives of the meek, the helpless, the repressed, and the oppressed. These are the people we pass in the street and don't notice. They have feelings too, they have their joys and their sorrows, but they keep them to themselves and suffer silently. Nella Last broke the rule of silence, the 'omerta' of the obscure, and she spoke out of the depths of her suffering heart about what it is like to be a nobody and to be treated as one. She also described her slow climb up towards a degree of self-confidence, her achievement against all the odds at doing something constructive for the War Effort, yes, she, Nella Last, the nobody. She ended up being, in her small way, a somebody. And that is her story, and it was so worth telling. And only somebody with the heart and the soul of a Victoria Wood could or would ever have dared to try. And the success is total. The performances of the other people in this incredible film are breath-taking in their honesty and heart-breaking in their intensity. David Threlfall is an actor many of us remember for his unforgettable portrayal on stage of Smike in Dickens's 'Nicholas Nickleby', a quarter of a century ago. Here, he portrays Wood's husband, a man so immobilised by the inability to express his feelings that it is perhaps the greatest classic film portrait ever achieved of a man frozen into silence, whose feelings are powerful surging currents, but whose lips are sealed, and only his pathetic, pleading eyes reveal anything at all. The women who play the many vivid supporting roles in the film are all so brilliant that one gasps. When the film is over, you feel you have left a group of friends whose personalities are seared into your memory. These are real people, this is a real film, this is a real story. Watch it and learn. It deserves to be shown in schools, to humanize some of the feral young who have no feelings and no compassion, and whose idea of life is to go around stabbing each other to death in the streets, as they do nearly every day in London now. Above all, this story of Nella Last is a study in loyalty, and of the ultimate true human values which she exemplified in her hidden life of obscurity, poverty, and invisibility to the world. What an achievement this is! And how proud Victoria Wood should be of what she and her inspired colleagues have done in making this film!
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Slightly Disappointing Dramatization of a Memorable Mass-Observation Diary
l_rawjalaurence30 August 2015
Based on the wartime diaries written for Mass-Observation by Nella Last, HOUSEWIFE, 49 tells the story of a Barrow-in-Furness homemaker's experiences of living through World War II. Her life is not especially exciting, but the written account of the struggles with her mental difficulties, an uncaring spouse, and the day-to-day traumas of the Blitz makes for compelling reading.

I wish I could say the same about Victoria Wood's play. Gavin Millar's production makes strenuous efforts to appeal to viewers, through a relentless focus on Wood's face as she plays the central character; through a deliberate use of contrast between her stoicism and the indifference of husband Will (David Threlfall); and through the way she battles through all obstacles, both physical as well as mental, to undergo a significant change of character. She begins the film as a rather mousy, insignificant person, dominated by her husband and frightened of her social superiors. As the action progresses, however, she acquires both self-reliance and strength of character, so much so that she forces the bossy Mrs. Waite (Stephanie Cole) to make an apology.

And yet there remains a fairly unbelievable air to the whole enterprise; we never get the sense of historical empathy that is essential to the success of most period dramas. This is perhaps due to the stereotyped casting; the deliberate contrasting of Nella's down-to-earth manner with the over-the-top snobbery of Mrs. Lord (Marcia Warren in one of her familiar snooty roles). As Mrs. Lynch, Cole merely reprises the bossy woman role most obvious in her long- running sitcom WAITING FOR GOD. There is also the problem of the over-emphatic dramaturgy, most obvious when Nella's son Cliff (Christopher Harper) reveals his true sexuality to his mother, who still fails to understand. Whether this is a willful decision or not is left uncertain; but in dramatic terms the scene is so obviously sign-posted that we wonder why she should be so imperceptive. On another occasion Nella has an argument with her husband about the fact that no one actually talks to her; the camera cuts to a shot of his face, then back to Nella, and then the husband stumps upstairs. If we did not understand previously why Nella chose to write her diary, we certainly do so now.

There is also a slight problem of tone: Wood insists on including scenes of little dramatic value, that enable her to incorporate some of her characteristic one-liners. In Mass-Observation's London offices Godfrey (Hugh Sachs) jokes about a bag of dough-nuts with Jill (Daisy Haggard). This technique works well in some of Wood's comic plays, but seems a little incongruous here.

Granada Television's production is high on production values, with the usual precise emphasis on period detail (their recreation of a bomb-site immediately after an air-raid is especially good, even down to the little boy wondering whether or not to rummage in the ruins of his family home). Perhaps the historic cars are just a little too shiny, but nonetheless they look cheap and functional, a characteristic of British social life at that time.

HOUSEWIFE, 49 is certainly watchable, but we are left with the feeling that it could have been scripted slightly better.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Treasure
drew-12131 December 2006
As a long time fan of Ms Wood, I was very happy to watch this sojourn into the drama world. The writing contained her usual naturalistic flow, the evocation of 1940's Barrow was superb and the journey portrayed by Ms Wood as Ella was totally believable.

The subtle way in which she dealt with such issues as those raised by her son Cliff was heartening and again true of the period. Her grasp of the historical perspective, the way families lived and coped with the war was so very true and at the end of the film I was left with a sense of having witnessed real life not a drama.

Great acting from David Threlfall and Stephanie Cole.

The best thing on TV over Christmas by far!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Faithful to the book?
broadrk21 May 2018
Very few scenes were ones reported in the diary but Wood's film conveyed its substance very well indeed. Beautifully handled, for example, was Nella's naive inability to recognise Cliff's homosexuality. But I thought her 'Nella' was too passive. You can see the film's nervy, pensive introvert in her intimate writing but her diaries also make it clear that she could be feisty and would have come across to others as able and assured. Nella herself contrasts 'the quiet, brooding woman who, when alone, draws the quiet around her like a healing cloak and the gay lively woman who 'keeps all going'''.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Heart-warming wartime drama
Jackanackanory11 December 2006
Although I am not a fan of Victoria Wood as comedienne (I just never understood her comedy and therefore never found her funny) I was intrigued by the concept of this drama so I watched it.

I am glad I did, as it was a very well written drama that looks into life in the perspective of a mother Nella Last who sees her life change around her, more often than not in the way peoples attitudes are and also throughout the war realises she doesn't know those close to her including her family as well as she thinks she does, this in turn makes her look at her own lifestyle and realises she must change in some aspects too.

Although I may not be a fan of Victoria Wood in her primary guise, (as a comedienne), as an actress she has proved in this drama she is a first-rate actress and considering she wrote this drama, a decent writer too.

On the whole a nice heart-warming wartime family drama.
9 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Very close to perfect
Caalong26 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I watched this because there wasn't much else on TV at the time and this seemed to be the best of a bad lot. What luck! I may otherwise have missed this beautiful and sensitive piece of television. It's a gem. Beautifully written and with excellent direction. Every acting performance, down to the smallest role, creates a real and recognizable character. The dialog is spot on and coveys so much in so few words. The changing dynamics of the relationship between husband and wife and mother and son were so real and so moving. It captures the mood of the times as described to me by older English people who lived through the war and the air-raids. I was sometimes chuckling and sometimes close to tears. I loved it. Bravo Ms Wood and bravo those who financed it and brought it to us.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Endless turgid wartime plod
felix-gallagher10 December 2006
Taken from a housewife's diary writing in Barrow in Furnness, in the North of England, during World War Two, this two hour trudge makes for a very dull evening. As each plodding scene followed the last you began to hope for a Nazi bomber to drop a bomb on the lot of them. Every character is one dimensional. Every scene is played at a smug snail's pace. It seems to be shot entirely in sepia, until the war ends and suddenly people start wearing red. The ghastly derivative acting, music and script have no sense of rhythm. It is all apparently true. Whoever said that real life was more interesting that drama? The whole thing seemed longer than the war itself, and not nearly as interesting.
1 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very good period piece
pawebster18 June 2007
Victoria Wood is wonderful. For this she provides a top script and performance in the lead role. The rest of the cast are all very good, too. I loved the scene in the railway carriage with the doctor, excellently played by Jason Watkins. It all seemed very realistic. It was involving and moving. And, unlike some wartime pieces (e.g. Foyle's War), the dialogue was convincingly of its period.

Slight niggles: It is hard to believe that the son, Cliff, is a PT instructor. He does not look the part at all. The WVS ladies were perhaps a bit too caricatured. Also, there seemed to be no problems with rationing. People scoffed fruitcake and even doughnuts -- which I should think would wipe out the fat and sugar ration in one fell swoop -- as if this were quite normal. I also wish the film had not started with the words "inspired by" the diary of Nella Last. This is even less than "based on" and makes it sound as if a lot of the story we saw might have been fictitious.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
As close to the real thing as can be
maxblinkhorn-1962523 December 2018
I won't get into describing the story but this is as accurate a portrayal of life in a quiet Northern English town during World War 2 as it's possible to see.

The stifling, local community is shown through a sharp and sometime harsh lens and ordinary grief is exposed in a simple and empathetic way.

Victoria Wood shows her ability to "act real" and even more, highlights how other good actors are actually really rather pretentious.

"His poor Mother.... why didn't you write and say?"

By turns depressing and uplifting but without the modern contrivances that deliver that neat, to our computers and televisions.

If you want to know what life was like in the war, at home, this will give you strong light and shade......

A work of genius.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
What a gem!
Serenstars7 May 2012
Flicking through the channels on a slow TV night, I chanced across this film just as it was beginning. Within minutes I knew I had found something worth watching. How 'Housewife, 49' (made in 2006) had slipped under my radar I'm not sure, and why it hasn't received far greater accolades than it has, I have no idea.

I went to the cinema earlier this week and watched the latest blockbuster, raking in millions at the box office .. and honestly, it wasn't a patch on this.

Just for starters - The acting is breathtaking. Who knew Victoria Wood was such a stunning actress and as for the performance from David Threlfall (known to British TV audiences as Frank Gallagher in Shameless) - all I can say is Wow! His portrayal of this tightly buttoned-up straight-laced man who loved his family more than life itself (but was totally unable to show it) is like an acting masterclass. Add to that a supporting cast of Brit stalwarts like Stephanie Cole and the wonderful Sylvestra Le Touzel (one of my favourite actresses) and this wasn't a film that was going to go far wrong - that was apparent. But add to that a moving and eloquent storyline, great authenticity and attention to detail, bucket-loads of Brit humour and smart direction and cinematography .. and the result is an absolute gem of a film which I intend to purchase on DVD asap.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed