This is the last William Hartnell story so surely you can imagine him being quite heavily focused on, go out with a bang and all that where in reality the doctor is shown prominently in the first two episodes and then is sparsely seen at all in the last two and most important of the serial, luckily Polly and Ben are excellent as ever and prove they can carry episode all on their own here but I feel like this episode could've been so much more if they had just given WH a little more to do, nevertheless a story thats well worth the watch. 8 to an 8.5 out of 10
3 Reviews
a good story that could've been a great one if not for it's underuse of William Hartnell
maxglen12 November 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Please someone find it.
Sleepin_Dragon10 October 2019
It makes me so sad to think that this episode ia still lost, it really is monumental, a pretty incredible and standout piece of television.
Despite this being one of the most sought after of missing episodes, we still have the option of the radio version, and the BBC's animated version.
The story is very good indeed, the future of the human race, Mondas, the cyber threat, all terrific elements, but the true highlight comes in the regeneration.
It was such a brave decision back then to replace the lead actor, Hartnell was The Doctor, the show wouldn't have worked without his brilliance, step forward Patrick Troughton, and another wonderful era for Doctor Who.
Thank you William Hartnell. Your legacy gave millions of us so much joy and entertainment over the years.
Despite this being one of the most sought after of missing episodes, we still have the option of the radio version, and the BBC's animated version.
The story is very good indeed, the future of the human race, Mondas, the cyber threat, all terrific elements, but the true highlight comes in the regeneration.
It was such a brave decision back then to replace the lead actor, Hartnell was The Doctor, the show wouldn't have worked without his brilliance, step forward Patrick Troughton, and another wonderful era for Doctor Who.
Thank you William Hartnell. Your legacy gave millions of us so much joy and entertainment over the years.
Historic, very effective and entertaining - First ever Cybermen story and the first ever regeneration for the Doctor
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic21 August 2014
Review for all 4 parts:
This story from writer Kit Pedler is historic and thankfully the quality matches its importance. And important it really is because the idea of changing the actor playing the Doctor by having him 'regenerate' into a different version of the same character was incredible and untested. It is hard now to imagine how radical this idea was at the time. If it had failed Doctor Who would have been finished whereas as the time of writing we have just celebrated an amazing 50 years of Doctor Who with the show and most of its key elements still continuing as strongly as ever.
As a springboard for all that we have this excellent adventure which also has the historic first ever appearance by the Cybermen. I really like these prototype Cybermen and even their 'sing-song' voices. I think the concept behind them is great and the story itself has them involved in an exciting attempt to destroy humanity. Their unfeeling nature and the scares and action set them up as an iconic 'monster' to rival the Daleks.
All aspects of the production are very good indeed and any flaws are minor. The story unfortunately has the Doctor sidelined a lot of the time which was unnecessary and sad in Hartnell's last regular appearance. However, when he does get involved he is as good as ever, delivering his lines with his usual charisma and that magical touch Hartnell had for being somewhat other worldly and dangerous but also endearing and delightful.
This is a classic which all fans must see. All 4 episodes 10/10.
Average rating for all William Hartnell episodes 8.26/10.
This story from writer Kit Pedler is historic and thankfully the quality matches its importance. And important it really is because the idea of changing the actor playing the Doctor by having him 'regenerate' into a different version of the same character was incredible and untested. It is hard now to imagine how radical this idea was at the time. If it had failed Doctor Who would have been finished whereas as the time of writing we have just celebrated an amazing 50 years of Doctor Who with the show and most of its key elements still continuing as strongly as ever.
As a springboard for all that we have this excellent adventure which also has the historic first ever appearance by the Cybermen. I really like these prototype Cybermen and even their 'sing-song' voices. I think the concept behind them is great and the story itself has them involved in an exciting attempt to destroy humanity. Their unfeeling nature and the scares and action set them up as an iconic 'monster' to rival the Daleks.
All aspects of the production are very good indeed and any flaws are minor. The story unfortunately has the Doctor sidelined a lot of the time which was unnecessary and sad in Hartnell's last regular appearance. However, when he does get involved he is as good as ever, delivering his lines with his usual charisma and that magical touch Hartnell had for being somewhat other worldly and dangerous but also endearing and delightful.
This is a classic which all fans must see. All 4 episodes 10/10.
Average rating for all William Hartnell episodes 8.26/10.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
