The Winter's Tale (TV Movie 1999) Poster

(1999 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A tale that is beautifully told
TheLittleSongbird1 October 2021
'The Winter's Tale' is not one of the very best plays of William Shakespeare, a master playwright and one of history's most important, with one of his more improbable plots. It is still though a charmer that really casts a spell when done well, has interesting characters difficult to portray in some cases (especially the Othello-like Leontes), has Shakespeare's usual mastery of language and has emotional impact. To me, even when Shakespeare was not at his very best there was still an awful lot to admire.

Anything with Antony Sher, a very seasoned Shakespearean actor, is worth a look and he himself is always a reason to see anything he's in. While he is not always the most innovative of stage directors and is not as much of a risk taker as other stage director, Gregory Doran even in non-traditional productions has more often than not directed in good taste and has always made characters and interactions interesting. Which is what is most important in Shakespeare. This is a great and very accessible production of 'The Winter's Tale' that overcomes most of the play's potential problems and is very entertaining, well acted and charming.

Ryan McClusky and Emily Bruni are a little on the bland side as the lovers, but quite a large part of the problem is the characters themselves (not the most interesting in the first places, they're no Leontes or Paulina, the two most well developed, that's for sure).

Everything else works absolutely brilliantly, with the rest of the performances being spot on. Sher in particular is extraordinary and intensely and movingly makes the difficult, complex role of Leontes a very layered character, embodying every single one of those layers and balancing them beautifully. Other standouts are Estelle Kohler's Paulina and Alexandra Gilbreath's radiant Hermione.

Doran's staging is always tasteful and manages to make the story cohesive, when it could easily have jumped and sprawled around, nothing is ridiculous or confusing here. And never does it feel static or too much. The final scene is absolutely magical and this is one of the few productions of 'The Winter's Tale' where the notorious bear scene, the play's Achilles heal and one of the most notoriously difficult stage directions in all Shakespeare, is not botched or/and unintentionally silly.

Production values are simple but also attractive and atmospheric. The dialogue always sparkles in humour and emotion and the whole storytelling has a lot of brains and heart.

In summary, fabulous and one of the stronger versions of 'The Winter's Tale' available. 9/10.
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Technically quality but feels rather highbrow. Also poor camerawork. Watch the 2021 RSC version or 2014 ballet instead
mickman91-17 February 2022
There are so few versions of The Winter's Tale available to watch on screen. This is one of them and can be found available to rent or buy on Amazon. I have to say that this to me felt a very technically proficient but safe version of the play. The acting was all round of high quality and the production sound. But overall it didn't reach me on an emotional level. The intensity wasn't there of jealousy, tragedy, redemption etc. This may be in part due to the fact that the recording is totally static which takes a way a lot of the dynamism. But I guess this is no different to how one views a play in the theatre.

There is a 2021 version performed by the RSC which is available on BBC player. While perhaps not as formally proficient, I found this one much more emotionally engaging, not to mention far superior in camerawork and watchability. There is also the 2014 ballet by the Royal Opera House which available free to watch on MarqueeTV. This is also excellent and conveying the emotions of the play.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed