Jimmy (Mike O'Malley) tells a story about how Kim (Jean Louisa Kelly) kissed him when they were younger. Christine (Liza Snyder) is mad at Jimmy because Kim kissed him, but Greg (Anthony Clark) is not mad at Kim because it was long before he met her. Kim later tells Greg that she kissed seven guys. Greg says that he was a ladies man, but Kim does not believe that. In response to this, Greg makes a list of all the girls he kissed in order to prove to Kim that he was a ladies man before they met. The final result was 49 girls. Kim becomes angry and jealous at Greg until Jimmy says that Greg has not kissed that many girls. Christine is still mad at Jimmy and kisses Greg out of spite. Kim reveals that when she kissed Jimmy when they were younger, it was out of spite because Christine pissed off Kim.