"The West Wing" A Proportional Response (TV Episode 1999) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
It's what our fathers taught us.
kickdoor0215 April 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is definitely the one that hooked me. I enjoyed the first two episodes but wasn't 100% sure the subject matter was going to keep me interested, but now I am. It started with the same humor I've come to expect and love from Sorkin.

"You know what, CJ, I really think I'm the best judge of what I mean, you paranoid Berkeley shiksa feminista! ...well, that was way too far."

"No, no. Well I've got a staff meeting to go to and so do you, you elitist Harvard fascist, missed the deans list two semesters in a row, Yankee jackass!"

"Feel better getting that off your chest there CJ?"

"I'm a whole new woman."

While the comedy was great,

"There is no law, there is no decency."

"He's just getting that now."

It was the drama that made this episode shine. I really got behind Bartlet in this episode, because in many ways I agree with him about the disproportional response. America does have the greatest military force on earth and the fact that we use it to do so much good should mean that those on their way to do good should be able to do so without fear of death. It was a plane full of doctors and nurses on their way to teach others how to become doctors and nurses, how much more altruistic can you get? And if an enemy has the gall to shoot down that plane they should expect more than a slap on the wrist.

"Let the word ring forth from this time and this place, gentlemen, you kill an American, any American, we don't come back with a proportional response. We come back with total disaster!"

But what I love about the show is that every issue has two pretty valid sides(exactly what politics is), and as soon as you mention civilian casualties things change pretty quickly. Though Bartlet's monologue about Rome still had me wishing they could have done more. But as Leo said it's the way a super power(the last one) should behave, has to behave.

"It's what our fathers taught us."

I even began to see the other side to Sam's situation with the call girl, though I still say he's almost crazy for doing it, I can see it might be more out of frustration with the system than his own personal agenda.

"It's not like you didn't know you were going to be held to a higher standard when you took this job."

"I don't mind being held to a higher standard I mind being held to a lower one."

Also Charlie's(Dule Hill)introduction was done quite well, looking forward to seeing more of his character.

Easily the best episode so far for me and the first(of many) truly perfect blends of comedy and drama that Sorkin produced.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Excellent in Every Way
Hitchcoc1 January 2021
I won't get into current politics. This episode shows the realities of being the President. Perhaps Bartlet should have known more, but this is what a Chief of Staff does--he advises and, in many ways, protects his boss. As unfair as it is, one can't respond in kind when civilians' lives are at stake. I was impressed with the portrayal of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. John Amos has been good in every role he has played. Dule Hall moves into position to be an intriguing character. The pacing of this episode is incredible. Aaron Sorkin has the knack of controlled chaos as the people bob and weave but seldom touch.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
THE WEST WING: SEASON 1, EPISODE 3: A Proportional Response
dalydj-918-25517517 July 2023
Warning: Spoilers
THE WEST WING: SEASON 1, EPISODE 3: A Proportional Response Directed by: Marc Buckland Written by: Aaron Sorkin

The tension really increases with this episode. The first two episodes where all about establishing the universe & characters where as this episode gets more into the politics & how the president & his team must perform real life acts while also having personal connections.

The show continues its smart humour in the dialogue with many incredible lines throughout the episode even as the drama increases.

Allison Janney really became the C. J. we all know & love. From the beginning of the episode we get to experience the witty & fun C. J. Cregg that would become a fan favourite from the show. Janney really excels in this role & I love that she was finally given the spotlight.

This being the first episode not directed by Thomas Schlamme still feels visually the same and that is great compliment to Schlamme and the directing team for the show. We also are introduced to Dulé Hill as Charlie Young in this episode and while it's a soft introduction I do enjoy how he has been used so far.

This is a very strong third episode and really caps off a strong three episode beginning to the season and the series as a whole. (5/5)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed