"Gunsmoke" Cow Doctor (TV Episode 1956) Poster

(TV Series)

(1956)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Disrespecting Doc
wdavidreynolds17 December 2021
Ben Pitcher is a farmer who lives near Dodge City. For some reason the viewer never learns, Pitcher hates doctors. He sends his son Jerry to Dodge to ask Doctor Adams to come out to the farm due to illness. Matt Dillon is suspicious of this development, and he accompanies Doc to the Pitcher farm.

When Doc and Matt arrive, Ben tells Doc he has a sick cow. Doc is furious that he has been deceived into coming to the farm, but he treats the cow anyway. After he is finished, Jerry returns from his trip into town and tells Doc a woman in Dodge died from a cut on her arm in a freak accident. Doc is now even more angry at Pitcher, because he could have saved the woman from bleeding to death if he had not been called away. Pitcher is dismissive and spouts off that Doc couldn't have helped the woman, anyway. When Doc shoves Pitcher to the ground, Pitcher stabs Doc.

Now Doc is bleeding badly. Matt will have to tie off the blood vessels to stop the bleeding before Doc bleeds to death. Matt's amateur surgery is successful, and Matt transports Doc back to Dodge.

A few days later, Jerry Pitcher comes back to town to tell Doc his father is extremely ill. Doc is still in no condition to move, but he is determined to provide help where needed.

Robert H. Harris was a frequent guest on television dramas during the 1950s, '60s, and '70s. He plays the cantankerous Ben Pitcher in this episode. He only made one other Gunsmoke appearance, and it occurs later in Season 2. He can be seen in numerous episodes of other series such as Perry Mason, Have Gun - Will Travel, and 77 Sunset Strip.

Dorothy Adams appears in this episode as Mrs. Pitcher. She returned for one additional appearance in the series in Season 3.

Child actor Tommy Kirk portrays Jerry Pitcher in the only role he would play in the Gunsmoke series. At the time this episode was produced, Kirk had joined Walt Disney's The Mickey Mouse Club. He would go on to star in several popular Disney projects over the next ten years or so. As he grew into young adulthood, Kirk battled drug use and depression. Disney dropped him, and he resorted to accepting parts in b-grade movies before quitting acting. He returned to acting in the late 1980s, but he never regained the prominence he enjoyed in his teen years.

This Season 2 debut episode is the first directed by Andrew McLaglen. McLaglen would eventually direct a total of ninety-six episode of the series, the most of any director. (He holds the same record for the series Have Gun - Will Travel.)

One of the nicest attributes of this episode is the little glimpses of life in Dodge City. Chester escorting Kitty Russell to the Marshal's office to see Matt. Chester dropping hints that he wants to visit an old friend, and Matt playing along. The banter between Doc, Matt, and Kitty while they care for the recuperating doctor. These are all small scenes that add to the allure of the series and help the viewers become more endeared to the characters.

There is a nice mix of humor and drama included in this John Dunkel treatment of a John Meston story. The biting wit of Doc Adams contrasted with his dedication to his profession are on full display here, as they would be repeatedly over the course of the series.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
No Medicare on the Frontier
dougdoepke6 September 2011
This first entry of the second season is more a character study than gunplay. Doc's called out to Pitcher farm but ends up doctoring a cow instead of a human. He's not happy, especially after mean old Ben Pitcher (Harris) refuses to pay him. But turns out that's the least of Doc's worries in dealing with the ornery old cuss. Hard not to feel sorry for Pitcher's personable boy (Kirk) and haggard wife (Adams).

This is really Doc's episode, with Matt sort of tagging along. There's an extended opening byplay scene with Chester and Kitty—I expect to keep them in the picture to start the new season since they don't appear in the plot. Old man Pitcher has got to be one of the orneriest cusses of the whole series. If he's got a redeeming feature I can't find it. Nonetheless, a fine ending, hitting just the right note.

(In passing—this is one of the few instances of a "subjective" camera effect as Doc revives bleary eyed from unconsciousness. By and large, the half-hour series avoided anything but straight stories.)
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Doc takes the lead in this amusing story of life around Dodge.
kfo949426 May 2013
Doc Adams takes the lead in this excellent offering from the start of the second season where we start to concrete Doc's character. Doc still has not developed into a big teddy bear that we find in the later seasons but his oath as a doctor is as strong in the early shows as they were in the later ones.

In this episode, Doc is called out to the farm of Ben Pitcher who is a grouchy old Gus and no friend of Doc Adams. Matt rides out with Doc and they discover that Ben Pitcher wants Doc to check out his cow instead of a human. Ben even goes as far to say that Doc is only worthy of doctoring animals and not people. Well Doc goes ahead and checks the cow out before being told that someone in Dodge died because he was out at the Pitcher place looking at a cow. Doc strikes Ben Pitches with a fist then Ben stabs Doc with a knife. Doc is left with a gash in his abdomen.

While Doc is recovering, Ben's boy comes into Dodge saying that his father is very sick. Doc Adams, still recovering from his wound, must decide if Ben Pitcher is a person that needs help.

An excellent story that was entertaining. A well written script that was enjoyable right to the end. And even the end was not what the viewer expected as we learn some people are just not likable. Excellent watch.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A seemingly pointless episode...
AlsExGal11 July 2022
... because we already know what is revealed here about Doc Adams.-Though usually stoic he can be riled, and he takes his oath very seriously. Doc goes out on a case and finds a farmer who wants him to tend to his sick cow. He makes a point of saying that he would never trust a doctor to work on a human member of his family. While Doc is out there, a woman falls through a window in Dodge City and bleeds to death because Doc was not there. Doc is so mad when he hears the news that he punches the farmer, who reciprocates by stabbing him.

At the end of the show the farmer's wife says of her husband - who has stabbed Doc, insulted Doc, and says he will not pay Doc although Doc never brought up the subject of payment - that she is...proud to have him in her house??? The end??? What the???? Heck of a way to start off season two. In Gunsmoke's defense I will say that at this point the Gunsmoke team has been producing a new episode almost every week for a year. So maybe they are entitled to a dud after so much heavy duty production for so long.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Doc Treats A Cow
StrictlyConfidential5 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
(*Marshal Dillon quote*) - "There's nothing for you to do a round here, anyway."

"Cow Doctor" was first aired on television September 8, 1956.

Anyway - As the story goes - Doc suffers the loss of a human patient when he's unwittingly summoned to treat a rancher's cow.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Doc gives Mike Tyson a run for his money
LukeCoolHand14 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I have not seen every episode of Gunsmoke but this just might be the only one where Doc clobbers a man with his fist. I have seen him kill someone though which is rare for Doc.

Anyway, the man and wife in this episode are very despicable excuses for human beings. The husband stabs Doc after Doc clobbers him which the man richly deserved and then gets sick. Doc saves his life and then this horrible person tells Doc he is not going to pay because his cow died because Doc could not save him. I have seen every kind of terrible thug and killer Gunsmoke has to offer but this is the only person on the show I really wanted to put my fist through his face.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed