"ER" All in the Family (TV Episode 2000) Poster

(TV Series)

(2000)

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Beautifully Tragic Episode
fdm2589230 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
In a rare full cast episode, the ER team bind together in what I believe to be the first time in the whole of its fifteen year series in which we really see the bonds between the staff members of County General. It is therefore fitting that the episode title is "All in the Family"

As the maimed characters of Carter and Knight are found in the exam room, stabbed by a psychiatric patient, the ER is thrust into a frenzy and each team member shows their true colours as they run to the aid of their friends. Despite the doctors' efforts, they are not able to save Knight. Even though Kellie Martin's Knight only has one real speaking line, her portrayal of this med student in distress is very touching. Her eyes tell the whole story, we can see exactly how she is feeling about her situation through her body language.

The rest of the staff gather at the one social structure they have found in Doc Magoos and re-tell stories of Carter and Knight's few years as a student/mentor team. They laugh about the stories told and it seems that those telling and those listening are really bonding. They are a family, including Maura Tierney's Abby who only recently joined the cast a few episodes previously. This is cleverly portrayed by Kaplan's beautiful directorial work, the camera acts as one of the team members, at head height, blending in with the team.

Back in the OR, the tension between Romano and Corday in trying to save Knight's life is really exploded on screen. Despite their troubled relationship, when it comes down to it, they put the job first. Paul Mccrane's portrayal of the frustrated Romano is exceptional and we really see his emotional side for the first time.

A special mention must also go to Laura Innes in her playing of ER chief, Kerry Weaver. From the very first line, her acting is magnificent, riding a roller-coaster of emotions throughout the episode, showing her power over the ER staff, the anger she displays when confronting the staff for not knowing of the tragedy, the determination she has to save her student, the reluctance she has to drill open her chest and the total devastation she feels when Knight passes away. Innes has it all. Fantastic episode, fantastic cast!
46 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
All in the Family (#6.14)
ComedyFan20107 March 2015
Warning: Spoilers
The last episode ended in a horrifying way that made it impossible for one to wait for later to find out how it ends. And this one started on from there. The episode is absolutely high quality with amazing acting, story and outcome.

The finding of Carter and Lucy by Weaver alone was already greatly done. People having a party not suspecting anything and then her walking on them laying there in blood for hours. Laura Innes is always a great actress, but she sure got to show it a lot in this episode with her incredible emotional roller-coaster.

The whole episode is very intense as the staff has to save people who are very close to them, practically their work family. This is another thing that makes it so amazing, so much tension.

David Krumholtzalso does a great job as the schizophrenic who stabs Carter and Lucy. One actually sympathizes with him.

Watching Benton save Carter was also a great thing. Benton hasn't been his mentor forever, but one can still feel the special connection the two have which they perfectly showed in this episode.

Sad to see Lucy go! She was one of my favorite characters, there is so much more one could have done with her. But she left the show in the best way ever. This is a very memorable episode and greatly done. Kellie Martin played the final time of Lucy very well.
33 out of 34 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Grey's Anatomy Producers take note....
slak96u25 February 2022
This is how you do a character death. Also key, it rarely happened on ER, which magnified the feeling of shock and loss. Magnificent hour of television, this and Labours Lost are the best of the series.
31 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best of the series
jmbrunet19 September 2021
By far the best episode of the series. Don't watch it without seeing the previous episode!
23 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Powerful Television At Its Best!
spasek26 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I still recall vividly the first time I saw this episode when it aired. It was unlike anything I'd seen on television before. It was so powerful and poignant, that even seeing it again moves me inexplicably.

Dr. Carter and Lucy Knight have just been brutally stabbed by a psych patient. This occurs at the very end of the previous episode. So, imagine waiting an entire week to find out what happens next! This was one of the biggest cliff-hangers that I can remember, and everyone made sure they were available to watch this episode to find out what was going to happen to Carter and Lucy. Very few people foresaw what transpired.

The entire ER springs to action when Dr. Weaver discovers them on the floor in the trauma room lying in pools of blood. There's nothing like a team coming together for a single purpose, especially when that purpose is dire. There is something especially powerful in such actions. Virtually the entire episode is devoted to trying to save Carter and Lucy.

Benton is nearly out of control when he discovers that Carter has been injured. Perhaps for the first time in the series, we really see and understand how the usually emotionally cold Dr. Benton feels about Carter. It's on his face and in his actions. As Benton tries to assure Carter that he will be all right, Carter says in a cracking voice, "I'm glad it's you," when he realizes that Benton is going to operate on him. That single line chokes me up every time as you can feel the love between these two characters.

Equally strong is Dr. Corday and Dr. Romano working feverishly to save Lucy's life. Dr. Romano, who seems to care about no one at all, can't even hide his anger, frustration, and grief when it's clear that Lucy can't be saved. In many ways, Romano is the doctor who speaks for the audience. Seeing this episode for the first time, it was unbelievable that Lucy was dead. It wasn't often that a major character was killed in an on-going series, and so Romano expresses his anger and disbelief for us, and he does it well as he sends surgical instruments flying across the room.

Just when you think that ER can no longer surprise you, they came up with this episode. Word has it that Kellie Martin no longer felt comfortable being on the show as her own real-life sister was a traumatic victim of lupus.

You have to credit the writers for coming up with this episode. Very few, if any, characters up to this point in television history have had such a powerful and heart-wrenching exit as Kellie's character here on ER. I recall the following Friday everyone talking about it.

There have been previous events in ER that were terrific episodes, and there were even a couple more that would follow after Season 6, but "All in the Family" is still the premiere ER episode that truly defines the pinnacle of a great drama series.
20 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Have admit this one still gets me after all these years Warning: Spoilers
I'm binge watching the show from start to finish in 2022. Saw this episode the first time it aired and the loss of a main character never bothered me as much as this one. Credit to KM for her excellent portrayal of her character and making me tear up a little with her demise.
19 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
All in the Family
amofber28 March 2006
Warning: Spoilers
When Kerry comes into work to find a Valentines party still going she starts getting people back to work. The ER is slow, and so are the doctors in discovering Dr. Carter and Lucy both stabbed and bleeding to death in one of the trauma rooms, after previously being stabbed by a psych patient, one episode earlier. The ER springs into action to save their fellow co-workers who have both lost a lot of blood. Even Greene and Corday are called to the ER from a date they are having with their parents. While both sustain serious injuries, only Carter survives. The ER starts to get back to normal as each attending takes a moment for themselves. Carter talks to Benton in the end to discover Lucy is dead, and that he will make a complete recovery. The ER staff one-by-one learns of Lucy's fate and realize they must continue one staff member less.
25 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Previous episode cliffhanger ending, is a classic.
m-4782629 December 2022
Warning: Spoilers
That's the thing that make ER the best medical drama. They know how to build up the tension, intense scenes need to provide. With just the right amount of shock, and without overdoing it. The way you could feel the knife, plunging into Carter's back. The loud music, Lucy lying on the floor, numb and petrified. Everything was disturbing in that scene. But this episode, is where we get all the elements in check. And it is pretty gripping, even when you know who's going to die. I wish I watched it, the first time it aired on TV. And feel the anxiety of not knowing. But the acting and thorough writing, make up for that. It's the kind of episode that could've been over the top, and heavy handed on the drama and suspense. But it looks believable, and you feel each of the characters confusion. They tried to release the tension, here and there, but it's the violence of the attack, and its aftermath. That stands out and gets you glued to your screen. Just like when Mark was beaten in season 3, it's one of those ER moments that caught you off guard, and you enjoyed every seconds of it. Did I forgot to mention Deb (aka Jing-Mei) was back? Liza Weil and David Krumholtz also star.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Predictably bigott
gacsogergely23 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
So, we have two patient, both from the crew, having the same inhury.

Anyone want to bet one will live, the other die?

Anyone want to make a bet the character - marked as Evil Athiest - who refused telling a prayer at an unknown worldview patient's funeral will be the dead one?

The directing and script is also very dumb. Like Lucy gets stub. Carter goes in the dark room and gets stab. Then Weaver goes into the still dark room, noticing a bloody footprint - still does not call for guard... What am I watching, Scary Movie?
2 out of 127 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed