"Doctor Who" The Ice Warriors: Episode One (TV Episode 1967) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Introducing The Ice Warriors
Theo Robertson19 August 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Refers to all six episodes of which only four remain

An excess of carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere means that the Earth is plunged in to another Ice age . People are evacuated to rehabilitation camps in Africa as scientists try to use an ioniser to hold back the ice flow . The Tardis lands outside an isolated base and the Doctor and his companions are in danger of being evacuated . Meanwhile a expedition party find a body encased in ice and take it back to base

If the BBC hadn't committed a cultural atrocity such as deleting much of the Troughtin era of DOCTOR WHO one that would have been noticeable about season five is how formulaic the stories and with the exception of the political thriller The Enemy Of The World all the stories revolve around " the base under siege " type story with only the time period and location changing . Some people might moan about a lack of variety but if something is done well then that shouldn't matter and I love these type of horror stories and the loss of episodes 2to 6 of The Web Of Fear is sadly missed .

The Ice Warriors continues the horror feel of the show with eponymous monsters from Mars and right from the opening credits the story tells the audience what might be in store for them by having a unique title sequence with cold images of frozen landscapes with an unearthly choral soundtrack that this story might just be a little bit special . It's not all that special ( Bare with me ) but does manage to spin a out a different take on the formula that keeps things fresh . It's noticeable that director Derek Martinus uses a bit too much close ups to disguise the limitation of the sets but scenes such as the avalanche in episode one are very effective and convincing

The Ice Warriors themselves are very memorable monsters and while never being as famous as the Daleks and Cybermen they were popular enough to be brought back three more times in the classic show and once so far in NuWho . Brian Hayles has managed to not to portray them as one note monsters there simply to kill the human characters but having motives for doing things . They are if not a fascist race certainly a militaristic one but also a group of aliens who are just wanting to get back to their home world only to find obstacles in their way in the shape of humans . Executing someone because they're a scavenger rather than a scientist isn't all that different from a slightly more extreme version of Darwin's law of natural selection

What stops The Ice Warriors from being a masterpiece of its era - apart from it being surround by Tomb Of The Cybermen and Web Of Fear - is a couple of obvious flaws . One is the costume design which is pure 60s psychedelia with multi swirling patterned tunics and mini skirts for the females " Did ya see what those lassies were wearing " asks Jamie . Difficult for any red blooded male not to notice . but it's hardly sensible wear in an ice age . Some of the cast are dreadful and while it's good to see Peter Sallis Angus Lennie as Storr is distracting . He's best known for his role as Shughie McFee in CROSSROADS and gives a performance worthy of that legendary bad show . Some people might that the science of too much carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has the opposite effect and is the cause of global warming but if memory serves me right up until the late 1970s scientists were claiming too much CO2 was going to plunge us back to another ice age

In all The Ice Warriors is a very good story . Of course being a fan of the show I knew all about before I saw it for the first time recently but still found myself enjoying it despite knowing the upcoming plot turns while noticing some glaring flaws to the production which says a lot about the strength of the stronger aspects of the story . It's a claustrophobic story featuring memorable well written monsters . What more could you want ? Well apart from episodes 2 and 3
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The arrival of The Ice Warriors.
Sleepin_Dragon24 February 2020
The Earth is in the grip on another Ice age, man is attempting to survive, but struggling against the elements, The Doctor, Jamie and Victoria arrive at one of the control bases, just as an excavation team discover a giant being, frozen in the snow.

A good solid first episode, which has enough going on to hold your interest, the Earth's climate is out of control, food and shelter are a major issue, it seems the elements are winning. At the head of the team is Clent, being a big fan of Peter Barkworth I'm of course enjoy watching him here, he interacts very well with Trioghton. The companions are put to good use once again.

Another six part serial, and the creation of yet another menace we want to see featured in the returned show, the iconic Ice Warriors, although here, we only glimpse the Giant.

Very atmospheric, nice effects, it's a very good start. 8/10
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Iceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee Warriors...
wetmars1 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The TARDIS arrives on Earth in a new ice age. The travellers make their way into a base where scientists, commanded by Leader Clent, are using an ioniser device to combat the advance of a glacier.

A giant humanoid creature, called an Ice Warrior by one of the scientists, has been found buried in the nearby glacier. When thawed, it revives and is revealed to be Varga, captain of a Martian spacecraft that landed on Earth centuries ago and is still in the glacier. Varga sets about freeing his comrades and formulating a plan to conquer the Earth - Mars itself is now dead.

The scientists realise that continued use of the ioniser could make the ship's engines explode. Their computer is unable to advise them without more information. Disaster seems imminent. The disaffected scientist Penley, supported by the Second Doctor, decides to risk activating the ioniser. There is only a minor explosion which destroys the Martians and, at the same time, checks the ice flow.

Review of all six episodes -

At last, we first meet the Ice Warriors, would be bone of the iconic Doctor Who monsters who will later appear in The Seeds of Death, The Curse of Peladon, The Monster of Peladon, Cold War, and especially Empress of Mars.

I'm not a big fan of this story for obvious reasons; Victoria screaming all over the place, Jamie doing nothing in "a" Moonbase vibe if you probably know what I mean by that. I do enjoy the Ice Warriors hissing. It's quite relaxing like ASMR. I also like the theme here for the Ice Warriors. There's not much to say about this episode.

7/10.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Icy but super hot - this is a fantastic production and a real classic
A_Kind_Of_CineMagic1 September 2014
Review of all 6 episodes:

This is a tremendous production in all respects. The costumes really stand out straight away as superb and believable. They are stylishly and expertly made especially for the humans and also for the Ice Warriors. The acting and characterisation are of a high standard throughout with guest parts well written and acted providing realistic and interesting characters. The Ice Warriors are brilliant, the TARDIS crew main cast are on great form and the script is fantastic. The story itself is great fun with plenty of action but also intelligent and thoughtful science fiction. There are ideas of humans over-reliance on machines, people torn between just running away from a system they dislike or fighting to change it, relationships with aliens (those different to us) and the threat of war and moral questions which result. More than that though it is just a fine example of a very well produced, exciting story with great villains and three dimensional characters.

I really could not disagree more (and frankly do not understand) a review I read on here giving this a very cool (pardon the pun) reception. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but the only direct criticism I could spot in that review was to say this is somewhat copied from the story of The Thing From Another World, other than that they just say it did not grab them. Well if this does not grab you I suggest Doctor Who will never rate well for you. This is top notch Doctor Who, and that is a view supported by its high rating on IMDb and by reviews by Doctor Who specialist reviewers such as the BBC Episode Guide. To say it is like The Thing From Another World is not entirely wrong in that the story contains an alien preserved in ice which is then thawed out but would that reviewer criticise The Brain of Morbius (widely considered one of the best ever stories) because it vaguely copies the premise of Frankenstein?! I am not a fan at all of copying other people's ideas or derivative stories. However, this is not derivative it purely shares an aspect of that story just as the ideas of nearly every science fiction story all share some aspect or other with at least one other story. The Borg in Star Trek for instance are quite close in concept to the Cybermen (and all cyborgs in sci- fi) but it does not make them rubbish because they are done differently enough and are good in their own right.

This story over its 6 episodes has way more going for it and way more ideas than just the alien in the ice premise. It is a perfect example of an alien menace adventure. The only significant flaw for me is a tiny bit of the scientific explanation regarding the ice age in Episode 1.

My Ratings: Episode 1 - 9/10, Episodes 2-6 - 10/10
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Arctic Ice, Green Warriors In Black & White
timdalton00718 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
(Note: A review of the six episode serial.)

Doctor Who's fifth season is an interesting one. Essentially one long series of "base under siege" stories, it was the season that gave the series many of its iconic monsters. Coming smack dab in the middle of it, and just before the monster-less The Enemy Of The World, came The Ice Warriors. With the titular creatures still appearing in the series as recently as Peter Capaldi's final season, it's safe to say that they've become mainstays across TV and spin-off media. How does their debut story stand up after fifty-one years?

Thankfully, with the 2013 DVD release, we can watch the story again in full. With two of its six episodes long missing from the BBC archives, judging the story hasn't been an easy task despite surviving audio and the stills reconstruction done in 1998. The 2013 DVD release offered up the two missing episodes (two and three, respectively) as animations. The black and white stories suit animation rather well, especially given that Patrick Troughton's Second Doctor is well suited to the caricaturing animation requires. Unfortunately, the animation for The Ice Warriors is the weakest seen to date in the Classic Who DVD range with characters feeling more like paper dolls with painted faces at times with odd limb movements (see Jamie being knocked out by an Ice Warrior moments into episode two). Despite that weakness, the animation completes the story and allows us a better idea of what the story was like before being wiped and junked by the BBC.

For starters, it has a solid premise. Brian Hayles' script contains a fair share of interesting ideas and themes brought nicely to life by the production team. The story, set at a base in Britain in a future time where ecological disaster threatens, is as solid premise in 2018 as it was in 1967. Even more so when one considers that the base under siege is run and populated by people using a technology that not only offers salvation but over-reliance. There's even Storr, a character that willfully denounces science as evil despite the evidence around him of disaster (with intriguing consequences). These elements almost make this a story one which is better suited for our time rather than the summer of 1967.

Where Hayles' script is very much of its time is in how it unfolds. Like virtually all of the stories from Classic Who's fifth season, it's six episodes long. Unlike, say, The Enemy Of The World or Fury From The Deep, it also feels like it. There is an inordinate amount of wheel spinning going on throughout with characters consulting computers, sojourns back and forth to the Ice Warriors ship, and base commander Clent (Peter Barkworth) alternating between bravado and insecurity. Even watching the story an episode or two at a time (while keeping in mind viewers saw one episode a week in 1967), one can't escape the sometimes thin plotting by Hayles.

Thankfully, the story has other things going for it such as the titular creatures from Mars. Watching the story, it isn't hard to see why the Ice Warriors have remained as popular as they have. From the moment the warrior Varga comes out of the ice, they have an immediate presence. Towering over the rest of the cast and armed with thin but hissing voices, they exude menace and strength. Even if they have Lego hands and stomp along, that doesn't dimish their presence. Indeed, they help keep interest in a sometimes flagging plot which makes them all the more memorable.

The story also benefits from its performers. The casting is solid from the TARDIS crew down with Troughton's Doctor getting to shine from the moment he climbs out of the TARDIS to various confrontations and conversations. Though the story sidelines Frazer Hines' Jamie in its back half, the upshot is an increased role for Deborah Watling as Victoria though she is reduced once more to sobbing and screaming at times. The supporting cast is strong as well with Peter Barkworth's leader Clent, Wendy Gifford as his willing aide Miss Garrett, and Peter Sallis as the brilliant but disaffected scientist Penley being particular highlights. They bring Hayles' script to life nicely, breathing life into sometimes thin characterizations.

The story also benefits from being a solid production. The design work of Jeremy Davies creates setting ranging from a Victorian house overrun with (by 1960s standards) futuristic technology to icy wastelands and a Martian spaceship. While the technology may look dated, the sets do not, creating a believable setting for the story. Dudley Simpson's score is full moments of menace and intrigue, creating one of his most memorable scores in the process. With director Derek Martinus at the helm, the story is elevated as a result though it never overcomes the flaws in its pacing or plotting.

That last sentence is as good a description of the story as I can present. The Ice Warriors has plenty of good things to say for it, the introduction of the Martians being amongst them. Ultimately, despite its strengths, it can't overcome the need to stretch things out that harms a fair few of Classic Who's longer stories. It's a solid story, but, it could have been a great one.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Anachronisms Usually Bug Me...However...
WarrenPiecz20 December 2014
Well, first, let me say I'm not a huge fan of anime, but if this is the only way I'd ever be able to see this classic story, then so be it. For anyone curious, "Ice Warriors" has just been released on DVD...missing episodes were re-created utilizing the original audio, and the action was cartoonified.

The story itself is standard base-attacked-by-aliens. I've always felt that the Ice Warriors were one of the more well-realized monsters of this era, and this is certainly no exception (for contrast, please see the 5-foot-tall prawn in the Tom Baker era).

Now...as I said earlier, I usually bristle at ridiculous anachronisms in TV and film. In a rare shift of acceptance, I have to honestly say that smokin' 60's babes running around an Antarctic sub-station wearing mini-mini-mini skirts is OK with me!
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Neat little story for Patrick Troughton's doctor
Leofwine_draca28 May 2017
Warning: Spoilers
THE ICE WARRIORS is a DR WHO story and vehicle for Patrick Troughton's Doctor, travelling alongside his companions Jamie and Victoria. In this episode they end up at a research institute in the snow, one that's trying to prevent the progress of a glacier working its way toward them. In a twist seemingly borrowed from THE THING FROM ANOTHER WORLD, they discover a body encased in the ice, a body which soon turns out to belong to a very much alive Ice Warrior intent on domination.

This six-part story remains pretty watchable in an era in which many of the DR WHO episodes seem dated and occasionally unwatchable for modern viewers. Troughton is a bit annoying here in terms of his hyperactivity but you do get supporting actors like Peter Sallis, Peter Barkworth, and even Bernard Bresslaw as the chief villain of the piece which engages things somewhat. The usual run of cliffhangers, near death experiences, and scientific jargon discussions ensue, and it's all handled quite neatly on an obviously low budget.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
"I think it's disgusting wearing that sort of 'thing'." Classic Doctor Who.
poolandrews8 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Doctor Who: The Ice Warriors: One (on screen it just says 'One' & unusually doesn't have an 'Episode' prefix) is set sometime in the future on Earth during a new & potentially catastrophic ice age, the TARDIS arrives & the Doctor (Patrick Troughton) along with his companions Jamie (Frazer Hines) & Victoria (Deborah Watling) enter a converted Georgian mansion that has been turned into scientific research station called the Brittanicus Ice Base where lead scientist Jan Garrett (Wendy Gifford) & her colleagues are struggling to control a device called an Ioniser which they are using to harness the suns rays in an attempt to melt the huge ice glaciers that are engulfing the Earth. Meanwhile a scientist named Arden (George Waring) has discovered a large humanoid like creature which he calls an 'Ice Warrior' frozen deep in the ice outside, after excavating it Arden takes it back to Brittanicus Base where it begins to thaw...

Episode 11 from season 5 this Doctor Who adventure originally aired here in the UK during November 1967 & was Patrick Troughton's third story from his second season playing the Doctor, during the tape wiping's & junking's carried out by the BBC during the 70's many Doctor Who episodes & indeed complete stories were lost & Troughton's time as the Doctor suffered in particular. As a result of these junking's all six episodes of The Ice Warriors were destroyed although miraculously 16mm telerecordings of episodes one, four, five & six were discovered at Villiers House a former home of BBC Enterprises (who handled worldwide distribution of BBC programs) in the late 80's apparently behind a filing cabinet. Anyway here it is, directed by Derek Martinus I thought this was OK but didn't really capture my imagination that much or was anything that memorable. The script by Brian Hayles is more or less a The Thing From Another World (1951) rip-off & the glaring similarities are there to see, this also marked the debut of the Ice Warriors & they would be used several other times in different stories, here they don't affect the action because they are almost totally absent from this episode since one is frozen in a block of ice for it's duration. The script has a slight ecological feel as Earth's future is under jeopardy in this story because of mans meddling with nature, The Ice Warriors wasn't the first program to try & warn of the dangers of global warming & it certainly won't be the last. An OK time waster but nothing spectacular.

The VHS version released in 1998 had a short filmed introduction by Frazer Hines & Deborah Watling (who still seems uncomfortable in front of a camera) who don't really say anything worthwhile, they also filmed linking narration for episodes two & three as these episodes are still lost. For some strange reason the TARDIS doors open outwards in this episode. The one thing that stood out for me in The Ice Warriors is the mark contrast between the classic Gerogian period house setting & the futuristic computer equipment inside, I personally thought it was a very jarring & ill-fitting contrast & didn't like it all. The other thing is that I presume it's supposed to be very cold with snow storms & ice glaciers but whenever anyones outside they have no face masks, gloves which expose their bare fingers & really thin looking clothing. I'm not being funny but I think a human being would freeze to death in temperatures like that without proper insulating clothing, wouldn't they?

The Ice Warriors: One is alright, I just felt like it was a pretty standard The Thing From Another World rip-off although I am sure that the following five episodes does it's own thing & this initial episode is the 'hook' to get you interested. As already mentioned both episodes two & three no longer exist (apart from audio reconstructions which don't count to me) so I will continue my comments from episode four through to the end.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed