Plot

Cheryl and Larry head to Monterey to attend her sister Becky's wedding... to a Jewish man who's converting to Christianity. When Larry misplaces the plane tickets, he accuses other passengers of stealing them.

Cheryl makes Larry get rid of his old maroon jacket that Larry had had since his Seinfeld days. He used to wear the jacket on show nights. Cheryl makes Larry give the jacket to a homeless person.

As Larry enters his office building, he notices that a man saw him punch in the security codes. Richard Lewis accuses Larry of stealing his outgoing answering-machine greeting. Richard makes Larry change his message in front of him. Larry changes the outgoing message for his home phone, from the office. Cheryl is concerned about whether he did that properly.

Cheryl and Larry head to Monterey, California to attend her sister's Becky's (Kaitlin Olson) wedding. Larry is peeved that the man (Mitchell Whitfield) Cheryl's sister is marrying is a Hebrew man converting to Christianity. He will undergo a baptism to complete the conversion ceremony. But Larry has even bigger fish to fry when he misplaces his plane tickets. He believes that the tickets are at the office, but he cannot find them there. He thinks that the man who saw him punch the security codes to his office building, got into the building later and stole the tickets.

Cheryl and Larry head to the airport, since the airline call center is useless and can't help Cheryl. Larry decides to drive, against Cheryl's advise to take a car service. At the airport, Larry can't find parking. Larry and Cheryl are late to the gate and the ticketing counter has a long queue. Larry tries to cut to the front of the line but is asked to get in line and wait for his turn. Larry starts to scan fellow passengers to see if he can find the man whom he thinks stole the tickets.

Larry questions 2 suspects. Larry thinks he recognizes the man who stole his tickets. But it is not the same person. This guy lost his mother and is travelling to Monterey for her funeral. The second person doesn't know what Larry is talking about. Larry is at a dead end.

The flight departs by the time Larry reaches the front of the ticketing queue. Larry now has to get tickets to San Francisco, and then drive 100 miles to his destination, to be able to attend the baptism in time.

Larry then finds that the message he changed on the answering machine, didn't work, and now the phone was not going to the answering machine. Cheryl & Larry get lost while driving from San Francisco to Monterey. They eventually get to the wedding venue. Larry gets down from the car for directions & down a steep ledge, in the river, sees one man trying to drown another. He screams bloody murder, during which one of the guys floats away. Turns out the guy who floated away is the groom and it is the baptism and now the whole wedding party has to get into the river to rescue him. Becky is livid at Larry for interrupting the baptism. Larry says that he didn't know what a baptism looked like. The groom's family is thankful to Larry. The priest wants the groom to go back to complete the baptism (the groom did 1 dunk in the water, and he needs 3 dunks to complete the baptism). The groom refuses to go through the conversion. Larry is blamed for it. The wedding is off and Becky is super angry at Larry.

Larry gets back home, and the tickets were in the maroon jacket that Cheryl gave away to a homeless guy. The homeless guy meets Cheryl and tells her that he tried to call but the phone machine was not working.