"Charmed" Freaky Phoebe (TV Episode 2005) Poster

(TV Series)

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
The Good, the Bad, and the very, very, very Ugly
owlaurence25 July 2008
Warning: Spoilers
There's nothing really outstanding about this episode. I appreciate the idea of a vain demon (and I had to ensure that no, the actress playing Imara didn't really look like that...) but this is the stuff of an earlier, lighter season. And really, we've already been there, done that, so even though it has some enjoyable parts, it gets tired rather quickly as we wait for someone to realize that Phoebe isn't Phoebe... to no end. She's right : her sisters really sucked this time. On the contrary, she did a rather good job of impersonating a demon (but then, she did spend some time playing Queen of the Underworld years ago). And her going back to college should give her a pleasant change of scenery, since we've pretty much exhausted everything that could be done at the Bay Mirror (as the unfortunate and really silly plot with the psychologist shows).

Paige, now. Her first "real" charge is a reluctant, rude ex-Whitelighter who is ignoring his calling because of a past tragedy. But wait. Isn't that the exact description of her first "real" charge from years ago (in Sam I Am) ??? So here again, although that side-plot is watchable, it really feels like it's been unfrozen and microwaved once too many.

Apart from that, nice to show how great Leo is doing at the Magic School. And it's also clever to bring Sheridan back by degrees, instead of having her come back with a vengeance. I am looking forward to seeing how that thread is tied up.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Season 7 is ending on a high note.
m-478269 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Everything post the 150th episode was great. Good storylines, well-written, solid cast. One of both finally had Collective Soul performing at P3. And Paige's big break happening. There were two good episodes, the kind that makes Charmed not a show you can give up on completely. Freaky Phoebe, is the first good Phoebe centric episode since Prue was killed off. It's fun, funny and witty. With Alyssa Milano finally impersonating an evil character again, and not sounding like a ten year old inside a thirty something woman's body. Seamus Dever and Suzanne Krull shined. Too bad they never came back. Obviously that pill inspector Sheridan keeps harassing the sisters, but who can blame her? They keep making all these rookie mistakes lately... I still think season 7 should've been it, as everything and all loose ends seem to be wrapped as the end of the season approaches. But I also understand why the network decided to keep on with the adventures for one more year. There's a real last minute improvement there.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed