"The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes" The Final Problem (TV Episode 1985) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
The Finest Man I Have Ever Known.
rmax30482329 March 2010
Warning: Spoilers
It was supposed to really be Sherlock Holmes' "final problem." Conan-Doyle fully intended to have Holmes and Moriarty locked in a death grip and falling into the Reichenbach Falls. Conan-Doyle was an ambitious writer and had grown tired of milking his cash cow for all those years. He had better, longer things in mind -- and he produced them too, only nobody remembers "The White Company." But when the story was published, such an outcry was raised against the ending that Holmes was brought ashore, an IV drip was initiated, CPR was applied, the Heimlich maneuver exercised, a chi square one-sample test and principal component analysis computed, a quick Coombs test done, his troubling archetypes disposed of by Dr. Carl Jung, and finally the Holger Nielsen method of artificial respiration brought the detective back from the brink and he lived to soldier on in stories of declining interest.

This particular tale, Holmes' apparent death aside, has some unique elements. For one thing there is occasional narration by Watson and, in the final shot, he actually turns and addresses the audience. Then, too, the final sequence was filmed on location in Switzerland and the majestic landscape is caught in swooping helicopter shots. And the real Reichenbach Falls is featured in the climax, although care had to be taken not to put onto the screen any of the modern facilities that are to be found there. (Brett and Burke both stayed at The Hotel Sherlock Holmes.) Finally, that drop down the face of the falls is extremely well done. Two stuntmen were lowered on thin wire cables by winches. The drop was done at about 30 miles an hour and stopped only a few feet above the water.

A sad ending shouldn't keep anyone from seeing this episode, especially since you now know it was fraudulent, if you didn't before.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An Early Fall!
Hitchcoc7 February 2014
For those who really love the Sherlock Holmes stories, this one is where we have our radar up, watching intently to see if the writers and directors have done it justice. Holmes' adversary, Moriarity (played with panache by Eric Porter), has been presented as the equal of Holmes and he and his henchmen have as much at stake as the great detective. Holmes often remarks that the world is lucky that he (Holmes) never decided to turn to crime. After a nice presentation of the evil of his arch rival, Holmes meets him in Switzerland at the Reichenbach Falls. Part of the joy of this episode (and it is really well done) is that for his encounter, he must part ways with Watson and go it on his own. This is out of love as well as practicality. The scenery is breathtaking. If one has never seen the beauty of the Alps, the wonderful scenery contrasts the evil of Moriarity. Conan Doyle was tired of Holmes because he was being judged for only one part of his work. This, of course, sets up the next set of episodes.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
One of Granada's Strongest Episodes
ericksonsam607 February 2012
Warning: Spoilers
A beautiful and poignant finale for the "Adventures" volume in the series. The story is dynamic and compelling with wonderful changes in scenery going from France to London and then to Switzerland. The photography and production in particular is quite lovely. Eric Porter is very effective as Professor Moriarty. The somber climax at Reichenbach Falls is moving. The music at that particular moment is brilliant. This story was originally Arthur Conan Doyle's way of ending his Sherlock Holmes stories by killing him off but brought him back after popular demand. It leaves a powerful impression after it is over, even if one knows the ending.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Most Excellent Dramatization of Sherlock Holmes! Perfection! Flawless!
gc12351720 October 2007
Well, I just watched this 1984 Granada production in October 2007 having read the Adventures of Sherlock Holmes in the late 1990's. And I must say that not only was the screenplay as faithful to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's story as you could get - it was an absolutely faithful production. For anyone who has read "The Final Problem", you will know that this is a very special and perhaps the most significant Sherlock Holmes tale. To those who are unfamiliar with the story, I shall be careful not to convey spoilers which will diminish the key plot points for you. But let me say that this tale takes Holmes and Watson beyond the bounds of England to face a formidable enemy, and in doing so expresses the depths of the friendship between Holmes and Watson, while also showing some spectacular scenery. Every minute detail was vividly shown and expressed, and I ACTUALLY applauded Granada at the conclusion of this episode, because their standards of quality and faithfulness to every detail of the story and characters is absolutely flawless. Bravo Granada! Bravo!
40 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Not only one of the best of the series but also one of the most special too
TheLittleSongbird3 June 2011
As I have said many, many times I am a fan of the Granada Sherlock Holmes adaptations. I love how well made they are, I love the sophisticated stories and writing, I love the music and as much as I do like Basil Rathbone(a lot actually) I consider Jeremy Brett the best Sherlock Holmes.

The Final Problem is for me one of the best and most special of the series. And although that's part of why, it's not only because it has Holmes and Moriaty and a final ten minutes or so that will delight any Holmes or Conan Doyle fan.

The Final Problem also has a loyal and thoughtful script, and the story is thrilling with seldom a dull spot. The adaptation has some of the most beautiful scenery in any of these Granada adaptations, and it is beautifully shot as well. The music score is also one of my favourites in the series, the final moments are orchestrated beautifully especially as if in a reflective and doubtful way, and the direction is reliable.

Jeremy Brett gives a commanding performance as always in the titular role and David Burke is a more than a perfect match for him. Moriaty is also very effectively portrayed by Eric Porter as well. All in all, wonderful and will be always be very special to me. 10/10 Bethany Cox
32 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Captivating and honest adaptation.
Sleepin_Dragon14 June 2019
The Final Problem is without a shadow of a doubt one of the best episodes of Brett's Sherlock Holmes, and arguably one of the finest productions to feature Holmes.

The script is terrific, and hugely faithful to the book. Burke's narration throughout is a real highlight in what would sadly be his last appearance as Watson. The location work is breathtaking, it looks imposing, dramatic and wonderful throughout, overall it feels big budget.

The best aspects of this episode though, without any doubt are the performances of Jeremy Brett and Eric Porter, the pair individually are astonishing, but together they are beyond compare, with some incredible scenes.

Flawless. 10/10
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The confrontation with the Napoleon Of Crime
suicidea22 January 2021
The Mona Lisa is stolen, a crime orchestrated by Professor Moriarty to sell dozens of imitations for millions. When Holmes recovers the original, it urges the Professor to take the ultimate step to get rid of his rival.

Eric Porter is truly intimidating as Moriarty, and this final episode of the series is filled with great moments of delight. It's the last episode with David Burke as Dr. Watson, before he's replaced by Edward Hardwicke in the following series. This episode has some of the best scenery and score of the series. The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes really ends on a high note.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Sleuth
jerseygirl49-674-59955921 February 2022
Jeremy Brett will forever be the quintessential Holmes! He Is magnificent portraying the elusive genius of Holmes like no other! He lives on forever in the hearts of Sherlock Holmes fans!
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Holmes the superhero
vitoscotti11 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Way, way way over the top excellent episode. Holmes in now almost a comic book like story, and he's the superhero fighting crime. And wow does it click on all levels.

Watching midway I thought how could the end live up to this amazing point so far? Then, the ending is even better. Holmes treks all over Europe, and Moriarty is a blood hound on his track. Holmes (a heavy smoker) and Watson trevail the Alps on long hikes, following intricate paths in yes, their street clothes and shoes. They always find their destination dodging cliffs, and waterfalls. Never get winded, sweaty, or wet. Always behind the scenes secret Moriarty now is in the open Alps following behind.

Holmes & Moriarty fight scene is ridiculous. The two now immobile brawlers having a challenge of strength to keep from falling. Images are superimposed on the waterfall falling to their demise.

Thrilling, total satisfying stellar episode. Other then a 10 rating never crossed my mind.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Gripping finale
grantss29 November 2022
Holmes is hired by the French government. The unthinkable has occurred: the Mona Lisa has been stolen from the Louvre. In his inimitable fashion, Holmes manages to solve the crime but this creates another problem: Professor Moriarty was behind the attempt to steal the Mona Lisa and is out for deadly vengeance. Moriarty may well be Holmes's final problem.

A fittingly gripping finale to the series. After being introduced to Professor Moriarty in the previous episode he now becomes the focal point of this episode. While Holmes is intellectually Moriarty's equal, if not superior, Moriarty has means at his disposal, violent means, that Holmes cannot counter. This makes for a very tense cat-and-mouse game and a thrilling conclusion.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Mother Of Mercy, Is This The End Of Mr. Holmes?
bkoganbing17 March 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Like so many artists, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle grew bored with his creation and the incessant demands it made on him. Being the creative guy he was he longed to move on. The Final Problem was supposed to kill off Holmes by having him fight to the death with a man of equal intelligence and cunning Professor Moriarty.

No less than the French government hires Jeremy Brett as Holmes to find the stolen Mona Lisa before it becomes a public scandal. Holmes smells the hand of London's Godfather behind it, but also sees an opportunity to smash his criminal ring once and for all.

He succeeds, but he leaves a vengeful Moriarty behind who wants equally to rid London's criminals of their greatest antagonist. So Brett and David Burke as Watson take holiday in Switzerland to put the confrontation on neutral ground so to speak.

But poor Conan Doyle caved into the demands of his public and resurrected Holmes for a whole lot more stories. In fact the only change here is that of the surviving Dr. Watson who was replaced in the next batch of stories done by Grenada by Edward Hardwicke.

Eric Porter is close to what Conan Doyle had in mind for Moriarty, but I prefer Henry Daniell as the best Moriarty of all.

Knowing the history as I do, the episode is not one of the better ones in the long series.
8 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Final Problem
Prismark1023 March 2019
There is a cinematic element to The Final Problem as Holmes faces grave dangers to his life from Moriarty's henchmen right from the beginning.

The Mona Lisa has been stolen and the French authorities have bought in Sherlock Holmes.

Moriarty plans to use the story of the theft to sell expertly forged copies. However his plans are scuppered by the meddling detective.

Holmes and Watson flee to the continent with Moriarty giving chase. There is an encounter between the two at Reichenbach Falls.

Looking back at this know it is astonishing how I have not got used to younger version of the characters in the modern take of Sherlock and the Robert Downey Sherlock Holmes films. Porter really does look old in the part and it shows when the two men grapple when the fight scenes should be more punchy.

Dr Watson breaks the fourth wall and talks to the audience at the end of the episode.

Sadly this was David Burke's final episode as Watson. He decided to concentrate on theatre and spend time raising his young son. I always liked Burke's interpretation of Watson and preferred his version more than Edward Hardwicke's.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed