Saving Shiloh (2006) Poster

(2006)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Truly Moving Picture
tollini6 April 2006
I saw this film on April 5th, 2006 in Indianapolis. I am one of the judges for the Heartland Film Festival's Truly Moving Picture Award. A Truly Moving Picture "…explores the human journey by artistically expressing hope and respect for the positive values of life." Heartland gave that award to this film.

This film is about a 12 year old boy growing up and coming of age in a small, picturesque town in the Midwest. Even though his family is of modest means, he has an ideal life with a loving family consisting of his father, mother, two little sisters, and his beagle dog, Shiloh.

The boy takes on a challenge. He befriends an old, cantankerous man who has no friends or family, and is rumored to be involved in everything from dog beating, to burglary, and even to a current murder investigation. This old man was abused as a child and seems to be a hopeless cause. His cause seems hopeless not only because of his behavior, but also because he is forever the victim of gossip. The boy looks for the good in the old man even though he is not sure if he will succeed or whether the old man is capable of change.

Along the way, the boy confronts other challenges closer to home. He has a senile Grandmother who appears to be an Alzheimer victim and is difficult to love. He also has a rebellious young sister who is a constant pain.

Displaying sacrifice and compassion well beyond his years, the boy learns valuable lessons about life. However, this is not a preachy movie. The morality statements are understated, and the children are surprisingly fine actors who mostly display the fun of being young and open and naive. The whole family can enjoy this movie, which is part mystery, part adventure and part family drama.

FYI – There is a Truly Moving Pictures web site where there is a listing of past Truly Moving Picture Award winners that are now either at the theater or available on video.
64 out of 69 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Family Film
gregberne119 December 2018
This is a very under rated movie that I had not even heard of before. The kids love it but it can be kind of emotional and sad for younger kids. It's got good performances and a good story though and the dog is adorable. This isn't a dumb talking dog type dog movie, it's a good story with a nice ending.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Shiloh, West Virginia, is a VERY REAL PLACE in WV.
ShilohWV13 July 2006
I grew up in the REAL SHILOH, WEST VIRGINIA, and rode School bus #2 from the end of the SHILOH BRIDGE through FRIENDLY,WV 26146 on to Sistersville, WV 26175

BEAGLE dogs were very common in the area and the dog inspiring the SHILOH book and film series was a real dog found under the Historic Shiloh Bridge in TYLER COUNTY, WEST VIRGINIA.

ALL THREE MOVIES HAVE BEEN WONDERFUL FAMILY FILMS. THEY PROVIDE A SNAP SHOT IN TIME OF A VERY REAL WAY OF LIFE IN RURAL TYLER COUNTY, WEST VIRGINIA. I am a luck girl to have grown up there.

If you have any questions about the REAL Shiloh, WV, area, please E-mail your questions. or write to MAYOR'S OFFICE, TOWN HALL, FRIENDLY,WV, 26146

SHILOHWV GIRL
15 out of 58 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Surprisingly good conclusion to an underrated family movie trilogy
shensley-3144520 September 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I read the books as a kid before this third movie had come out. I remember when the movie had come out but just never got around to watching it even though I owned the first two on VHS as a kid.

I think Michael Moriarty's absence as Ray the father was a big reason why I didn't get around to this one for so long.

I just thought he was wonderful as the father in the first two films and played him as a strict authoritarian, but also a loving man full of integrity.

Knowing he was replaced left a bit of a sour taste in my mouth.

Fortunately Gerald McRaney who replaces him in this film does a good enough job. Moriarty's presence is missed but McRaney is serviceable enough.

Scott Wilson still shines as Judd Travers who was mean all throughout the first film until the end, became even more mean in the second film but in this one he seems to have a bit more of a balance.

He can be mean some times but usually regrets it but we find out that Judd is actually a good guy in this installment which makes it an even better movie than I expected it to be. Wilson was indeed a very underrated actor and as Judd he showed many sides of his talent.

Here we see that Judd shows his good side when people treat him with kindness. He is very believable as a man who has been hurt by years of abuse that wasn't his fault but can indeed change by the smallest acts of kindness.

It's nice this film respects Judd's character enough to turn him from a horribly mean person who still has flaws but has a heart of gold underneath them.

Bonnie Bartlett is back as Mrs. Wallace but Rod Steiger died a few years before this was made so obviously he isn't back as Doc Wallace and another actor didn't replace him.

Jason Dolley doesn't have the same charisma that Blake Heron or Zachary Browne did as Marty in the first two films but he does ok as Marty in his own right.

Taylor Momsen from 2000's The Grinch is good as Samantha Wallace granddaughter of Bartlett's character and friend of Marty's.

I would say this one is as good as the first Shiloh and actually better than the second one.

While part 2 has Moriarty and Steiger I just feel this one has a stronger story with more suspense and also turning the antagonist into a protagonist.

Almost sort of like how Arnold Schwarzenegger started off bad in Terminator 1 but became good in number 2 Wilson's Judd has a nice similar transition and is very believable.

This was a surprisingly good movie. I agree with Roger Ebert the Shiloh films are intelligent, thought provoking and can provide enough entertainment for adults and children alike.

Adults shouldn't dismiss any of these films as a stupid kids movie.

These movies can be enjoyed by young and old alike and even as a 32 year old man I found a lot to entertain and enjoy me here just as the other two films did as a 7-10 year old child.

These films are hidden treasures and deserved to be seen by all families.

I know there is a fourth Shiloh book Shiloh Christmas.

Not sure if they will adapt it to a film. If they don't this was a perfect place to leave off for the movie adaptations.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed