The Murmuring Coast (2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Love and life are not what she thought they would be when Evita moved from Lisbon to Mozambique, a country on the edge of in-dependency...
esqia1 December 2004
During the war of in-dependency Evita (Beatriz Batarda) moves from Lisbon to Mozambique to marry Luís (Filipe Duarte). She slowly discovers how different and disturbing life is in a country of war and when her husband is send on a military mission she starts to fight loneliness. Over time she finds out more about her husband and Mozambique than she would have imagined in her peaceful European home. Racism, violence, injustice and fatalism make life unbearable... (exploring this "insufferableness" makes it a very Portuguese movie)

Beautifully made for a first time... Margarida Cardoso's first full length movie has rich characters, marvelous images and draws a profound picture of life in Mozambique during its struggle of in-dependency (seen from a Portuguese perspective).
19 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
End-of-empire bloodstained nostalgia
cliffhanley_14 November 2006
Mozambique in the 1960s began its struggle for independence in earnest, having being colonised by Portugal in the 16th century. The 'terrorists' were FRELIMO, who formed the first government in 1975, but not before a protracted war with the Rhodesian-backed RENAMO, leading to over a million deaths. The early days of this uprising are examined through Portuguese eyes, as Evita (Beatriz Batarda) arrives from Europe to marry Luis (Filipe Duarte). She is a headstrong young woman who finds herself at first lost and confused in this strange land which is changing as she tries to come to terms with her life there. He is a soldier with a unit whose task is to wipe out the 'insurgents'.

During Luis' expeditions he tries to insist that his bride stays inside the home in Maputo, the capitol, as he fears attacks from locals. She refuses to live in purdah, though, and moves to a hotel, enjoying the city and beach by herself. She finds a friend, in Helena (Monica Calle), who has accepted subordination; they form a close relationship, and Helena reveals secrets about Luis' previous army experiences - more than Evita would rather have wanted to know. Once, on leave, Luis and his boss, Helena's husband, take the girls on a shooting trip where their complete loss of respect for life, and particularly Luis' desire to impress his superior, are demonstrated in their incontinent spending of bullets.

Evita also strikes up a close relationship with a journalist (Luis Sarmento), who explains that it's dangerous for newspapers to be as literal as she would like, in the telling of what really is going on around them. Her awakening already caused upset at the dinner table when she had the temerity to suggest that it might be alright for the Mozambicans to get their country back after so long. Meanwhile, mysterious poisonings all over town and spontaneous attacks by Portuguese residents against the 'niggers'. These are not sub-plots, there to lift the story from pulp-fiction level; they are part of a complexity, an echo of the chaos the country as a whole would have been suffering.

Comparisons can be made to other films, like The Quiet American, or Indochine; and to other post-colonial countries like Iraq (and Maputo, with its comfortable but fragile insularity, could be Tel Aviv). This is its own kind of film, though, and the screenplay includes warm novelistic drifts from the novel (of the same name) by Lidia Jorge. In voice-over, the older Evita talks to her younger, active self, musing on what could have been or what was. Throughout, the minimal soundtrack by Bernardo Sassetti is more ambient or emphatic than straight music, and is inseparable from the visuals. Lisa Hagstrand's camera-work subtly acts in a similar way: Evita is always shot against bright light and breezes, while Helena is framed by mahogany and deep shadow, and the colour is slightly washed-out; almost sepia. The fact that 'A costa dos murmurios' defies easy classification should guarantee a long life. CLIFF HANLEY
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
I didn't hear the Murmúrios
SelvarajanK2 April 2006
The film is shot in exotic locations, the characters are strong but they don't leave any impact on me. The director i think was little confused between a documentary and film. The story is weak, not so gripping or sentimental as it could have been. It had all the potential to be a good love story but lost in the waves. The way the characters were handled is good, right from the lady in the kitchen to the leading lady. The theme is also fine, but its not so clear about the marriage which actually is very important in the context of the film. I really liked the climax of the movie it was so shuttle and cheers to the director for not dramatizing it.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A surprisingly good film
moreymark1 February 2008
This film is more about the futility of colonialism than it is about the disintegrating relationship between Evita and Luis. The relationship is a way for the viewer to personalise the struggle for independence: the newly-married couple are torn apart because they see the war from opposite sides.

And this is why the film works so well, because the viewer focuses on the micro, love gone cold, and clearly understands that this is because of the bigger issues that surround the young couple.

Margarida Cardoso surprises directing her first feature-length movie. Although two hours, not one shot is wasted nor one scene drags, and the screenplay never betrays that 'The Murmuring Coast' is condensed from a novel. The ending is delightful: confusing and yet clear.

It is a movie that anyone who enjoys fine characterisation will gain a lot out of.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Boring Portuguese women look at war, stupid army men and senseless killings
FilmCriticLalitRao4 August 2008
A costa do murmurios (The Murmuring Coast) is a striking debut film by Portuguese director Margarida Cardoso who also happens to be an acclaimed director of many award winning documentary films.Her film is based on an eponymous novel written by acclaimed Portuguese writer Lidia Jorge in 1989.This film is her homage to her childhood days which were spent in a war torn Mozambique.In this film,Cardoso shows us lives of Portuguese soldiers who are waging war against freedom fighters and rebels.They are shown as brutes who would not mind killing innocent civilians.On the one hand it is quite true that "A Costa Do Murmurios" is a film about native people fighting for their independence,on the other hand,it can also be said that it appears more as a film about lonely Portuguese women,their inner worlds,their hollow existences and their fights for their own independence.Beatriz Batarda plays a memorable role of a silly woman who is shielding her idiotic husband.Most of the film is shown through her perspective which is the silent cry of an innocent woman against the ghastly horrors of a senseless war.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed