The Magic Flute (2003 TV Movie) User Reviews

My favourite Magic Flute

[TheLittleSongbird · 10/10 · 24 February 2011]

I love this production of The Magic Flute, and it is my personal favourite of all the productions I've seen of this magnificent opera, and I have seen quite a few. The Magic Flute has a wonderful story that never fails to captivate me when I see it, the characters I fell in love with immediately yes even with Queen of the Night and Mozart's music is up there with his very best work with highlights being the Queen of the Night Aria(a colouratura tour-de-force), Papagaeno's aria, Sarastro's aria as he comforts Pamina and gives her advice and the heartbreakingly-poignant Ah ich fuhl.

This 2003 production looks positively radiant. The sets are beautiful, the lighting is atmospheric and the costumes are eye-popping especially Queen of the Night which makes her even more regal and chilling. The singing and acting is top notch and further complimented by excellent orchestra playing, conducting and direction.

Willi Hartmann is an appealing and heroic Tamino, while Dorothea Roschmann is quite stunning with a heartfelt voice and acting ability. Franz-Josef Selig is very noble and firm as Sarastro, the three ladies are beautifully blended not to mention strikingly beautiful and threatening, Aillish Tynan is witty and playful as Papagaena and the three boys also surprised me in the angelic tones to their voices. Two performances made this for me.

First, Simon Keenleyside, I loved his Papagaeno, always entertaining with a great voice to match. Second, and more so, Diana Damrau as Queen of the Night, she is superb with a very flexible voice with even more impressive projection and diction and a presence that sends chills down your spine, Roschmann actually looked genuinely frightened of her and it is not hard to see why.

I agree the comic side of Monastatos is slightly overplayed, but that isn't enough to hurt what is a brilliant production that I cannot recommend highly enough. 10/10 Bethany Cox

A very good version of The Magic Flute

[aulendil · 10/10 · 15 October 2006]

Diana Damrau sings as an angel and as a devil at once. She scares Pamina so much that the poor girl actually shudders when Diana touches her. She radiates megawatts of strength. Truly outstanding.

Papageno and Pamina are good enough. Maybe Monostatos overacts the comic side of the role. Sarastro, who happens to be my favorite character, is not a match to the Queen of Night. Pamino and Papagena are, well, I have not fully made my mind on them.

I'd give top scores to the orchestra and direction. Costumes: good enough, some are a bit too modern. Sarastro ought to look like a priest, but doesn't.

A superb performance. You will want to watch it again and again. Don't allow Diana to sing out real loud, she might break some glasses.

The Best of the Lot

[MikelMask1 · 10/10 · 11 November 2010]

I have seen many performances of Die Zauberflote on stage, on TV, and on DVD. This is by far the best of the lot. All of the performers are terrific. Many reviewers of the performance have commented on the outstanding work of Diana Damrau's Queen of the Night and Simon Keenlyside's Papageno and I completely agree. However, I also want to underline the emotional realism that Dorothea Roschmann was able to bring to her part as Pamina and the heroic stoicism of Will Hartmann as Tamino. Ailish Tynan, a singer whose work I was previously unfamiliar with, is a highlight as Papagena- whenever she showed up on stage, sparks flew. Franz-Josef Selig as Sarastro was able to be regal without being boring (it helps when you have a bass like his) and the Queen's Three Ladies were simultaneously beautiful, amusing, and threatening (no mean trick). Probably the thing that I liked best in this performance was staging the action in the Age of Enlightenment. This underlined the philosophical elements that Mozart input into the opera and took away, or at least greatly diminished, the fairy tale, fantasy aspects that are often focused upon in other performances. This staging also helped the humorous aspects of the Papageno/Pagagena relationship stand out since Ms. Tynan, dressed in garish 1960's/1970's garb, was an eye sore compared to the "proper" eighteenth century folk around her resulting in her performance being such a hoot (and was better than the P/P pair being dressed up as pseudo-birds). All in all, this is a fabulous performance which I cannot recommend any more highly.

Simply brilliant

[franjo-tahi · 10/10 · 27 December 2012]

Magic Flute is my favorite opera so I was searching the Youtube, looking for best performance of famous "Holle rache" aria. My favorite performer used to be Edda Moser when I heard Dianna Damrau - she was nothing less than superb. There are lot of good performances of that aria but when you hear Dianna you can hear not only music but also feel her emotions - hate and vengeance. It was same with other two arias - sorrow in the first one and joy in the second.

Next step, got that DVD and listen to the whole opera. Magical Flute has quite a few important roles and usually some performers are excellent/very good and some not so good. Here it is not just Dianna that excels in her performance, but virtually every singer is excellent and also an orchestra - even Mozart himself would be pleased.

Simon Keenlyside masters the Papageno role both in singing and acting (esspecialy the comic side of his character) and Ailish Tynan as Papagena doesn't fade in their famous duo like some other singers.

Willi Hartmann as Tamino and Dorothea Röschmann as Pamina with their clear voices goes well together.

Sarastro, Monostratos, Three ladies, Three boys I liked all of them.

Scenography and costume design is simple but good - it doesn't hinder performance like for example in Metropolitan 2004 version where poor Erika Miklosa has to stand still whole time because of her costume.

The music is in the center here but director and choreographer have also done good job and there is enough space for good acting as well.

If you like Mozart and opera, watch this and you will watch it again and again.

The best Magic Flute yet!

[eleanan · 10/10 · 7 November 2013]

Thoroughly enjoyable, beautifully cast and superbly directed - a real feast for eyes and ears, combined with enough comic elements to keep it light and enjoyable.

Diana Damrau is THE definitive Queen of the Night - none other has ever or will ever sing these arias in such silky, consummate, wrathful fashion.

Her maidens have heavenly voices to compliment her - not a mean feat!

Sarastro... well, I love the voice but to be honest, he pales in comparison to The Queen!

Momostatos is just pitiable - as he should be, being more of a victim rather than a monster.

Tamino is a bit of a washout but his voice makes up for it - and has enough empty swagger to poke fun at the aristocracy he represents!

Pamina is just lovely and has a gorgeous voice herself - she radiates maidenly innocence yet rises to the occasion (she's got more guts than Tamino).

Papagena is spot on - earthy, shrewd and fun - a perfect match for Papageno.

But all my stars really go to Simon Keenlyside - there will be no other Papageno like him - ever! He is a delight both to listen to and watch as he seemingly blunders his way (but in reality is the sanest of the lot) through the opera.

My only regret is I never had the opportunity to watch this stunning performance live. I am delighted it has been immortalised on DVD and I think it's one of the best gifts one could give to an opera-phile!