Ghosts of Attica (2001) User Reviews

Fantastic Documentary of a slowly forgotten event

[jmuir · 10/10 · 8 March 2005]

I've just finished watching this movie three times: once to preview it and twice with students of a history of crime and punishment class. The film is an amazing and engaging piece of work.

The narrative of the Attica prison riot and its aftermath is pieced together from interviews with guards, prisoners, state police officials, and observers and both new footage and news footage of the prison rebellion. The film nicely provides both a political background and a brief view of life in a prison for both guards and prisoners before walking through the events of the riot from the hunger strike over a San Quentin killing through the takeover of yard D and to the moving in of the state police, the killings and beatings, and the investigations that followed. The film is framed by the conclusion of the Attica Brothers legal action and the beginning of the Forgotten Victims of Attica suit.

By presenting voices from several perspectives (most particularly the guard Mike Smith and the prisoner Frank "Big Black" Smith) the film provides a rich story. My students and I were deeply moved by the images and events, regardless of our political stripe.

Less heralded than many recent big documentaries this film deserves a wider audience interested in prisons, policing, power and race.

Get the Survivors Together.

[dlc507 · 10/10 · 9 November 2021]

This documentary and the recently completed Attica released in 2021, are great to compare these two. I know it will be a difficult task, but either conduct new interviews for the same documentary with all the survivors, inmates, hostages, and survivors families. NY need to be held accountable, the NY State Police and NY State Corrections needs to make it right for the hostages and the families of fallen officers, and lastly the inmates that were tortured.

To survive this siege, and to not be rescued, but murdered by your own people and then to walk away from their families, the state of NY should be ashamed.

Even hostages who are living today, they weren't even compensated because that would've been an admittance of guilt. These men, whether right or wrong while performing their job inside those walls, deserve more than what they were given. I understand that they came out with their lives, but that trauma isn't going to disappear, ever. Survivors guilt can eat at your soul.

Inmates are tortured in this current timeline we live in, and that's with officers who speak to them as human beings. In Attica, they used the sound of the baton to communicate, we don't even do that with animals in cages today, or even in the past. So think about that for a moment.

There are many Attica documentaries out there, view them and make your own conclusions, but know that the ending tragedy is the same and this film has a couple hostage survivors telling you that they believed a false narrative.

Attica Uprising 30 Years and a Settlement Later

[view_and_review · 9/10 · 30 January 2021]

Ever since I read the Pulitzer Prize winning book "Blood in the Water" by Heather Ann Thompson I've had a keen interest in the Attica uprising in 1971. Since reading that book in 2019 I've watched a documentary and two movies about it. Today was the second documentary I've watched. The first documentary titled "Attica" was done in 1974. It was only three years after the melee and has more interviews from the victims. It is probably the best film on the matter being that it was done so soon after the event and memories of it all were so fresh.

"Ghosts of Attica" is a current day documentary (2001) that recaptures the four day uprising capped by a brutal takeover and the eventual settlement the surviving prisoners got. Their settlement put them back in the news again in 2001 thereby making this follow up documentary relevant.

"Ghosts of Attica," unlike the documentary "Attica," shows a bevy of stomach-turning photos. These pictures were clear evidence of the indiscriminate use of force by the state of New York to retake the prison. This documentary also mentions, for the first time, how the state screwed over their own employees. Those guards that were injured or killed during the takeover weren't compensated with anything but peanuts in the aftermath. Finally, this documentary gives a fuller look at the length of time the legal battle went on and the legal games the state of New York played to avoid culpability.

Documentaries like this are always necessary. They circulate the truth of events especially when there is a multi-billion dollar institutional machine in place to dictate what the "truth" is. The Attica slaughter was a travesty and a pock mark on the face of U. S. history. I will always appreciate documentaries such as this that expose the skeletons hidden in the closet of America's legal and "justice" system.