The Forgotten Faces (1961) User Reviews

The short lived people's revolt in Hungary

[Captain_Couth · 8/10 · 17 November 2002]

Peter Watkins tells the story of the short lived revolt of the people in Hungary against the Soviet backed regime that toppled their democratically elected goverment. Watkins uses his trademark faux documentary style as he follows the people's revolt from it's beginning to it's tragic end. Watkins uses Eisenstein's style of filmmaking along with his own to create a very unique and interesting short film. A sign of greater things to come.

Very educational and highly recommended.

Despite The Conflated Politics A Memorable Amateur Film

[Theo Robertson · 7/10 · 7 April 2014]

Say what you like about Peter Watkins but you can never accuse his work of being uninteresting . This early piece is of am almost forgotten chapter of post war European history that of The Hungarian uprising against Soviet rule in 1956 . Now this seems like a strange choice of subject matter for Watkins since his anti-war politics are very well known but this alone should intrigue a potential audience . Doubly so since it's " an amateur production " .where with the exception of Watkins himself no one involved in the production were professional film makers .This extends to the cast themselves and the film was shot in Kent

According to Watkins official website he was influenced by Truffaut's Les Quatre Cents Coups and not as one might expect the Italian Neo Realists . One can't help thinking that despite not mentioning him Watkins might very well have been influenced by the great Andrzej Wajda and these Hungarian revolutionaries mirror those of the Warsaw uprising in KANAL . You can almost hear " These tragic heroes . Watch them in their last remaining hours of their lives " and the audience knows who side to take . These Hungarians are freedom fighters oppressed by Soviet rule so it doesn't really matter if they execute captured policemen because all's fair in love and war . Strange then that the film ends with the narration that:

" "There has to be a right and wrong in any human conflict. This most tragic of revolutions can be no exception. But in any conflict between two major creeds, one of which you believe in, there has to be a final taking of sides. And if those who happened to believe - as these Hungarian freedom fighters believed - had also taken a strong moral stand on their behalf at a time when it most mattered, then it is more than likely that more than 20,000 of these people need not have given their lives or their liberty for this belief."

Sorry but I don't understand the point being made here ? Putting it in to historical perspective at the same time The Hungarian Uprising happened Britain , France and Israel were involved in invading Egypt to gain control of the Suez Canal and the eyes of the World were on this intervention rather than in Eastern Europe . America did all it could in ending that crisis by severe political and diplomatic coercion against these three nations . It couldn't use that same coercion against the Soviet Union because the USSR was a superpower with no dependency on America . The only option would have been military intervention on Hungary's behalf and that would have started World War Three and considering Watkins most famous work is the Oscar winning THE WAR GAME I doubt if that's what he's advocating so the political message seems slightly confused and seems to be having a dig at the Western democracies rather than where the fault lies - Stalinist socialism

That said for an amateur film it's a quantum step forward from Watkins previous short film DIARY OF AN UNKNOWN SOLDIER . Truth be told it's also superior from a directorial view point as some of his later work that relies far too heavily on close up . Here Watkins employs a good mix of medium and long shots too and you'd never believe that it was shot in the English Home counties . There is a slight annoyance that on screen movement seems slightly exaggerated but again you have to remember this is amateur film making which is very effective and poignant

Powerful, kinetic, forceful political short shows Watkins' genius at its undiluted best

[OldAle1 · 10/10 · 10 April 2008]

On the same DVD as Punishment Park is this 1960 (according to the credits on the disc, 1961 here) 18-minute very low-budget short, shot silent with narration and sound effects, detailing a small group of freedom fighters engaged in the 1956 Hungarian revolution. This is much more powerful, kinetic and forceful film-making, and the politics are for the most part more obvious and blunt, though there is a beautiful passage at the end that shows that the notion that "the right side" is dependent on what side one is on has not been forgotten by the leftist filmmaker. This is Watkins at his most basic and primitive and for me, at his best.

Where to obtain film

[fuchal · 9/10 · 2 September 2005]

This film is available in its entirety as an extra on the BBC DVD release of Watkins' 1964 film "Culloden" (PAL region 2 - UK). It is also very interesting to compare this with his Culloden film; the camera work, narration style, minimal use of music are all quite similar. The Culloden film is worth the price of the DVD alone, along with its audio commentary and location footage. Well worth checking out. As an aside, it is interesting to note that this film (The Forgotten Faces) was made in England, 5 years after the event took place. I would love to compare the two films with Watkins' 1999 film on the Paris Commune, but it has not been released on DVD yet (Sept 2005).