A Wonderful Life (1950) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
A Crisis of Faith
boblipton5 November 2019
James Dunn has just died, and his daughter, Allene Roberts, is having a crisis of faith. It's been going through her mind for some time as she enters her last year of college, that kind, generous, church-going people like Dunn are always called upon to do the work, and receive no payment or credit. Every civic committee in his town has him as unpaid treasurer, because everyone trusts him. Now, with the War on, Miss Roberts thinks it's all for naught,

This short feature (43 minutes in length) in from the Presbyterian Church. It's directed by William Beaudine -- he directed a lot of the Church's movies in this period -- and narrated by Arthur Shields, who also plays the minister. We see Dunn's life from 1929 through his death, and his cheerful demeanor in times of hardship. Clearly, this was the message the Presbyterian Church wished to send: forward thinking, kindly, and trusting in G*d.

It's a straightforward effort, without much in the way of cinematic pizzazz. Doubtless that was its selling point, and the reason they hired Beaudine to do the job: given the good actors he had here, his nickname of "One Shot" because he didn't like to do retakes, meant an inexpensive shoot.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Dealing with the pain of death by reviewing a life.
mark.waltz10 November 2019
Warning: Spoilers
What does a good life mean without the extreme comforts of home, money in the bank and the respect of your neighbors? For Allene Roberts, losing her father (James Dunn) just as she's beginning to live her life as an adult, she wonders why he donated so much of his time to church causes and in his small way, making the world a better place. She has to question her own faith, look at the suffering her mother (Isabel Withers) is going through and look into her own heart to accept his life as one of a great man. Fortunately, her pastor (Arthur Shields) is there to offer her words of wisdom, not just comfort.

As directed by William Beaudine, the director of many poverty row films of the 1940's and 1950's, this religious drama made by the Prespiterian Church is simple and unjudemental and its narrative. It doesn't tell its viewers how to live, but only suggests that a life of giving can be much more fulfilling than a life of working to collect material objects and personal comfort. These films are not meant to become classics or to convert a non-believer, but only a subtle advisement of how to live a better life through spiritual teachings that are similar in many religions and are more of a code of ethics that aids everyone.

Ironically, Dunn picks up that fact when he gives a traveling salesman a ride to the local train station, an ironic giver of spiritual advice, and this gives him the idea of how he will spend a good portion of a bonus he has just received. I have seen about half a dozen of these films which deal with subjects like the evils of gossip, loss of faith through growing cynicism towards life, inhospitality and judging without finding what the truth is. It is not a film that will necessarily convince unbelievers to convert to Christianity, but it's a simple story of just giving to humanity rather than proceeding to take.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed