The Beautiful Country (2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
36 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
They come into America
anhedonia16 December 2005
One of the least attractive aspects of the American movie industry is that while crap, such as "Fever Pitch" (the remake), "The 40-Year-Old Virgin" and "Be Cool," get millions of dollars spent on marketing and promotion and are splashed on thousands of screens, a gem like "The Beautiful Country" gets barely released. Even then, it only hits the major cities.

I pretty much knew little to nothing about this film when I saw it. I vaguely recall seeing an Ebert & Roeper review of it, though I don't remember when they recommended it. What a completely wonderful surprise this one turned out to be.

"The Beautiful Country" is as much about the lengths to which immigrants will go to come to the United States as it is about a man's search for his father. Writer Sabina Murray (who apparently was hired by Terrence Malick and Edward R. Pressman to write a film about immigrants and came up with this idea) deftly uses Binh's (Damien Nguyen) quest as a device to depict the hardships of immigrants.

What ultimately makes "The Beautiful Country" a shattering experience is its complete unpretentiousness. There isn't a single emotion in this film that isn't earned. It's as much a testament to Murray's script as it is to the performances.

Nick Nolte might be the name actor in this film, but his role's relatively small. But, just as he did in "Hotel Rwanda" (2004), Nolte takes what's essentially a cameo and turns it into something memorable. He gives his character true depth.

The two surprises in this film are Nguyen and Bai Ling as Ling, a sexy Chinese refugee who is willing to do anything - anything - to fulfill her dreams. This is undoubtedly the best thing Bai Ling has done. Usually cast as caricatures or in minor roles, she imbues her character with genuine feeling. We understand and feel for this woman, her struggles and her passions.

Nguyen completely dominates the film. He doesn't do anything wrong. He underplays Binh so expertly, you'd think this was a veteran actor, not a novice. It's such an incredibly honest performance, you wouldn't for an instant believe Nguyen is a surfer boy from California. It's one of the year's best performances.

At a time when the news media and politicians seem to be concentrating on demonizing immigrants, it's important to see a film like this, to see why people leave their homelands, endure unimaginable suffering to come here. True, the immigrants in this film aren't of Arab descent or Haitian - we all know exactly how they'd be treated. But "The Beautiful Country" is all about the beauty and ugliness of life. It's also emotionally devastating at times. And what makes the film all the more remarkable is that the gut-wrenching scenes never come across as any sort of contrivance. There's no emotional blackmail here; the actors play the scenes straight and with a gesture, a simple word, manage to bring us to tears.

"The Beautiful Country" is a rare treasure, a film that never cheats us, never asks for what it hasn't earned and still manages to be deeply affecting. And in keeping with the rest of the film, the final scene is simply perfect.

A film like this deserves a much larger audience than it got. This is why we go to the movies.
71 out of 81 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A movie beyond expectation
bananku26 March 2004
This movie is not specifically about the Vietnam war, but it gives a good perspective that is not biased in any way. It proves that justice and freedom are not present for all people, only the "lucky" ones. The people that are born in the western world. We take it all for granted what 70% of the population can just envy. It is usually said that if you work hard you will always become something significant. But after watching this movie, I understand that no matter how hard you work, if you are born poor you WILL most likely stay poor. The story follows Binh, a half Vietnamese and half American man. He isnt accepted in society in Vietnam just becasue of this hard fact "he is the enemy" and therefore he is worthless. This has become a major issue in Vietnam after the Vietnam war, but it has never been taken this seriously before. This is a very good movie! I would reccomend everyone to watch this, it gives everyone a humanitarian lesson about how we are all humanbeings no matter where we come from.
48 out of 59 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Coming to America
jotix1005 August 2005
"The Beautiful Country" is a film that tries to capture one of the worst problems in the world today, illegal people smuggling into that promised land that for some is the United States. Director Hans Peter Moland has created a film with the feeling of a documentary that follows the hard journey of a man in search of a father he never knew. Beautifully photographed by Stuart Drybargh, and with a haunting musical score by Zbigniew Preisner, "The Beautiful Country" could well have been subtitled "His Worst Nightmare".

We are introduced to Binh, a tall young man living in Viet Nam after the end of the war. The time is 1990 and we are offered a glimpse of Binh's life where his relatives, as well as the rest of the Vietnamese don't like him because of his mixed race. His father was an American G.I. who married his mother, Mai, but Binh never gets to meet him because Steve, as the father is named, disappeared from Saigon, never to be found again.

The film is Binh's odyssey to be reunited with the father he doesn't know. It's a horrific journey where Binh shows his own skills to endure the worst possible conditions to realize his dream of getting to meet a father he never knew. It's a homage to the surviving spirit of a man.

Damien Nguyen is Binh, the young mixed race Vietnamese man. He does an outstanding job under Mr. Moland's direction. Nick Nolte, as Steve has some good moments. The supporting cast makes an excellent contribution to the movie.

The film proves to what extent a determined man will go in order to get what he wants.
43 out of 55 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I understand the difficulty of the journey to America
huckfinnsj@aol.com13 March 2007
My son, Tam, and I were reunited on July 24, 2003, after a separation of 36 years. His mother, Huong, tried to flee Vietnam in May, 1975, but due to circumstances beyond her control, she missed the boat which was to take her and Tam to freedom. The communists caught the boat on the Saigon River, and sank it, killing all aboard. Huong finally decided to stick it out and worked hard to raise the money to come to the US. After arriving with Tam in 1994, she died of a stroke later that year. By a stroke of fortune, Tam, in 2003 found someone (an American) who could access my name in the Navy records. Within a few days of locating my name, the navy received a request to forward a letter from Tam. Needless to say, as I never knew if Tam or his mother had survived the war, I was stunned when I opened the large manila envelope from the Navy Department. The rest is history, and we are together. Tam lives and works near Los Angeles, and I recently retired and moved to a close-by state.

The movie, "The Beautiful Country", which I first viewed last night (3/12/07) really struck home. I feel like "I'm one in a million".
34 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best movies of 2004
abhattac13 July 2006
Underrated by critics and virtually ignored by the mainstream film press, I found this to be one of the unexpected surprises of 2004. An amazing film covering the often grim fate of Amerasians (ie, children of American servicemen and Vietnamese mothers, often illegitimate and to the detriment and neglect of the mothers/children), one of the messy side-effects of a messy and mismanaged war.

This film was as haunting as it was brilliantly conceived and surprisingly well constructed for a low-budget film. I wish the actors all the best, as their tour-de-force performances captured the essence of the struggles any desperate person faces in trying to create a better life out from poverty, neglect, and despair. An absolute MUST-SEE for any serious independent/off-the-beaten-track film connoisseur....
15 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Great movie, yet underrated
jdpyke7 August 2005
Classic tale of redemption, brimming with drama and a lead character that says little, but who you quickly relate to and associate yourself with. Starts of kind of slow, but after 15-20 minutes, the movie picks up and never slows down, with high drama and classic storytelling. A must-see. The movie is set to the backdrop of the aftermath of the Vietnam war in Vietnam, and portrays the poverty-stricken environment they are forced to live in. It then moves on to show the desperation of would-be American immigrants fleeing from one land that doesn't want them to sneak into another. After watching this movie, you will definitely have a greater appreciation for what some immigrants have to go through.
31 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An Incredible Film
jsmact1 May 2005
I saw this film at the Tribeca Film Festival yesterday, and thought it was the best film in the festival. The cinematography was beautiful, the story was touching, and the characters were rich. There is one point in the movie where something tragic happens and it moved the entire audience to tears, including myself. The script is excellent, creative, and intelligent. The director did an extraordinary job and so did the lead actor, who had never made a feature film before. Tim Roth and Nick Nolte also give strong performances. I think this film will become a classic and end up winning some big awards. This is one of those epic monumental stories that should not be forgotten. An extraordinary and touching film.
36 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Austin Movie Show review
leilapostgrad6 August 2005
The children of American GI's in Vietnam were treated as second-class citizens – walking symbols of American control, destruction, and occupation. Binh (Damien Nguyen) lives with a foster family, can only eat their leftovers, and longs to find his own family, including the mother who couldn't support him and the American father he never knew. With only a picture of his parents, he leaves the village in search of his roots.

Binh finds his mother (and a young half brother) in Saigon, but after a deadly accident, he and his new brother are forced to flee the city and the country in search of America. Binh endures the purgatory of a Malaysian refugee camp and survives the hell of an illegal slave ship.

His travels are extraordinary and devastating, but the character of Binh is reason enough to see this incomparable epic. He has lived his life as an outcast, full of sorrow and shame. He rarely has the courage to look other people in the eye. But every catastrophic event in his journey brings him strength and courage, so that by the time he finds his father, he's man enough to face him. Or is he?
23 out of 28 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful movie
citicencane23 March 2004
Truly one the most beautiful movies i`ve ever seen. It feels very honest and true to the story about a young vieatnamise boy who goes to USA in search of his father. This journey is visually remarkable and shows what refugees have to deal with in search of a better life. It`s easy to see that Therence Malick is one of the producers behind this projeckt considering that it`s the pictures that speaks most, not the dialogue. Damien Nguyen gives a fantastic first performance as the leading character Binh. In supporting roles we find Nick Nolte, Tim Roth and Bai Ling who helps in a great way to bringing the story to life. Highly Recomended!
31 out of 44 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Seeing Nick Nolte is not everything about watching this movie; it's the only thing
harry_tk_yung6 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
(watched in Toronto)

extra spoiler warning

When talking about a movie, I sometimes slip into the bad habit of starting from the end. But this time, I think it's forgivable.

When I read in some of the local (Toronto) reviews that top-billed Nick Nolte appears only in the last fifteen minutes of the 2-hour movie but is well worth waiting for, I reserved my judgment. After seeing the movie, I'll have to borrow Vince Lombardi's famous quote: seeing Nick Nolte is not everything about watching this movie; it's the only thing. Well, maybe I exaggerated. But let me start from the beginning.

"The beautiful country" might have been an alternative plot for Puccini to end Madam Butterfly, or Webber to end Miss Saigon. The movie is actually structured neatly into 4 acts.

Act 1, in two scenes (the home village and Saigon), sets the stage for Binh (Damien Nguyan) to set out on an epic journey to look for his American father in Taxes, a G.I. who legally married his mother but was there one day, gone the next, leaving behind only a picture of the couple and their infant son Binh.

Act 2 takes place in a Malaysian refugee camp, where he encounters Chinese refugee Ling (BAI Ling), initially through the kid half-brother his mother has asked him to take along.

Act 3 depicts the trio's ordeal on a refugee-smuggling ship run by Captain Oh (Tim Roth) and the little boy's tragic death from illness.

The final Act could be one with multiple scenes: Binh and Ling's experience in New York's Chinatown, Binh's southbound quest and his final reunion with his father Steve (Nick Notle).

Starting with some extraordinarily beautiful photography of Vietnam's serene countryside, the movie tells the story of Binh in such a sensitive, honest way that, even when some familiar cliché scenes are inevitable, it is never mawkish. Development of the relationship between Binh and Ling is handled tastefully, and their communication in broken English is the most natural thing, just as it would be for a German and a Frenchman whose common language is English, which neither really knows well.

Nguyan, billed under "introducing", carries the entire movie from beginning to end, with an uncanny ability to touch the audience through his sincerity. Bai is cast in her best role to-date and she portrays the defiance, devotion and passion of this complex woman perfectly. Tarantino's favourite Tim Roth (or one of them at least) also puts in a memorable performance as the ruthless but benevolent protector (of Binh), in fact quite a familiar Charlie Dickens character.

But in the end, it's all Nick Nolte, whose performance last year against Maggie Cheung in "Clean" is one of the best in any film (she won best actress in Cannes; his was only in a supporting role but would have won had there been such a category). That last, 15-minute scene of reunion of father and son in The Beautiful Country, played to perfection by Nolte and Nguyan, is reason enough for me to go and see the movie again.
8 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Harrowing film
rosscinema17 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
With the summer upon us this is usually the time of year where I start to rant and rail about the commercial idiocy from Hollywood that is supposed to be passed off as film but instead I viewed arguably the best film of the summer. It shouldn't come as a shock to learn that this is clearly not a Hollywood studio film and it provides the type of viewing experience that refreshes jaded audiences (like myself) and gives hope that films are still being made that don't cater to the more shallow and commercially driven viewers. Story is about Binh (Damien Nguyen) who's a "Bui Doi" (less than dust) which refers to him being half Vietnamese and half American from the Vietnam war and he lives with his foster parents as a servant and is called "pig face". Binh is thrown out one day and decides to go to Saigon and find his real mother Mai (Thi Kim Xuan Chau) which he does and finds out that he has a half brother named Tam (Dang Quoc Thinh Tran) who's 3 years old.

*****SPOILER ALERT***** Mai gets her son a job but an unfortunate accident occurs which leaves his employer dead and Binh is forced to flee the country and takes little Tam with him. Binh is now trying to get to America and find his real father but during his journey he lands in a Malaysian refugee camp and meets Ling (Bai Ling) who's a Chinese prostitute and the three of them eventually escape and manage to get to a freighter which transports refugees for money. The freighter is commandeered by Captain Oh (Tim Roth) and he and his men force Binh and everyone else on board to sign contracts for the money that is owed them and the trip on ship turns tragic when they run out of food and water and passengers start to die including Tam! Eventually Binh and Ling land in New York City where he works several odd jobs and she continues to be a prostitute and even though Binh is in love with Ling he decides to leave and go to Houston, Texas to find his father. Binh's father is Steve (Nick Nolte) and he's also blind which explains to some degree why he left so suddenly after he was born and though Binh doesn't tell him who he is there seems to be wordless acceptance in their blossoming relationship.

This is directed by Norwegian Hans Petter Moland (Aberdeen) who's films all seem to have something in common in that the story is about a character (or characters) embarking on a long journey. One has to respect the manner in which this film shows incredible patience to tell it's story and scenes in both the refugee camp and on the freighter give this an overwhelming epic narrative. Although it might be tough to call Nguyen an actor (at this point anyway) he's nonetheless the central figure here and his lack of professional training gives his performance a naturalness that adds to the realism of this effort. While I was never sure about the relationship between Binh and Ling I still found Ling's performance very interesting and shows why others have been talking about her and in a good script she can really shine. This film has no real emotional payoff at the end and that seems fine because this isn't about revealing something or venting one's anger it's instead about the emotional journey one takes to reach a point of psychological closure. This is an impressive film and it's practically impossible not to become absorbed in Binh's story and how can viewers not feel his pain when he learns that he could have flown to America for free instead of the torturous journey on the freighter which caused little Tam to lose his life. Moland is definitely a filmmaker to keep an eye on because this is a truly memorable and compelling film that's impossible to forget.
6 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
a great movie
gayromeo200020 March 2004
This was a great movie. It was a sincere and a true movie. Compared to legally blond which is a moral about being blond, stupid and kindhearted is not how the world works like. This movie shows the cruelty and the sadness which is out there in the real world, and it was made in such a good way that i was about crying many times in the movie. This young man who has rejected by his own people, is seeking his destiny in going to America. He brings his much younger brother along with him, and this movies shows the struggle poor people from area with out hopes have to go through in fighting their rights for a better life. People takes advantages of their hopelessness and he and many others end up in this boat with some cynical people smugglers who want to use them as cheap labor and take advantage of the girls for prostitution to make a nice profit for them self. This movie is about hopes, sadness, exploitation of people, cynicism. This movie had also good names like Tim Roth, Bai Ling and Nick Nolte, who delivers a good job like always. I recommend you people to drop the plans of seeing some stupid love comedy for a change, and watch this movie which is very emotional and sad in a very artistic way.
34 out of 50 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A beautiful, if flawed, film
oschaefe14 July 2006
The Beautiful Country is a drama ostensibly concerned with consequences of the Vietnam War, but I would argue its content makes that conflict almost incidental. The story is, rather, a more general parable about migration, assimilation, identity and family - an unabashedly humanist film.

We begin with a young Vietnamese man, Binh, whose father was an American G.I. There are a few brief scenes which outline the discrimination he faces, and his abrupt departure from rural Vietnam to seek his mother seems, like much of the film's plot, somewhat contrived. Why now? What specifically drove him? He faced such discrimination all his life.

His journey to Saigon (oddly, not referred to as Ho Chi Minh City in the subtitle) and his mother then grows into a larger quest to find his father in America. It is only at this point that Binh's motivation becomes fleshed out, and the idea of the immigrant identity comes to the foreground.

The main impetus for a harrowing journey halfway across the world is twofold. One, Binh seeks a better life for himself and his young half-brother. Two, he seeks to know his father, perhaps to better understand himself. America is referred to, early on, as "the beautiful country", but that enigmatic phrase will haunt the film's realism.

The plight of illegal immigrants is something we all are aware of - dangerous transportation into the country and degrading treatment inside the country. These sequences, I think, undermine the film's more powerful message, because we might be tempted to see the film as a general rallying cry for immigration reform in general, instead of an exploration of one immigrant's journey.

The film succeeds best when it pauses from the harsh realities to focus on Binh's inward journey. If the world outside him, and its hardships, are overstated, then he is likewise understated in expressing his own troubles.

The journey, and his perseverance, then becomes a metaphor for Binh's exploration of what, exactly, the beautiful country is. At one point, one character even refers to Vietnam as the beautiful country - a seemingly confusing idea, since Binh traveled so far to get away from the country which would not accept him.

What is beautiful to Binh, then, is relative; he seeks acceptance, and comfort. He is, really, looking for a place which would be reasonably called home. Perhaps most immigration is more practical than this, but the idea that there is a place where one belongs is, indeed, compelling, and I think it's what drives most of our lives.

The Beautiful Country, then, speaks to everyone's desire to fit in and shows how identity is formed not by complacency, but by active search.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Uneven mess
kevinsunde10 July 2004
An Epic Story of Hope constrained by budget and limited artistic ambition. Seeing as Terrence Malick produced this, I expected something haunting and lyrical. Instead, we get a typical Norwegian co-production ("Revolution" with Al Pacino, anyone?), where - quite possibly - good intentions are scuppered by a dreadful screenplay, and where many of the characters are reduced to stereotypes. The "me-Tarzan-you-Jane" English dialogue between the non-English-speaking protagonists is particularly cringeworthy – one could speculate whether Nick Nolte and Tim Roth ad-libbed their own, as they almost sound like real people. The story is loaded with implausibility: we are expected to believe that Binh can speak a smattering of English after having spent his entire life living as a peasant slave (his vocabulary, but unfortunately not grammatical command, increases impressively in the Malayan refugee camp, without the benefit of night classes). Coincidence is rife; I wonder whether an hour or two has been edited from the first third: he tracks down his mother in Ho Chi Minh City almost immediately - after bumping into his thirty year younger half brother, who nonchalantly recognises him! Mum gives him a gold locket (or something similar of great value) as they part, but this is never referred to again. His relationship with "Me Dead Inside" Ling is supposed to provide the obligatory "love interest", but feels as artificial as Leonardo and Cameron in "Gangs Of New York".

The voyage in the rust bucket of a boat does convey a sense of the appalling conditions that human trafficking entails. Indeed, the only time the film is remotely exciting and unpredictable, is the jerky, hand-held footage shot from the bridge during choppy weather conditions. (Incidentally, a boat cruise from Malaysia to New York via The Cape Of Good Hope and the African coast, without stopping for fuel or supplies, is certainly an epic journey). The beautiful shot of the New York skyline echoes Malick's use of magic hour, but I want to know why the Coast Guard didn't show up. Perhaps they were watching the Super Bowl, or something. Of course, Binh manages to track down his blind old Dad on a remote farm in Texas, with the same navigational flair he displayed in Ho Chi Minh City. I was impressed at how Nick Nolte could wander around digging fields and feeding horses on a large ranch without the aid of a guide dog or white stick. For demonstration of how a story about the travails befalling refugees could be structured and shot on a small budget, check out Michael Winterbottom's far superior "In This World".
11 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Looking for my place in the world
lastliberal6 March 2007
Damien Nguyen is incredible in his first film role as a child with a Vietnamese mother and American father, who is trying to find out where he fits in the world. As a mixed race child, he is shunned by the Vietnamese and cannot even hide in a small village with his grandmother.

He sets out on a journey to find his mother and, ultimately, his father in America. It is a long and hazardous trip. Along the way he is befriended by the incredibly beautiful Bail Ling and by Tim Roth. He eventually finds his father; played tenderly by Nick Nolte.

It is a film for drama lovers. It moves slow, but that is necessary to develop the story. There is never a dead spot as the tapestry of his life is carefully woven. Loss, hardship, fear, embarrassment, love, sacrifice - they are all there and critically important to the story.

The ending is surprising, tender, and fitting. It is a movie that will not disappoint.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Slow paced, soul turning drama
siderite4 June 2010
To be honest, I only got this movie because Bai Ling was in it. She was a secondary character, however, and the main story was about this half Vietnamese, half American boy who searches for his parents.

The film is soul wrenching at times, showing this quiet and calm boy going through hell just to survive and go on, but most of the time it just slowly builds up empathy and outrage. There is a timeless quality about the feel of the movie (I honestly thought it was an 80's film) and the acting is top notch. The first half of it is in Vietnamese, the other in English, after the main character crosses the ocean.

Bottom line: quite good, however really slow paced. There are not many scenes to make the blood boil, so you need to be in the mood for a slow drama. It is worth it, though. It makes people understand that there are misfortunes, and then there are misfortunes.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very nice story, super well done, Viet boy coming to America.
TxMike27 May 2006
Warning: Spoilers
Damien Nguyen in his first big role does a remarkable acting job as Binh, a young man of maybe 20 in Viet Nam who is a social outcast because his father is an American. The word they use for him translates to "less than dust." When the lady he is staying with gets married, he is forced to leave and, with no place to go and only a photo of his mom and American to guide him, rides his 3-wheel bike to Saigon to search for his mom.

This is not a short movie, running just over 2 hours, but takes the viewer on a remarkable journey with Binh, who finally decides to go to America to search for his father whom he believes is in Houston, Texas. It is a very hard journey with many side trips, but the movie is about Binh's perseverance and his moral fiber which allows him to stay on the straight and narrow.

This is the very first screenplay by a writing professor, and its evolution into this movie is in itself a fascination story, included in a 20-minute interview with her in the DVD extras. She is also came to America as a younger girl and has an appreciation for the journey.

SPOILERS FOLLOW. While with his mom in Saigon, and working with her in a home of rich Vietnamese who looked down on them, an incident badly injures the old woman and, even though Binh is innocent, has to run to escape the inevitable. So his mom gives him all the money he has saved and tells him to go to the boat, with her small son also, and go to America. They get detained in Malasia, but manage to get out of the refugee camp, catch the boat, where many die, including the small boy, but Binh and his 'girl' manage to get sneaked into New York where they must spend years working off their debt.

As Binh works and develops his English, he finally takes off alone, catching rides to Houston. His dad Steve (Nolte) is not there, but his ex-wife thinks he may be in Sweetwater. Binh finds him there, doing odd jobs on a farm and living in a small trailer. Binh soon finds out why he disappeared 20 plus years ago, he was injured in an explosion in Saigon, woke up in America, blind, and could never go back. The movie ends as Binh and Steve are getting along, Binh happy to find his dad.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
English/Writing/Script detract/distract from the movie
pc9517 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Whoever wrote the script and dialogue did this movie a huge disfavor. Anytime that Binh uses English, it sounds terribly forced and phony. Had the director/storyteller/editors/writers caught this and called for perhaps just ad-libbing or improvisation or perhaps more rewrites etc from/for the actors the movie probably would've been good. As it is the story is interesting and the cinematography at times captivating. The love interest which could've lifted the movie is made to suffer and actually detracts from the movie with lines like "Have no 2000 dollars" and "Boat no go without Ling" or something to that effect. The actors basically are caught red-handed with conversations to spew out that unnecessarily dumb everything down and point to how ignorant and stereotyped the writers preconceived notions are of non-English Asian speakers. The movie unfortunately is something of a mixed bag with great performances from most despite the English mess.
4 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Pity of War: Another View
gradyharp21 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
While we are engaged in yet another intrusive ill-advised war, the time is right for the release of a story that reminds us of the lingering malignant consequences of the equally intrusive war in Vietnam. For those who falsely believe that a war is over with the signing of a declaration and the evacuation of troops this magnificently poignant film will be an eye opener. And for those who are aware of the broken families and bitter scars of war marking those who fought on both sides, the story will find a different response - one of memory of pain, regret, and wonder at the tale of just one survivor.

Binh (Damien Nguyen) is a half-breed, his mother a Vietnamese and his father an American soldier, and as such is has no country: he doesn't belong and lives as an outcast. His struggle for life leads to his departing his village in Vietnam for Saigon where he reconnects with his estranged mother Mai (Thi Kim Xuan Chau), and his very young half brother Tam (Dang Quoc Thinh Tran), who works as a servant in an abusive wealthy Vietnamese household. The reunion is touching and Binh joins his mother on the staff as a servant. An unfortunate accident occurs forcing Binh to flee to America, his young brother Tam accompanying him at Mai's insistence: Mai sees America as the beautiful country where her sons will find their father in Houston, Texas and have a new life.

The bulk of the film is the treacherous journey of Binh and Tam along with Ling (Ling Bai), a Chinese girl who befriends them. They survive a detention camp in Malaysia, a doomed boat trip, and a long journey aboard a filthy human trafficking ship whose Captain Oh (Tim Roth) monitors their survival (except for Tam who succumbs to fever) and ultimately releases them into the waters along New York. Binh and Ling survive in Chinatown in New York in the most menial of jobs, again surviving abuse in the land of promise. Eventually Binh travels to Texas for a reunion with his biological father (Nick Nolte) and even that reunion is marked by the permanent scars the war has left on the survivors.

Through all of the incomprehensible hardships Binh is marked with a spirit of survival that pays homage to the human soul's ability to sustain life through hope. The message is powerful and for once is not cosmetically altered by the writers or the director or the fine cast. Damien Nguyen and Ling Bai are outstanding and the cameo roles are all superb. This is an epic film, not a pretty one, but a film about the pity of war, one that pleads the case against war in simply recalling the disastrous after effects that many choose to forget. And it is a story of the triumph of the human spirit. If we are to ever understand the pity of war and the inhumanity of war, we must be aware of the sequelae. Highly recommended on every level. Grady Harp
10 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A ruin of good intentions
Chris Knipp12 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Hans Petter Moland's "The Beautiful Country" is another in a long line of coming-to-America films. This one is about a Vietnamese man who journeys arduously from Saigon to Texas to find his American father. It's a classic theme, and an important one: but fine themes and noble intentions do not a great movie make. Poorly written and edited, draggy, incomprehensible and lacking in verisimilitude (or flat-out unbelievable) in parts and disjointed, an ordeal to watch, the film -- which has some pretty images and some good acting -- is briefly but memorably saved in the last quarter hour when Nick Nolte comes in as the father and he and his son Binh (Damien Nguyen) play off each other in Texas ranch country like a couple of laconic Cormac McCarthy cowboys. Nolte certainly hasn't lost his touch; and the Vietnamese character has had a tight-lipped, stoical quality all along which now suddenly fits and harmonizes in a few quietly effective scenes. Whether it's worth it to sit through all the rest to get to this short sequence is another question.

Binh, the central character, is a Vietnamese half-breed man treated brutally in his own country because, as someone fathered by an American soldier, he's regarded as "less than dust." This is true, we find, even though Binh's father married his mother -- and left her behind for reasons not his own. Each major narrative shift is punched forward by an invented-looking event. When the people Binh lives with in the Vietnamese countryside as the film begins gain another family member he's immediately ejected from the household.

Binh goes to Saigon where miraculously, though his mother is a nobody working as a house servant, he quickly finds her. Life for Binh is full of Dickensian grimness with sudden strokes of good or bad fortune, and he has a perpetual hangdog look and a creeping walk with shoulders slumped and face down. There's something wrong with his lip. Everyone keeps saying he's ugly, but he's just ordinary: they either perceive him as ugly because of his Caucasian look, or because it's part of the plot. Binh immediately becomes a punching bag as a servant at the house where his mom works, and an accident makes him look guilty of a crime so serious he must immediately flee. Weepingly, his mother sends him off with her young son by somebody else, to make his way -- to America, with a small bundle of cash she's been saving.

The hero ends up with his little half-brother in a Malaysian refugee camp, where he meets a resilient Chinese prostitute and would-be singer, Ling (Ling Bai), and they bond. At her urging he escapes and miraculously they are taken onto a rust-coated vessel full of desperate human cargo, a virtual slave ship, headed for America. The captain is Tim Roth, in a typically interesting, but this time wasted, performance. Things are so mismanaged on the boat that the hapless passengers die off like flies, despite a manager's pledge to lose no one since he'll be paid by the head on arrival. Life on board is a seemingly futile struggle to survive. Amid the craziness and death a fantastic game is played wherein the desperate travelers compete by calling out the names of Americana such as foods, places, or movie stars.

Binh remains an implausible mixture of hangdog manner and iron will. For no clear reason Captain Oh (Roth) takes a shine to him -- but tells him he'll be out of place wherever he goes. "I know," Binh says.

Finally New York comes into view -- but how the passengers are unloaded is one of many explanations the screenplay avoids providing. Binh works in a Chinatown restaurant in the indentured situation he was promised when he talked his way onto the boat -- till somebody remarks that if he has an American father, he's entitled to US citizenship. This revelation causes him to strike out cross country to seek his dad, who's supposed to be in Houston.

Since Binh didn't even know where his mother was in Saigon, how he finds his father working as a ranch hand in an obscure corner of cowboy country is one more far-fetched plot twist. But we can only be grateful, if we've made it through this far, because Nolte comes in and for a quarter of an hour, creates another, better movie.

Why this was directed by a Norwegian is hard to guess; one can only say that the producers, who included Terrence Malick (also credited with the film's concept) took a chance and played a long shot. Obviously when the actors are speaking Vietnamese, they were on their own. Maybe that's why everybody starts speaking broken (but in Nguyen's case, surprisingly idiomatic) English after a while. There can be no other good reason.

There is no question about the fact that the writing and editing of "The Beautiful Country" are irredeemably flawed. Apart from stilted speeches, the script is marred by more fits and starts and inexplicable or incredible outcomes than can be listed here. This movie can be considered "timely" and socially significant and from that the allowances begin. It has -- or attempts -- an epic quality -- and visually it has fine moments. But the contrived screenplay and stilted dialogue make it painful viewing and an artistic disaster.
3 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
a very fine film,
jaybob23 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
The Beautiful Country Is a very well made & interesting film of a Vietnamese lad (about 20 yrs old) & his search for his American father. I have no way of knowing how true this story may or may not be, This should not deter you from seeing this poignant drama.

Nick Nolte is the American Father of the lad portrayed by

Damien Nguyen.He is just nothing short of excellent. Nick Nolte again proves what a fine actor he is in a short but excellent portrayal.

The only other name actor is Tim Roth as the Captain of the ship that takes our intrepid young hero to America. Tim Roth also gives another fine performance. His role like Nick Nolte's is small.

The other members of the cast are unknowns (to me), but are very good. The cinematography is excellent as well as the other technical credits.

This is a good movie & should be seen,

Rating: *** (out of 4)--88 points (out of 100) IMDb 8 (out of 10)
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Poignant
MikeyB179311 July 2009
Warning: Spoilers
This is a very touching and moving film with a strong and evocative story – a young man searching for his father. It is very acted by the main lead Damien Nguyen, who is in almost all the scenes in the movie. He carries the film along.

Even though this is filmed in many different locations from rural and urban Vietnam to New York City and Texas the story holds sway through-out; there is no loss of continuity or distractions. The interaction between Damien and 'his girlfriend' did at times seem to risk becoming a romance and this would have been a huge mistake and would have trivialized the story. The ending with Nick Nolte was somewhat of a surprise twist so I will not give that away. This is not a 'Nick Nolte' vehicle – he is only in the last 15 minutes.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Seattle International Film Festival - David Jeffers for Tablet Magazine SIFFblog
rdjeffers18 July 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Thursday June 9, 9:15pm Egyptian Theater Saturday June 11, 2:00pm Uptown Theater

Being loved and belonging is essential for most children. Those born to Vietnamese mothers and GI fathers often found neither. The Beautiful Country is the story of one such child, Binh, rejected by his rural village then struggling to find his American father. The film begins with green and wild country but descends into grimy sweaty ugliness and boredom. The considerable talents of Tim Roth and Temuera Morrison are wasted in pointless and ill conceived roles aboard the rusting freighter carrying Binh and is dying brother across the ocean with what appear to be stock shots of stormy seas. New York City offers slave labor and cliché characters. While very uneven from it's start the great curiosity of this film is the final segment. Nick Nolte is given top billing among the cast. I jokingly suggested he would probably be in the final scene only and was not far from the truth. As the journey brings Binh to Texas and his father the film takes on a serene and austere simplicity. A tenuous cohabitation knits these two men together into a family of father and son. The ninety odd minutes of garbage we have just watched is rewarded by a profound and subtle performance from Nolte as they slowly interact. The credits rolled and I was surprised to see the names of Badlands executive producer Edward Pressman and West Texas native Terrence Malick.
3 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
How I Won My War
pylgrym6 November 2007
It was my privilege to see this movie at the Plaza Theater in Atlanta on a Saturday afternoon with about 150 Vietnamese: grandparents, parents, and kids obviously "made in the U.S.A." . . it was even a greater privilege to be allowed to sit next to a typical third grader who's command of English is far better than his understanding of the parlance of the Old Country. His folks and grandparents, uncles, etc. were all around us, but allowed the lad to ask me questions during the movie while giving his family leisure to thoroughly enjoy it. I whispered my replies as plainly as I could, given the situation, and as we walked out of the show he wished me well and genuinely thanked me (with a little familial prodding).... My situation is that I am a Vietnam veteran whose reckless, existential behavior in 1971 may well have resulted in a son or daughter, as another reviewer, ''huckfinn'', above.... Amazingly, the LORD saw fit in His grace and mercy to save me in 1973, and off and on I cast about for a way to make peace with that part of my sordid past.... well, after I had been married for almost four years, Dung Tanh Phu came into my life, a blessing from World Vision. "Young", as we called him, born just after I left The Nam, had had no little difficulty arriving to America as one of the Boat people. His aunt, Mui and he were the only ones of his family to escape in 1979. So traumatized was Young that he was a problem child in his first, foster home. When we received him (in the name of Christ), he was tubercular. The wife put him on macrobiotics for six months and amazed the folks at the St. Louis County Health Department. We kept him for three formative years and turned him back over to his aunt in somewhat less than delightful circumstances, but that's a longer story.... I won my war by having such wonderful opportunities given to me for ministry to the wonderful Vietnamese and may yet win another of my wars - if God wills - but three's a story yet to be written... suffice it to say that I dearly loved my experience of this film, and hope to share it with my grown children someday. Blessings!
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An excellent, intelligent, heart wrenching movie.
stevespelling7 October 2006
Well worth seeing. It serves to give one a good understanding of the types of back stories, trials and travails that dispossessed immigrants coming to America might have experienced. I guess in some ways it could be similar to the story of many poor immigrants who came here in the past. Therefore it should have a universal appeal to American audiences. Next time we look at a first generation immigrant to this country we might have more of an appreciation of the humanity that we are encountering. Great performances all round, good screenplay, and thoughtfully directed. Bai Ling gives an excellent performance, and Damien Nguyen is outstanding in a first time lead role. He's in every scene and carries the entire picture... an incredible performance. One of the better movies of 2004.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed