Momma Don't Allow (1956) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Middle of the road for me
MissSimonetta16 November 2022
MOMMA DON'T ALLOW is largely of historical interest these days. The mid-50s jazz scene is portrayed with unvarnished documentary style, but otherwise, it's a repetitive 21 minutes. I felt the visuals were not as stunning as the other reviewers claim and while I'm interested in both of the directors attached to the film, they would go on to do far more memorable and artistically successful work in the (then) near future.

The one thing I got out of this: dancing seemed to consist mostly of spinning. I suppose that's better than the silly grinding I had to deal with in high school-- but like grinding, it gets monotonous after two minutes.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best Film Ever?...... Short Film Certainly!
scopitone21 May 2013
Hard to believe this is the first review for this euphoric, exhilarating and visually stunning film. Amazing film tells the story of at at least five different people at a nightclub dance party...... without one word of dialog. However, The Chris Barber Jazz Band performing at the party provides a constant live Swing /Dixieland & Rock 'n' Roll soundtrack for the films entire 22 minutes. Full of wonder & stunning first film for future Oscar winning directors Tony Richardson and Karel Reisz. Great look at 1955 Teddy Boys, Cool Kittens and Lindy Bop dancers. Delivers on every count..... Music, style, cinematography, storytelling and enthusiasm. A joy from start to finish. You'll wish it didn't end.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A REAL TREASURE
sinapisme26 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Of all the films catalogued in the the BFI archive denied widespread attention, this unique social historical document must be one of the most important. Reisz and Richardson proved a brilliant combination. At the time Richardson probably had the edge on creativity, Reisz provided the sharp observant camerawork. But with his later 'We are the Lambeth Boys' definitely more 'fly on the wall', 'Momma' is infinitely more perceptive. We catch the momentary anxiety in the eyes of the patient in the dentist chair as the drill descends to her open mouth. A classic extended rear shot of three cleaning ladies walking away from us on completion of their shift succeeds in conveying relaxation at the end of their arduous physical labour, and hints at the close bond between them. A conversation between our heroine's boyfriend and a pretty girl as they dance to a slow blues conveys a level of intimacy that we understand would make any girlfriend furious. A glimpse of a male dancer in battledress reminds us that this is era of National Service, for the young men a hugely disruptive factor which ruled their lives for two years between the ages of 18 and 20 - two years. Several of those present have short haircuts suggesting they are in or shortly demobbed from the services.

Our directors highlight the universality of the music by choosing subjects for focus across the rigid class system of the time. Our carriage cleaner would be lower working class, our butcher upper working class, our dental assistant middle class. It was the era of the 44 hour week - these three worked 48. The upper class 'Hooray Harrys', who briefly visit the club are clearly there to enjoy and not to patronise, although the driver feels it necessary to remove the mascot from the bonnet of his expensive car! The film was shot mainly in the early months of 1955, a time of major change in the UK music industry. The U.S dominated pop scene had held sway for decades with bands formed by celebrity leaders and swing-based line ups, and vocals featuring celebrity singers. Countrywide, ballrooms and major hotels provided live dance music on Saturday nights, the main outing of the week for the young.

By 1955 however, thanks to early post war pioneers like George Webb, with sufficient influence to cut records and promote concerts, traditional jazz music had forced its way into the national consciousness. Older generations, unable or disinclined to unravel the harmonics, branded it as hideous cacophany. Cue for the young to adopt it as their own and invent their own style of dancing in jazz clubs, which sprang up everywhere in the many available vacant sites, often below ground. The Chris Barber band was at an early stage of recognition and happy to accept a booking at the typical slightly sleazy Wood Green club. We see new boy trumpet player Pat Halcox, replacing the hard line New Orleans purist Ken Collyer, who proved a bit too pure for the rest of the band Singer Ottilie Paterson was another newcomer. On arrival in London from her Ulster home, she had been turned down when she approached them to sing during a gig. At the end of the evening she persuaded Johnny Parker, the pianist on the hit 'Bad Penny Blues' to play while she sang 'Careless Love Blues.' The band listened and hired her on the spot.

I understood them. I first heard Ottile's fantastic black voice on record on 'Bad Woman Blues' 'When i was nuttin' but a chile, all you men used to drive me wild.' Surely this was the great Bessie Smith reincarnated.

The film was instant nostalgia for me as I was part of that long ago scene. One evening at Macks in Oxford Street the retaining screw on Ottilie's mike stand sheared and I sat at her feet on the edge of the stage with right arm outstretched holding it together. After two consecutive protracted blues my muscles ached excrutiatingly but she thanked me graciously and the pain magically disappeared! .
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Good music, but that's it Warning: Spoilers
"Momma Don't Allow" is a British short film that runs for approximately 20 minutes and was made back in 1955, 10 years after the end of World War II, so this one is already over 60 years old. The directors Karel Reisz and Tony Richardson have had amazing careers, but this black-and-white short film here is probably among their least memorable works. We hear music from start ti finish and see people dancing to the wild jazz tunes. The whole thing is obviously recorded in a club and this is what they looked like back then. While I thought the music is a good listen for jazz fans, I cannot recommend this film anyway. The video site is just entirely forgettable. We see people dancing and that's it. Ultimately, there is no real reason to watch this instead of listening to an old record. I can only laugh when I read other reviewers call this the best (short) film ever made. Thumbs down from me and I don't recommend it.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed