Olive, the Other Reindeer (TV Movie 1999) Poster

(1999 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
36 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Christmas Movies,...what the World needs.
toxiemite21 December 2004
With so much war and moral decay in this world at present time, Christmas has become my favourite time of the year. Not just because it's a festive season and colourful... but because its a time that represents innocence and goodness in people. We need Christmas all year round, it might make the world a better place.

And that's why I am a sucker for Christmas movies so much. At the core, I am a die hard horror nut and general cinema lover all round... but one thing I cannot get enough of is an original and off-beat Christmas movie. Over the years there's been some gems like: 8 Crazy Nights, Nightmare Before Christmas, Santa Vs the Snowman, Christmas Vacation and The Grinch (to name only a few).

While 'Olive the Reindeer' is a few years old now, I only saw it recently having heard many good things about it. It is a wonderful little film suitable for the entire family. The story is simple, sweet and subtley hilarious. One reviewer on IMDb said that Drew Barrymore dragged the movie down.... I can't disagree more. I thought she was delightful. She has child-like innocence in her voice that puts a believability into the Olive character. Not to mention that she Co-Produced this film so possibly without her involvement, Olive may not have been made (I don't know!?).

Anyhow, if you want a Festive movie for the kids and adults alike to enjoy.... rent Olive the other Reindeer. It's sure to amuse and entertain.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Make It Rein - Very Good
ninjaalexs20 January 2022
Despite being Emmy nominated, here's a Christmas film virtually nobody talks about anymore.

Olive, the Other Reindeer is a 2D computer animated TV special. It has Olive who is a dog, a Jack Russell terrier, I think. Her best friend is a penguin who sells fake Rolex watches (Rolexxx to be precise). An evil postman plots to stop Santa delivering presents; because he's sick of delivering letters to Santa. After a misheard radio announcement Olive comes to the rescue as the other reindeer to pull the sleigh.

This film is very charming. It's now regarded as a classic. To be honest it's not up there with The Snowman, or some of the Rankin Bass productions, but it is great fun. The film has some grown up humour, but nothing sexual or edgy, mainly just pop culture references and wordplay. I preferred this over "Hooves of Fire". There's a superb mix of voice talent on show, Drew Barrymore is excellent; bringing a cute naivety to the role without being irritating.

Unfortunately, given this uses computer animation from over 20 years ago it looks a bit rough around the edges. I saw it in 2000 and I remember it looking great and it has a very unique style, which is sort of flat. Viewers will be reminded of early South Park episodes and Cel-shaded videogames like Wacky Races on the Dreamcast. Once you get over the dated look there is a lot to enjoy. At 46 minutes long it does outstay its welcome by about 15 minutes.

It was first broadcast and produced for Fox Television with Matt Groening serving as executive producer. It was later repeated on Nickelodeon the year after and on Channel 4 in the UK in 2000. It was repeated for a few years after, but it hasn't been broadcast in the UK since 2003 to my knowledge. A DVD has been released with a nice picture and some extras.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"grinch" for the younger generations?
postmanwhoalwaysringstwice21 December 2006
Matt Groening's "Olive, the Other Reindeer" started its life quietly as animated holiday filler in the winter of 1999, and has since become somewhat of a cult classic. The story blends an original story with some help from the holiday classics into one cohesive package, with a dash of "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" and a villain torn from the pages of Dr. Suess' "How the Grinch Stole Christmas". It tells the story of Olive, voiced with youthful exuberance by Drew Barrymore, a naive dog who is mislead into believing that Santa Claus will have to cancel Christmas unless he can receive assistance from "Olive, the other reindeer". Such sends Olive on a quest for the North Pole, with a peddler penguin by her side and the proverbial disgruntled postal worker trying to thwart her efforts. Though most of its forty-five minutes are filled with the cuteness factor, several full-bellied laughs, and great cameos (notably music's Michael Stipe and the legendary Ed Asner), what will keep "Olive, the other reindeer" from ultimately succeeding through the years are the weak musical numbers and its irritating third act.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
GREAT FUN!
xf_60331 December 1999
I loved this animated special on the FOX network. And Drew Barrymore just brought the main character to life. It's about a dog (Barrymore) who thinks she is a reindeer and goes on a quest to help Santa after one of the other reindeer can't. With the help of a little penguin named Martini, they accomplish their task while dodging the evil mailman who wants to stop Christmas. I hope this comes to video and DVD. I think it will be another instant classic like "How the Grinch Stole X-Mas" and "Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer". 5 out of 5 stars! So if it is aired next Christmas, DON'T MISS IT!
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
You will laugh, but you won't call Olive names.
Victor Field25 December 2002
One of the least accomplished episodes of "The Simpsons" was "Insane Clown Poppy," with Drew Barrymore as the voice of Krusty's illegitimate daughter Sophie. Happily, she and Matt Groening pre-emptively made up for this in 1999 with the charming "Olive, the Other Reindeer," which they executive produced, and which featured one of them (hint: not Matt) as the voice of the title character.

When Santa Claus faces a crisis that may mean his deliveries won't get through, lovable dog Olive mishears him on the radio hoping to depend on "all of the other reindeer," and believing that Mr. Kringle is counting on her, she's off to the North Pole with the help of her penguin friend Martini, but with a conniving postman (!) out to stop her. Only Scrooge would not be rooting for Olive and Martini to succeed in the course of this special, not least with the warm and winning voice work (particularly Barrymore as our four-legged friend, Joe Pantoliano cast against type as good guy Martini, and Michael Stipe as one of Santa's reindeer - who has a very funny joke about Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer).

A good, heartwarming story with computer animation from DNA Productions that looks more traditionally cartoony than the norm, which is not a bad thing here; Drew also does her own singing, and it must be said that she won't be giving Alicia Keys a run for her money - but her scrappy enthusiasm on her numbers ("Merry Christmas After All" provides an oddly endearing blend of Miss Barrymore's slightly flat vocalising and the truly musical Big Bad Voodoo Daddy) only adds to the special's charm. Funny and non-sick-making, this is up there with Channel 4's adaptation of "Father Christmas" and some of Rankin/Bass's seasonal cartoons in the winner stakes; one to tape.

"Warp speed, captain!"
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A cute Christmas special
Rectangular_businessman23 December 2012
Warning: Spoilers
"Olive, the Other Reindeer" was a cute Christmas special produced by produced by Matt Groening's The Curiosity Company, the same company behind the excellent animated series "Futurama". However, unlike "Futurama", this was an animation for the whole family, being aimed at kids, but I think that adults will find this to be quite enjoyable too.

The animation style from this special, despite being simplistic, was also very cute and well made, with very appealing designs and a neat use of colors.

The characters were likable and funny, the songs were catchy and the voice acting (Done by Drew Barrymore, Edward Asner, Dan Castellaneta, Joe Pantoliano and Matt Groening)was pretty good, making this a totally worth-watching experience.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An underrated Christmas classic
crothman11 December 2002
This has been somewhat overlooked, but it really is a terrific special. It's clever and witty (a characteristic that you don't see enough of these days). Olive is a dog, who thinks she can substitute for one of Santa's reindeer and save Christmas. The choice of villain is inspired -- a mailman who wants to stop Christmas so he won't have to deliver all the cards. Not a lot of big laughs, but it's filled with gentle smiles.

The voice work is excellent, and the style is outstanding. There's little attempt to be "realistic," but rather it looks like a picture book (and seems to be sticking closely to the style of the original book).
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A holiday guilty pleasure
TheOneManBoxOffice6 January 2017
Even though I'm 26 years old, I can't help but have a soft spot for some Christmas specials I saw as a kid. This is one of those specials that I have said spot for, and it happens to be produced by the same man behind everyone's favorite jaundice-skinned family "The Simpsons" and the animated sci-fi comedy "Futurama".

Based on the children's book by J. Otto Seibold and Vivian Walsh, this TV special focuses on a small dog named Olive (Drew Barrymore), who hears a radio broadcast where Santa mentions he's canceling Christmas due to Blitzen hurting his leg. However, when Santa mentions "all of the other reindeer", Olive mis-hears it as "Olive, the other reindeer" (hence the title), and thus, she treks her way to the North Pole with her penguin buddy Martini (Joe Pantoliano) to take Blitzen's place for the year, all while an irate postman (Dan "Homer Simpson" Castellaneta) chases her down so he can prevent Christmas from happening.

Now I fondly remember watching this one time on Cartoon Network, back when I watched that channel religiously, and I remember thoroughly enjoying it. Watching it as an adult, as silly as the plot is, I can say it's rather innocent family entertainment that anyone can smile at if they're in the right mood. The 2D-on-3D animation is really not that bad for a television special, it's only an hour long, and there are a few catchy songs thrown in for good measure.

It's not the best Christmas special out there, and the art style might turn some people off, but if you give it a chance, it's rather harmless. For me, I kinda like it, and I think a lot of kids and adults today will still enjoy it around the holiday season. I say give it a watch.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Surprise Favorite
cilardi10 December 2006
My wife, 5-year-old daughter, and I ran across this special last year. Seeing Drew Barrymore's name gave me some pause, as she had recently flashed David Letterman while giving him a birthday dance, so I wondered if this special was actually going to be suitable for family viewing, and not some subversive story with a Christmas theme. Well, I definitely over-thought this one: "Olive" was absolutely wonderful, and unexpectedly charming (a very rare commodity these days). Her voice work was heartfelt, and a truly eclectic list of other voices, ranging from Joe Pantoliano to co-producer Michael Stipe (whose experience in cartoons includes his hilarious appearance on the funniest "Space Ghost" episode ever-#17, "Hungry") keeps this story light and humorous. The animation style was appropriate to the story and, apparently, to the source material (I have not yet seen the book). I recommend it!
7 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Yes I know it's March not December, but who cares ?
myriamlenys30 March 2023
Warning: Spoilers
"Olive, the other reindeer" is charming, likeable Christmas entertainment for all the family. The movie tells a tale about a sweet-natured dog who mistakenly assumes that Santa wants her to help pull his sleigh. Santa had expressed no such wish but this does not keep the dog from trying, even though she's somewhat disadvantaged in the flying department.

I can't say that I was blown away by the animation style, which belonged squarely in the late 1990's and, presumably, wasn't thought particularly attractive even then. On the plus side, "Olive" is strewn with glorious jokes and puns, a number of which may take a few moments to register. Olive-the-nontypical-dog makes for an enormously sweet and friendly protagonist - some excellent voice work here - and her battle with her postman nemesis is genuinely funny.

Still, I wonder about the general message carried by "Olive". Is it "If you pursue your dreams with hope and energy, you may achieve greater things than you thought you were capable of" ? If so, I don't disagree. However, I fear the message may be closer to "If you pursue your dreams with hope and energy, you WILL achieve all your goals, however far-fetched and ambitious". Now this is the kind of "everybody can do, get or be anything they want" cr*p that self-help gurus and positive-thinking merchants have been peddling for decades, with disastrous results for Western societies. The fact that this cr*p is so wide-spread and pervasive doesn't make it any less cr*p.

So "Olive" may be a good starting point for a constructive parent-child discussion about the difference between reachable and unreachable goals.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
What a horrid, unworthy piece of trash!
douglaswells-0701212 December 2023
I don't know if preview reviews were written by people with no taste, or times have changed the way people look at 'good' movies/shows, or what.

The artwork is dreadful.

The dialogue is lackluster.

The 'star' (Drew Barrymore) is deservedly ranked as one of the worst (if not THE worst) actor of her generation (if not of several generations!).

There are 'adult' themes and lines in the movie that are not only nonsensical, but totally irrelevant to the story.

Drunk elves?

'Gangster' reindeer?

What a flop. I feel sorry for anyone that considers this, in any way, a Christmas 'classic'.

The whole storyline seems to be something that any 5+ year old child would find boring. I guess it would be a good thing to put on to PUT CHILDREN TO SLEEP QUICKLY!

I rate this with the just-as-horrible "Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer".
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A charmer. Deserves a long holiday-season life.
dick_d7 December 2002
If you've just noticed 1999's "Olive, the Other Reindeer" in your TV listings (as I did last night)and are checking it out on IMDb, I heartily recommend it. The script and characters do not ring any of the false notes that usually undo other Christmas fare. The cute story will keep kids interested, but is peppered with references and visual gags for grownups.

Drew Barrymore gives a plucky-not-sucky performance as Olive, and keeps her character's likability from turning sappy. Joe Pantoliano (Ralphie in "The Sopranos"!) as her shady-but-good-hearted sidekick Martini the penguin is a likeable Runyonesque pal. Michael "R.E.M" Stipe contributes a wry musical highlight in the bar scene. Dan "Homer" Castellaneta makes a fine villainous postman, and the other voice artists too numerous to mention here are also first-rate.

The 2D-in-3D computerized animation is highly imaginative but not gimmicky.

"Olive" is as enjoyable as any holiday entertainment since "A Christmas Story". Like that film, word-of-mouth should keep "Olive" around for many Christmases to come.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
You'll Go Down in History!
ExplorerDS678925 December 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Olive is not your ordinary, average dog. Nope, she's a Christmas-loving pooch who stepped in to save the holiday when Santa almost considered canceling his usual run. But I'm getting ahead of myself. I remember when this special aired 21 years ago (God, I feel old) and at the time, I didn't think much of it. It looked like another crappily animated cartoon big names threw together for big bucks. But now, two decades later, I've decided to give it another chance. So, back to our story in rendered Nintendo 64 Town, Olive loves the Christmasy time of year, even when her buzzkill owner Tim doesn't. He's disappointed that Olive isn't like other dogs, as they can talk to each other and she doesn't destroy things or make a mess in the house. He wants a wild mutt who will pee on his carpet and chew his slippers. Well, clearly, he knew what he was getting into when he bought a dog that could talk to him. Anyway, Olive went back to her doghouse to chat with her pet flea... as you do. But a bulletin on the radio warns the world that due to Blitzen suffering an unfortunate accident, Christmas might very well be canceled. But when Santa says he'll have to make do with all of the other reindeer, Fido the flea misinterprets that as "Olive the other reindeer" and tells the amiable pooch that she's really a reindeer and suggests she go to the North Pole. To get her going, the flea purposely misinterprets Tim when he comes over to apologize, making it sound like he didn't want Olive anymore and was getting a new dog. Fido is a jerk. And so, Olive heads off to find a way to the North Pole, accidentally bumping into the surly post man called... Post Man, and he sounds like Dan Castellaneta doing a decent imitation of Vincent Price. On this day, Post Man is unusually happy because Christmas seems to have been canceled. He hates Christmas because it means extra work for him, and when he hears Olive intends to save Christmas, he plans to stop her by any means necessary. So when the stalwart dog buys a bus ticket to the North Pole, she's accompanied by a con artist penguin named Martini, who reluctantly saves Olive when the Post Man attempts to kidnap her... that's a sentence I just said. En route to the north, Olive and Martini meet the bus driver named Richard Stands, who thought the Pledge of Allegience was about him (for which it stands) and some other tourists who try to tell her she misheard Santa and was wasting her time, but Olive stands by her assertion that she is a reindeer and that Santa, as well as the whole world, needs her. Speaking of wasting time, that zany Post Man is still hot on that pup's trail... what? Jingle All the Way can't be the only Christmas movie to have a crazy mailman villain.

They arrive at Arctic Junction, where Richard treats Olive and Martini to some food, while the Postman becomes Guy N. Cognito, the waitress. He tells Olive that Santa is waiting outside and wants to meet her, and because Olive is too gullible for her own good, she falls for the rookie mistake and the whacked-out mailman takes her hostage. In the back of his van, she finds a parcel addressed to her from, and I'm not kidding, Deus Ex Machina... don't you just love that guy? It's a metal file, which Olive uses to liberate herself from her captivity. Fortunately, Martini was still at the diner and they try to find somebody in the bar who can take them the rest of the way, only they discover the bar to be full of rubbernecks, surly reindeer and belligerent elves. They scoff at Olive being a reindeer and threaten to chuck her off the roof, when she makes another passionate speech about finding her place and that you should earn what you want, and not just get it... hear that, welfare frauds? Seeing the error of their ways, everyone apologizes for being a jerk and trucker Round John Virgin (Round yon virgin) agrees to take Olive and Martini the rest of the way. Upon reaching the North Pole, they discover a press conference being held, awaiting Santa Claus to officially announce he's canceling his Christmas Eve flight, though St. Nick himself feels reluctant to do so. At first, Olive is barred from getting in by a jerk gate guard elf, but after a nice distraction from Martini, Olive gets in and tells Santa she's the "other reindeer". So with no other alternative, they strap her in with the rest of the team, while the evil Post Man arrives to deliver Santa more letters, all nasty notes telling the jolly man they hate him and to "lose weight". You know, I have a feeling those letters aren't from actual children. Post Man also pulls a fast one by stealing Santa's sack of toys and replacing it with junk mail. Dude, you have serious issues. Even the Grinch would tell you to tone it down. So, with Olive trying her best to keep up with the rest of the team, Santa's sleigh takes flight. But upon landing at their first stop, they discover the presents gone. Olive knew who was behind it, so using her terrific power of scent, she leads them to the Post Man, who had kidnapped Martini and was most likely on his way to dispose of the toys. They manage to catch him, making his truck crash. With the gifts back in the sleigh and the Post Man subdued, Olive and the other reindeer successfully complete their run, and she makes it home in time to celebrate Christmas with Tim. So, Christmas was saved, Santa and his reindeer had their confidence restored, Martini went straight and was given his old job back at the zoo, and even donated a brand new penguin: the bound up Post Man. He really should thank Martini, because after he's fired from the post office and probably jailed for the numerous laws he broke, he'd be lucky to be allowed anywhere near a mail box again. So it was a Merry Christmas for all!

After watching this again after so many years, I have to say it was better than I remembered it. The animation is weird, the characters look disjointed and, as stated above, it looks like an early N64 game, but animation aside, the voice acting is really good. That's Drew Barrymore as Olive, Dan Castellaneta as the Post Man, Joe Pantoliano as Martini, Ed Asner as Santa (so does this take place in the same universe as Elf?) and Peter MacNicol as Fido, all gave very lively and enjoyable performances. Some jokes are pretty funny too, and the humor doesn't get lowbrow, as a lot of these types of shows often do. The characters are very likable, even the Post Man who is so over-the-top that you can't help but laugh at him. So this Christmas, if you've seen it already or want to see it for the first time, I recommend Olive the Other Reindeer.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Enchanting Christmas Movie
Scout41923 January 2000
This Christmas movie, is destined to be a wonderful Christmas classic. Olive the other Reindeer is a charming Christmas story with a bit of abstract modern animation that still manages to be very endearing and quite original compared to the very frequent re-hashings of Christmas type stories. I hope they release this movie on DVD or Video, I would certainly buy it. I hope this wonderful movie is aired again next year.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
refreshingly unique holiday film
joesgirljeri27 November 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This is a holiday movie that will definitely be a classic in our home. The characters are bright and engaging, the story is warm and delightful but has a unique twist and some modern spunk to it. The animation style is taken directly from the original Olive book but they've made this little 2-D dog very convincing in her 3-D world.

This movie appeals to a wide range of viewers, it has funny characters for children, subtle humor for the adults, and the dialog is refreshingly snappy. Olive is hilarious as a dog who doesn't do any "dog" things. Drew Barrymore's voice is perfect for such an innocently sweet, good-hearted animal character. I loved the postman, he makes the most deliciously evil bad-guy. The songs are wonderful; jazzy, catchy and upbeat and you'll be catching yourself singing "Bah, bug and hum" for days.

The thing I liked best about this movie is that it wasn't silly, sappy, dark, heavy on the morals or boring. It was just a darling movie about a sweet little dog who wants to do her best to save Christmas.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Enchanting story with beautiful drawings
Antantz22 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
During the release of Futurama, Matt Groening creator of The Simpsons made another classic: Olive, the Other Reindeer! With its cute story and beautiful drawing design that looks like it has come straight out of the Vivian Walsh children's book and onto our screens! After falling out with her owner Tim, Olive mishears from her little friend 'Fido' that one of Santa's reindeer 'Blitzen' has been injured during a test flight and may not be able to pull the sleigh on Christmas Eve. Olive sets out to replace the injured reindeer, meeting new people along the way. Meanwhile, after hearing of Olive's plans to save the Christmas Eve flight, a nasty postman who hates Christmas attempts to derail Olive's plans so that he can put an end to the Holiday once and for all. After a few mishaps, Olive eventually makes her way to the North Pole and finally (after a bit of convincing Santa) saves the Christmas Eve flight with the Postman finally getting his just deserts.

This is an awesome movie to watch at the end of the year which adults and children will both like.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An unexpected Christmas cracker
TheLittleSongbird25 December 2009
I really enjoyed this special when I was little, and revisiting it again after, ooh, six years I loved it as much as I did even then.

The only minor quibble I have is that sometimes the pacing is a tad too slow, but because I enjoyed Olive the Other Reindeer so much I was past caring.

The computer animation is highly imaginative, and does have this sophisticated look. Plus it stayed true to the illustrations of the book it is based on.

The music is just as delightful. The incidental music is lovely and fitting with every scene and the songs themselves and there are only a few are well above average.

The writing is also spot on, and the writers certainly did their homework by allowing the hilarious puns to come thick and fast. And I loved the sweet and heart warming story That just leaves the voice acting. It was marvellous, Drew Barrymore gave a very expressive and heartfelt voice to Olive, who is plain adorable and spirited. Joe Pantoliano was hilarious as the penguin Martini, and Edward Asner is suitably merry as Santa. The villain is a postman bent on ruining Christmas; he isn't the most sophisticated villain ever but he is a funny one. As usual, Dan Castallenetta was great.

All in all, an unexpected Christmas cracker. 9.5/10 Bethany Cox
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Funny but more straightforward than you'd hope from Groening
bob the moo30 December 2002
Olive is an ambitious little dog who hears that one of Santa's reindeer has been injured and may not be able to pull the sleigh. Olive sets out to set into the place of the reindeer, making a few friends along the way. Meanwhile a bitter mailman sets out to ruin Christmas for all concerned.

I caught this early on Christmas Day buried in the middle of every channel trying to put up some feel good programmes and films about Santa and reindeers – mostly animations. This one struck me because how different the animation was – a little weird and off-kilter to be just another banged out Christmas animation. Then I noticed it was produced by Matt Groening – he of Simpsons and Futurama fame. I had hoped that this would be as sharp as some of the better episodes of those series but it didn't quite make it.

Generally it was amusing and it did have a few characters that were sharp and delivered one liners and I suppose the whole set up is inventive enough and different enough to stand out from the crowd of feel good animations on this morning. But it wasn't in the same league as Groening's Simpsons episodes. However the humour is sufficient to make it stand out and the voice work helps a lot.

Barrymore brings a relentless cheerfulness to Olive and the various side kicks help. Pantoliano is the best voice as the penguin Martini while others include Jay Mohr, Castellaneta, Stipe and MacNicol. It's not star studded which is good as that can often replace a quality product, but the cast are all good enough to deliver on the story's potential.

Overall this can't hold a candle to much of Groening's other work but as a competitor for your attentions amongst a host of other festive cartoons then this should easily beat many of the other stocking fillers that the networks serve up to fill the day.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Fine Line
j1j23 December 2006
Somewhere in the middle of this movie, our main character is in a bind in a mail truck. Looking around, she finds a package, addressed to her, that helps get her out of it. The sender? Deus ex Machina.

It is quite common for children's movie makers, especially in the animated genre, to try to be modern, hip - to push the limits of their audience. The results are usually just vulgar - anyone who ever watched 8 Crazy Nights, regardless of their opinions on the rude, contrived piece - can't help but wonder if it is appropriate for all children, at least those whose behavior we have to live with. Olive is witty, funny, and original, and yet there is no smart- alecky kid, no fart jokes - it's interesting because it's tightly written, well-crafted, and voiced by excellent people.

Several people have written about Ms. Barrymore's voice in it - it's laughable to imply that she had meant to create a refined, beautiful sound, as well as a bit sexist. No one questioned that Dan Castellaneta (read: Homer Simpson) also sings an off-key silly song - but Drew Barrymore is compared to Alicia Keys? No, if a Dog - no, a dog who was eager, sweet, and unflappably lovable - had a speaking and singing voice, hers would be it.

Altogether, I can think of no modern Christmas or holiday special (Martini, Olive's penguin friend, is Jewish, somehow), that succeeds in being warm, smart, and interesting all at the same time. There is no preaching, no moralizing, and yet, it leaves you feeling good about being good, almost the same way the Charlie Brown Christmas Special did just over 40 years ago. There's a fine line between sappy and sweet, rude and witty - Olive the Other Reindeer stands firmly on the good side of that line.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Quirky and entertaining
tiggaa-465534 December 2018
This show ought to become a classic. I'm not sure why it doesn't get more attention. Many of the best jokes are subtle by today's standards. Maybe that's it. Honestly not sure what kids think of it, but adults should appreciate it. I look forward to watching this every year!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
In a word, marvelous.
PhinePhriend1 January 2001
This show was absolutely hilarious. I sat there, watching it, laughing my rear off every three seconds. I regretted not recording it when it was on Fox. I can't even tell you how hilarious it was. Does it have schmaltz, you ask? that terrible plot ploy that has made several family films into absolute terrors to watch? Heck no! It's simply a funny, adroit film that should be on everyone's shelf. Watch it. 'Nuf said.
6 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Adorable. Just adorable.
kmccabe-25 December 2000
I missed the end of this film! I'm so upset. Now I'll never know if Olive succeeded in saving Christmas. There I was, Christmas Eve, sitting on the couch, flicking channels, waiting for my ride to turn up. A long night of drinking and general carousing awaited. Suddenly I was tuned into Channel 4 and watching a streetwise penguin trying to sell fake designer watches to a talking dog. Well, it happens every day, doesn't it?

So anyway, I could talk about plot, like that matters, and I could go on about how funny it was, or how heart warming, but would you really care? Would you? Let me just say this, I was utterly charmed the gloriously flat CGI characters in a totally unique 3D universe. And despite what some of the other reviewers have said, I found Drew Barrymore's characterisation absolutely perfect.

Barrymore's squeaky little confused voice was the delightful embodiment of this dopey, self-deluding dog. A dog who manages to convince herself that Santa, after a minor Pre-Christmas Reindeer incident, was relying on 'Olive, the Other Reindeer' and NOT the 'all of the other reindeer' he actually refers to.

How could you not love this film?

Just thinking about it now, I feel certain that Olive must have helped Santa save Christmas. If she didn't, where did all those presents come from this morning? I was certainly in no fit state to help out.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
a wonderful Christmas movie the whole family will enjoy
TheUnknown837-19 December 2007
"Olive the Other Reindeer" is a very unique film in a lot of regards, but it is also one of the better of the modern animated Christmas specials. Like a lot of family holiday specials, it is relatively short, clocking at a mere forty-five minutes long and in my point of view, that is far too short seeing how well-written, well-animated, well-acted, and simply wonderful and rich the movie is as a whole. It features some of the best animated characters I've ever seen, has a very good plot, is funny, not too childish or immature, but is not too perilous or mature for the kiddies. It is the kind of film that the entire family will enjoy.

The characters of "Olive the Other Reindeer" are very rich and developed, surprising seeing as how they are in a very short film. Characters get introduced and developed perfectly quickly, but are on screen for plenty of time considering the short overall length of the film. Olive is is a great Christmas heroine with Drew Barrymore's voice working to perfection in the role. One is not sure of Olive's exact age in dog years, whether she's young, or a middle-aged adult dog and this works out. She does seem to be very youthful, shown by her hopes and spirits.

The character of Martini the penguin is my personal favorite out of the entire cast. He is the smooth-talking comical and intelligent character we all love, who stands up for himself and does not let his size discourage him, quoting lines such as "Stand up for free enterprise! Fight demand!" and "The laws of breaking and entering, as the pertain to Santa, are unclear". Overall, a great addition who is the real reason why I wish the movie was longer.

There are other supporting characters like the comical Richard Stands, Olive's owner Tim, the reindeer, and there is of course, the character who makes all Christmas movies work out. Santa Clause himself. The character is well-done in this movie with a suiting voice that sounds both aging and tired-out, yet still having the supportive attitude of a sports coach at the same time. Santa isn't the main focus of the story, but is a strong central point, seeing as how most of the joy of Christmas revolves around his yearly flight.

The antagonist of the film is a mailman simply referred to be other characters as The Postman. Properly, his real name is not revealed on screen, making him seem more villainous. He's not a frightening villain, but still retains the qualities that are needed for an antagonist. He provides a lot of comical relief as he attempts to stop Olive and the others from saving the holiday of Christmas.

The animation in the film is very unique, almost everything being done in 2-D animation. The characters are all like flat cut-outs put in 3-D backgrounds, and there is something very unique and attractive about this. They may be paper-flat, but they don't seem to be. There are a few parts of the animation that do look strange. Such as this one part where a policeman approaches from in front of us. It looks kind of odd with his head sticking point off to the side and his arms swaying from his sides to his stomach and back, but then again, it's not very bothering or distracting. It may even be more funny for the kids and just almost unnoticeable to the adults.

Like many Christmas movies, there are a fair share of songs in the film, but they are not immature songs and each one has its own mood. Some of them are original holiday songs that pertain to a certain character's perspective, others are a bit darker or persuasive, and they all work out to enhance the characters who are singing them. Well-written songs like these are what helps make movies like "Olive the Other Reindeer" special and magical.

Again, the only flaw with "Olive the Other Reindeer" is its overall too short of a running time. I would have personally like to have seen it at least twenty minutes longer, seeing as how it was very enriched with talented voice work and a compelling storyline. But the way it is, it's a great Christmas movie and one of the best ones to turn out in recent years. I recommend it for the whole family.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An absolute joy, not to be missed!
I_Ailurophile22 February 2023
Can we please just take a moment to appreciate what a total delight this is? Anthropomorphized talking animals, a dog who doesn't exhibit all the customary domestic canine behaviors, and an utterly extraordinary voice cast would be enough all by themselves to sell the special, to say nothing of the fun songs. As if all that weren't enough, the animation at once looks very 2D but is also meaningfully 3D, is relatively simplistic yet is rich and colorful nonetheless, and further distinctly recalls the illustration styles of children's books. Add in the wonderful, silly, but warmhearted screenplay of Steve Young, based on J. Otto Seibold's book - a joyful variety of characters, fun dialogue and scene writing, and an imaginative story - and how could one possibly say that 'Olive, the other reindeer' is anything less than fantastic?

To whatever extent the vibrant animation could arguably be said to lack detail (if true, certainly only by comparison to other styles), the writing more than makes up for it. The world of 'The other reindeer' is filled with little bits and pieces that are fabulously entertaining, jaunty and jolly and terrifically inventive. The tale happily dispenses with any fragment of reality to revel in the ridiculous, from a cheekily cartoonish antagonist, to clever use of an often dubious plot device, to small nods and references, to the sheer willingness to let every character be who they want to be. Why, to that point, there are gratifyingly heartfelt, lovely themes peeking just around the corner - equal parts underhanded and obvious - and obliquely cementing the overall tack of the feature, please note the subtle acknowledgements in this "Christmas" story of other holidays that exist.

Between wordplay, situational humor, and gentle sight gags, the film is also flush with light comedy that gracefully adjoins the irreverent yet earnest storytelling. And that's to say nothing of the uncomplicated pleasure of listening to the voice cast who were clearly just having a blast bringing the tale to life. Perhaps I overstep, yet I wonder if Drew Barrymore, Joe Pantoliano, Jay Mohr, or even Peter MacNicol have ever had as much fun elsewhere as they do here, to say nothing of the involvement of Michael Stipe, Tim Meadows, Ed Asner, and many more. Everyone imbues their characters with such glad personality, doing as much behind their microphones as Young and Seibold at their keyboards to make 'Olive' the exceptionally amusing picture that it is. And where would this be without director Steve Moore or producer Matt Groening to tie all the component parts together?

It doesn't matter if it's Christmas Eve or the middle of July, or if a viewer is preteen or elderly: anyone who enjoys a good, genuine, jovial diversion will surely get a kick out of this, and at only 45 minutes, it takes no time at all to watch, and watch again. One rather assumes from the premise that it will be adorable and charming, but still I'm pleased with just how refreshing and satisfying the end result is. 'Olive, the other reindeer' is a modern classic that deserves to be revered alongside holiday classics of years long past, and I can't wait to see it again!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An unusual yet adorable animated Christmas special
Stompgal_8727 December 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I remember seeing the first half of this at Christmas when I was about 13 and up until now the only part I could remember was the mention of the 4th of July in Olive's opening song. Also I actually thought Olive was a reindeer but she is really a dog and an endearing character who was superbly voiced by Drew Barrymore who was particularly recognisable in this special. This morning when I was flicking through the channels, I caught this towards the end on E4 so I watched it from the beginning on E4 +1 and I found it more substantial and entertaining that time around.

The animation style is unusual but it matches the cover illustration of the book (I haven't read it, I just saw its cover whilst looking at it on Amazon) and the character movements are smooth. While I thought the lip-sync was initially basic, it turned out to be more detailed than I remembered. Although the backgrounds look as through they were rendered using cheap CGI, they were quite vibrant. Further to the characters, the postman is a decent villain who has a sudden change of personality but it was comical when he disguised himself as a waitress. Fido's mishearings of Santa saying he had to "make do with all of the other reindeer" and Tim apologising to Olive through the window of her kennel as she hides were essential parts of the story and Martini the penguin is funny. In addition to Barrymore as Olive and Dan Castellanetta (best known for his role as Homer Simpson in my all-time favourite animated sitcom) as the postman, other well-known cast members include Michael Stipe (REM's frontman) as Schintzel the reindeer, Matt Groening (one of the special's executive producers and creator of 'The Simpsons') as Arturo the Elf and Edward Asner (who later provided the voice of Carl in Disney and Pixar's bittersweet adventure 'Up') as Santa. All songs but 'Merry Christmas, After All,' which was initially forgettable but was likable the second time around due to its rock 'n' roll feel and accompanying around-the-world sequence, are memorable, especially Olive's opening song and the incidental music is magical and whimsical if generic and slightly repetitive in parts. The story has several twists and turns if some parts are clichéd but it is very different from the stories of many other Christmas specials and when I told one of my university classmates about this special, it kind of reminded her of the storyline of 'Annabelle's Wish' (due to Olive and Annabelle both wanting to be reindeer) that I should finish watching someday because it is so far so good. Although I felt that Olive should have worn the headband with antlers during Santa's sleigh ride rather than towards the end, I still found this a cute and amusing part of the film.

Anyway, here's my verdict. I found this a slightly bizarre yet adorable and underrated animated Christmas special with its brightest spots being the character animation, the storyline, the dialogue, the voice acting and the majority of the music. 8/10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed