Eat (1964) User Reviews

The most useless film ever made...

[MRBICKLE · 1/10 · 29 October 2001]

Is normal to have curiosity about the attempts on cinema of such an interesting personality like Andy Warhol, but "Eat" is such an idiotic, boring and uninteresting film that any interest disappears. But well, after all it's an experimental film made by someone with real anxiety for discovering new ways of express his art.

"Eat" are 40 neverending minutes watching a man eating a mushroom (later a cat appears but basically that's the plot). A peace metaphor? A contemplative experience? 40 minutes of wasted celluloid? I'll let everyone be the judge.

Incredibly funny!

[jchokey · 8/10 · 25 February 2002]

I had never thought much of Andy Warhol as a filmmaker. The thought of watching a motionless movie of the Empire State Building (his movie Empire) or of watching somebody eat (this one) something just seemed to me to be pointless, pretentious and tedious. But then again-- I had never actually seen one of his films. This was just an opinion based on what I had heard about them.

However, a few years ago, I was visiting the Andy Warhol museum in Pittsburgh and I happened to stumble across _Eat_ playing in the cinema room. And then-- I got it! This stuff is supposed to be funny, amusing, and playful-- not taken with high church seriousness! Or at least _Eat_ is. Watching the guy in the movie take 30 minutes to eat an apple (or a peach or whatever it was) sounds like it should be tedious, but it's not. In truth, it was actually one of the funniest things I'd ever seen. He takes a bite, he chews, he chews, he chews, he pauses, he chews some more, he looks at the apple again, chews some more, swallows-- no, he's still chewing.... Yeah, it sounds really dull to hear me describe it like that.... but really, if you actually watch it, it's incredibly comical. The other two people who came out of the movie room when it was over were also in hysterics. I know it sounds crazy, absurd, and unbelievable-- but this movie really is incredibly funny. You have to watch it to see why, though.... it really just can't be communicated in words.

A Guy Sits And Eats

[alexduffy2000 · 7/10 · 7 August 2002]

EAT is a guy sitting on a couch and eating what looks like bread rolls for more than half an hour. It's black and white and silent. If you've never seen one of Warhol's experimental films, this one might be a good place to start, but it might turn you off from seeing any more of them. Still, it's something you wont forget soon, it's a lot like the films from the 1890's just showing someone doing something mundane, except it goes on a lot longer. But art it is.

A beautiful film portrait.

[noelartm · 10/10 · 27 June 2005]

What can I say about this film that hasn't been said already? Well, if you add some Velvet Underground music to it, it makes a great music video. Also, John Cale put out a CD with music for this film and A.W.'s KISS. The film seems to change depending on what music you play to accompany it or if you just watch it silent. Like A.W.'s other "screen tests", the face seems to change if you stare at it for any length of time. So A.W. was taking the portrait to a whole new level. It's one of those simple yet profound ideas that had many artists saying "Now why didn't I think of that?". It's not hard to imagine an art gallery event with films like this playing on flat screen TVs while people mingle and music plays in the background. So rock on Andy Warhol!

A good film easy to digest

[Rodrigo_Amaro · 7/10 · 6 August 2012]

Andy Warhol's experimental film "Eat" is all about a man eating mushrooms in its almost 40 minutes of projection, only interrupting such act to joyfully play with a cat and have some deep inner thoughts which the audience must imagine since there's no dialogs whatsoever and silent above all. This is another fascinating experiment coming from the same artist who made us watch a man sleep, another getting a hum job, and couples kissing, among other precious works. Boring to some, futile to others, or amazing to few fortunate viewers, "Eat" is just what it proposes and nothing more, and that's why it is quite a good film.

What Warhol gives us, other than the just an almost frozen image of a man sitting eating mushrooms, is the imagination, it's the small details, it's trying to figure out what this man is thinking and each viewer will create his/her own conclusions. And the director couldn't find a better actor for the job. The man eating the mushroom is played by Robert Indiana, a very expressive figure who sadly only appeared in this short film, but he makes an impressive acting. Take a look at his facial expressions while eating, staring at the camera for brief moments, his love for the cat that suddenly appears on his side, and his genuine and affective smile that reveals a true joy that unfortunate it might be invisible to us. Is he smiling because someone told him to? Is he seeing something funny we cannot see? Or eating mushrooms cause such sensation? I don't know. What I do know is that he's perfect for the role and he's born under my star sign, one of the most patient signs of all (if not the most), Virgo and be patient to perform in something like this is completely necessary, not very easy to do. One could get easily distracted, bored in just sitting in front of a camera and keep on eating something for more than half an hour. I wouldn't be shocked if viewers find "Eat" a boring film. But no, Indiana has Job's patience, moving a few times and enjoying himself.

If you're open to real yet unusual film experiences and don't mind to focus your attention on a men eating, "Eat" is a good way to know about Warhol's underground films. I'm only rating this lower than "Blow Job" because that was a more challengeable film while this was almost like an exercise, presenting us an simple act extended to a long period. 7/10

Free Thought while Chewing Bareback

[mrdonleone · 8/10 · 20 November 2019]

Can you imagine how it feels like to eat just to eat and nothing but to eats just imagine me to fill Morocco and blood blood in between as it might be some crazy guy a rolling with the camera and the lighting is too much and I are black spots everywhere and then before you know the guy with the hat is true and again it is incredible you seem to Tru shoes I don't really know what else is doing is looking to the right what might be all right we don't know but you see the guy and he's chewing the guys chilling like a professional who like on the street in the middle of the night everybody's home going out for work and yet what do they do they put food inside the mouth and the truth just imagine what she'll like I would like a professional football player yes and he's chewing it again and it's true and it again and it's doing it again yes is a great man before we know it received the cat chew again and the hat and Drew the mass moves and it must be to the left it is all right but it's left in reality of course because people don't always understand that the screen is left in reality but in all reality right is there left is a fictional left or right it depends on how you see you then or is the same ball is 1 in Charlotte allies the great when we know what the guy is looking at this again and he's standing in front of us can it's easy to glasses with alien heads is it the seat is it something from an optician you know a guy who does the ice it reminds me of about to go once hit me in my face and my I did click and then before I know it that's a double and then cuz it's all done and that was before I knew right then I went to the doctor and the doctor in Africa just put something in front of your face and then the guy here but the guy can see clearly very well and then the doctor and didn't have enough two weeks ago 3 the scene and then I could see the still into phrase double science because of my ex's and same thing with the guy here the guy who's looking and showing going slowly and then of course we wonder what the whole thing is about because he's doing is looking down is looking at his feet or is it a woman sucking him off we don't know but he's looking he's waiting he's taking his time to sit on the seat moving the chin of his face up and down and up and down and up and down like a villain done before we know it received at the pussycat asleep in the north of the screen but it might be a pussy cat sleeping in there is something that they can remove a little bit left before did we didn't receive before it was something very beautiful it's like like a something the name something written but upset me from the ground to the top from the top to the ground. We expected from the ground to the top and then before we know it received the guy turn his head he has a hat don't like in the sixties what was its name french guy from breathless from saint Louis no drama she'll know we don't know but the whole thing of course is that we love is his name of the actress killed herself what was her name I forgot in the guy icon screen cleaner is thinking about sending because he's not doing anything is doing is putting it in and out of his mouth but let us think what the transverse the actress killed herself in real life and butts Merrick many times in the guys thinking what could it be about and then of course before we know it we see that's