Billy the Kid's Gun Justice (1940) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
"Boy it sure looks like you had yourself a time"!
classicsoncall2 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
Well even if you enjoy watching the B Western output of the Thirties and Forties, you have to admit that the believability factor for this one is set undeniably low. Not only does Billy the Kid (Bob Steele) retrieve the money spent by local ranchers to buy their land without secure water rights, but he does it by convincing the bad guys to fork over twenty five grand for a phony stash of gold. Did you ever see the main villain in one of these oaters willingly give up that much money? They would usually make some sort of bargain like that and then just kill the unsuspecting rancher they just dealt with, stealing the money back in the process. This guy Cobb Allen (Al Ferguson) sure wasn't thinking straight.

Bob Steele teamed with Fuzzy St. John in a half dozen of these Billy the Kid tales made by Producers Releasing in 1940/41. Steele's Billy was noticeably older than his historical counterpart, and he portrayed him as a hero who was framed by circumstances to look like a villain. In fact, this picture offered a five thousand dollar reward poster for Billy, but unless I missed it, I don't think it was ever mentioned why he was wanted.

Probably the best sequence in the story doesn't even involve Billy at all. It's when Fuzzy heads into the local saloon and puts on a drunk routine to lay out the phony gold story. Cobb Allen's henchmen (Charles King and Kenne Duncan) are taken in, and they figure they'd like to go it alone, so that adds another layer of incredibility to the story, as they wind up bidding against their own boss for the right to buy out the former Blanchard, now Roberts spread. In the middle is Billy, raising the stakes even higher.

I can't say there was a whole lot of action to this one, just some of your standard horse chases and that's about it. The gunfights didn't amount to much and the finale wrapped things up just a bit too quickly, so if you tune in, don't blink. But at least it was another successful outing for Billy and Fuzzy, who wind up heading off into the sunset for their next adventure.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Okay but typical entry in the P.R.C., Billy The Kid series
FightingWesterner5 August 2009
There's no real fireworks in Billy The Kid's Gun Justice. It's fast paced enough but runs out of steam near the end.

The standard issue plot consists of Billy and his sidekick Fuzzy trying to unravel the mystery of a friend's missing uncle and bring to justice the criminals behind the disappearance whom they suspect are also behind a related land swindle.

There's a few decent action scenes and Bob Steele is good as the wanted (framed) title outlaw. His tough guy posturing is pretty interesting compared to the somewhat sensitive men you usually see wearing white and wooing the ladies in these types of pictures.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Even with the stupid Billy the Kid angle, it's an awfully good B-western
planktonrules18 May 2014
"Billy the Kid's Gun Justice" sure surprised me. I was set to hate the film but ended up enjoying it quite a bit. Why was I so prepared to dislike the film? Well, it was made by PRC--a tiny production company known for making crappy films. Additionally, I HATE films that idolize western villains like Billy the Kid, Jesse James and the rest. These films completely fictionalize these real life killers--making them heroes! It's all complete bull! But, oddly, the film manages to overcome all this because the plot was clever...and that's something you usually don't see in B-westerns.

Billy and his friends, Jeff (Carleton Young) and Fuzzy (Al St. John) are headed to the ranch owned by Jeff's uncle. However, when they arrive they find a nice family is living there and they've never heard of the uncle. They insist that they were sold the property by a scum-bag named Allen (Al Ferguson). And, it turns out Allen has been cheating all the local homesteaders by selling them property he doesn't even own and then denying them water rights! So, it's up to our trio of heroes to save the day. None of this is unusual for a B and the plot is pretty familiar. However, HOW they resolve all this is what makes the film so interesting. It is NOT settled with guns but with brains--imagine that!

Overall, it's well made and worth seeing just to see Fuzzy's cool drunk scene. Well worth your time and like most of Bob Steele's westerns, full of fist fights!
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Ambushed
StrictlyConfidential5 September 2021
Warning: Spoilers
"Billy The Kid's Gun Justice" was originally released back in 1940.

Anyway - As the story goes - Billy the Kid and his pals stumble across a water rights squabble between some recent homesteaders and the crooked man who sold them their land. It seems the crook and his gang has diverted the water away from the ranchers, where they are forcing the landowners to pay exorbitant fees for water.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Justice And water to the valley
bkoganbing17 June 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Billy The Kid's Gun Justice finds Bob Steele and his two sidekicks hip deep in the middle of a gun battle with a posse. But a little clever tunneling by Al St. John allows, Steele, St. John, and Carleton Young to escape. Seeking a place of refuge they go to Young's uncle's place where they find new owners who bought the place from Al Ferguson and who never heard of the uncle.

There's quite a little bit of fraud going on here with Ferguson pushing people off their place then selling the land to the new owners, but withholding water by diverting a stream that fed all the homesteads. But Ferguson's villainy goes much deeper than that.

With the sheriff forced to turn a blind eye, Billy The Kid and sidekicks right all the wrongs and brings justice to the valley. And there's water for all. A lot of it involves an elaborate con game with the rubbery legged Al St. John pulling quite a drunk act.

One of the better Billy The Kid westerns from PRC.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed