"Theatre Night" The Devil's Disciple (TV Episode 1987) Poster

(TV Series)

(1987)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Wit, Wisdom or Words?
boblipton30 May 2006
Although THE DEVIL'S DISCIPLE is not one of George Bernard Shaw's best plays, it is a pretty fair historical piece, boasting, as it does, one of his more genuinely witty characters, in the personage of John Burgoyne, sometimes Parliamentarian, sometimes playwright, and always, in this show at least, possessed of a sardonic turn of phrase.

The plot of it concerns the relationship between the man of action and the man of thought and their easy ability to impersonate and, indeed, become each other. Shaw's plays are often composed of arguments in which the straw man argues fiercely and well until ultimately simply being unable to stand the blows of his opponents. In this show, when Dick Dudgeon becomes the Reverend Anderson and vice versa, they simply exchange registers and the pair of them become actors exchanging parts in repertory, while Ian Richardson as Burgoyne gets to say all the amusing lines. History becomes reduced to a minstrel show or Shakespearean male actors playing women who disguise themselves as men.

Well, if history is farce, then Shaw's witty lines make it an amusing farce. See it for that.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A Miss Is As Good As A Mile
rick_lapin15 November 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Not that I didn't enjoy watching this (sort of ... ), but I think this production is wrong-headed -- there are very few places where the sparkling wit characteristic of GBS is given a chance to breathe.

In form "The Devil's Disciple" is a melodrama; but one of the things Shaw attempted to do with the established forms of his era was to turn them upside-down and inside-out to reveal their limitations as representations of life; and this play is no exception. The director and cast of this BBC production apparently decided to play every scene with the kind of High Seriousness that would raise the melodramatic form to exquisite heights, instead of revealing those dramatic conventions (and the false societal codes behind them) as absurd.

Laugh after laugh is strangled in its cradle as the actors display their chops -- starting with the early scenes featuring Richard Dungeon's mother. Shaw meant you to laugh those kind of people right out of your mind and circle of acquaintance, not take them with such deadly gravity; the play should dance right along, not trudge, the dramatic and philosophical points making themselves with effortless good celestial humor.

The old Lancaster/Douglas film was much closer to the mark, as was a college production I saw many years ago that knew how to spoof melodrama, not insist on it -- and both were better representations of the kind of thing Shaw had in mind.

By the time Gentlemanly Johnny Burgoyne is allowed to sparkle, it's too late; and for my money, Laurence Olivier's breezy turn in the film beats Ian Richardson's somewhat labored performance into a cocked hat.

But the very worst performance of a Shaw play I ever saw was well worth watching; and that goes for this conceptually-flawed, all-but-plodding version of "The Devil's Disciple.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A Fine Television Adaptation!
Sylviastel13 December 2018
George Bernard Shaw was one of the great playwrights of the world. The BBC taped and recorded staged adaptations of his plays. He was witty and intelligent. His plays like "The Devil's Disciple" don't get produced enough about the American Revolution. Sir Patrick Stewart was the classical trained actor who did Shaw among other great playwrights. The film is a bit dated though. If you have to really work with Shaw to understand his brilliance though and that's the hard part. It's not a very funny play but serious and depressing at times. Shaw picked certain parts of world history to depict on stage. The cast is filled with great British actors and actresses like Ian Richardson, Elizabeth Spriggs, June Ellis and others.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Devil's Disciple, a compelling drama set in 1777.
mucky-duck-130 July 2005
A brilliant version of Shaw's play set in the second year of the American War for Independence, shown on Theatre Night on British television. Produced by Shaun Sutton and directed by David Jones.

Mike Gwilym takes the title role with attitude and a sneer! Elizabeth Spriggs is the long suffering mother (of Richard Dudgeon) and Susan Wooldridge as the Reverend's wife both are on top form, as is Ian Richardson as General Burgoyne.

Patrick Stewart plays The Reverand Anderson who follows his heart in all things and practises what he preaches. Larry lamb is the worldly wise soldier with a wink and a nod - say no more! The remainder of the cast give able support in what is a most enjoyable portrayal of the good and the bad (depending on where you stand) and Christian values.
6 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed