Lewis & Clark: The Journey of the Corps of Discovery (TV Movie 1997) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
12 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A Journey That Americans Should Appreciate
CitizenCaine28 January 2004
Warning: Spoilers
Ken Burns directs this PBS documentary on the expedition taken by Lewis & Clark from 1804-1806 at the behest of then President Thomas Jefferson. The film traces their journey, with nearly 50 expedition party members, northwest from St. Louis across the northern Louisiana Territory, into Oregon Territory, and to the Pacific Ocean and back. The film's composition includes beautiful cinematography and bridging music and the typical voice over narration that we've come to expect from a Ken Burns film. The narration includes commentary by historians and writers as well as excerpts from the actual daily journals of expedition members. The film details the many perilous obstacles they confront along the way, including changing river currents, disease, hostile Indians, lack of direction, lack of shelter, mental and physical fatigue, never-before-seen animal species, and weather changes.

It took them two and a half years to complete the journey, without ever finding a northwest passage to the ocean (which, of course, did not exist). However, the film highlights some of the important discoveries they made, such as plotting a map of the undiscovered West, documenting new plants and wildlife, and being able to diplomatically negotiate with different groups of Indians along the way. This is a skill America would later lose sight of. The film spends less time detailing the return journey, but illustrates a few important principles that we like to think of as American today: democratically voting when it was time to make a tough decision for the group, treating others as equals, and remaining steadfast in attempting to achieve goals. There's also a bit of sad irony when the expedition encounters the Nez Perce, if you know American History. The film is exciting and inspiring, without being too reverent. It's quite clear that these men and women faced tremendous hardships, had great courage and luck, and took great risks in making a journey, whose historical significance none of them realized. The journey itself is an extension of the visionary thinking that great, early Americans, like Jefferson, had. It was a journey of a lifetime for them and the journey of the century for the history of the United States. This should be required viewing in every high school History class. ***1/2 of 4 stars.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An absolute MUST for every school age kid to see !!!!!
mlehr7 September 2001
Beautiful Cinematography. Excellent narration. Inspiring. What a Journey !!!
9 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Brilliant documentary
grantss19 December 2015
Brilliant documentary.

The story of Meriwether Lewis and William Clark, the two adventurers who, in 1804-06, explored and charted North West America, from St Louis to Oregon.

Written and directed by master-documentarymaker Ken Burns, the man who gave us the greatest documentary series ever made, The Civil War. Thus, you always knew this was to going to be excellent.

In incredible detail we see the perils they faced, the ordeal of their journey and the importance of their efforts.

Very engaging - even though it is only a documentary (rather than a drama), you are engrossed in their travails and discoveries.

A must-see for anyone with an interest in history.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lewis and Clark 101
rrichr24 January 2003
If you have a love of history and the wilderness, and adhere to a certain code, the Lewis and Clark saga can get way under your skin. It certainly got under mine. In fact, it's still there although it doesn't itch quite as much as it once did. If you doubt me, watch writer/commenter Dayton Duncan fight back tears as he recounts Meriwether Lewis' heartbreaking demise in Ken Burns' PBS special on Lewis and Clark. The journey of the Corps of Discovery, as the expedition was entitled, occupies the emotional center of the history of the West in the same way that the Civil War occupies the specific history of the South. More than a few people now living would be tempted to sell their souls for the chance to jump back to 1804 and push off up the Missouri River with the Corps. Only the infected will understand.

Actually, I have Dayton Duncan to blame for my infection. I picked up his book, `Out West', a chronicle of his attempt to retrace some of the Lewis and Clark Trail (in a VW bus) at a yard sale and acquired the bug. From then on, any Lewis and Clark site had to be seriously out of the way from me to not attempt a visit. When I stood at Lewis' grave in rural Tennessee, reputedly on the spot where he died, I can't lie. I was moved. (I still want to see the site of the Two Medicine Fight, in which Lewis and his detachment, which had split off from the main party on the return journey, had been forced to kill two Blackfoot warriors; the only two Native Americans to die at the expedition's hands. It was an act for which the stratospherically-principled Lewis paid in kind (he was accidentally shot and severly wounded by one of his own men while hunting not long after the fight (unmentioned in the series); a pity as this sub-expedition was largely unnecessary.)

Despite its suave production, enchanting music track and heartfelt commentary by various historians including the late Stephen Ambrose, Ken Burns' rendering of the Lewis and Clark tale is just adequate historically. This is not to say I didn't like it. I thoroughly enjoyed it, both my initial viewing and a recent repeat broadcast. But there is so much more meat on the bones of this great adventure than the series was able to bite off. Anyone coming away from it with a case of the bug should definitely learn more. Allow me to suggest a course of action.

Much information resides on the Web but will often not tell you much more than the PBS production. Still, these sites can be fun. But don't be afraid to go analog as well. Find a good book or two on the subject.They're out there and will serve up more details. My favorite (out of print but still findable in a good bookstore or library) is `Lewis and Clark: Partners in Discovery' by John Bakeless. Here, you'll acquire a detailed, sensitive account of not only the expedition itself, but of the childhood and coming of age of Lewis and Clark, their experience as army officers on the frontier (then in Ohio) that laid their foundation as incomparable woodsmen, how the expedition was planned and outfitted, and what became of the many of its members after the return. Bakeless also makes a haunting and persuasive case for the possibility that Lewis did not commit suicide but may have been murdered; something I have always thought possible, certainly along the Natchez Trace, which in 1809 was probably the most dangerous place in North America. (This excellent book really should be re-printed for the bicentennial.)

Another interesting book (also out of print) is `Two Captains West' by Albert and Jane Salisbury. Not as scholarly as the Bakeless, it's still a worthy read and filled with photos of many actual Lewis and Clark sites, including some that are less well-known and, thereby, even more interesting to buffs. Once you've acquired a workable overview of the expedition, take the plunge into the actual journals that were compiled along the way by the Captains. At least two editions are extant, the most accessible being the abridged version by Bernard DeVoto, based on the original, complete journals (seven volumes and maps) published by Reuben Gold Thwaites in the early 1900's. At first, you may find the language challenging but eventually it will charm you. Then, go back to the PBS production for dessert. However, if you have not visited at least a couple of sites, I'm not sure we can call you a true buff. But once you're through DeVoto, your application for membership will be considered. And don't forget the aforementioned Dayton Duncan book.You'll like it.

A few months back, some soulless MBA-type did an article for the equally soulless e-zine, Slate, in which he disclaimed the importance of Lewis and Clark because they failed to find the Northwest Passage. This is rubbish, of course. The Passage was never there. How could the expedition have failed by not finding it? The importance of the Corps of Discovery lies not what it did, (which is still remarkable, Lexus Boy), but in what it symbolizes, what it says about the enormous promise that America once embodied, and the tough, resourceful people we once were. It speaks to a time when it was still not too late to rationally and humanely inhabit a world of profound beauty and natural harmony; a world in which the civil and hospitable Mandans, the incredibly noble Nez Perce, and even those pesky Teton Sioux and Blackfeet, all with knowledge to impart, had a place. We have actually fallen far, only to make temporary soft landings in our Lincoln Navigators. Lewis and Clark were geniuses, not of academia but in how they, and their command, manifested intelligence, compassion, and courage, often in the face of hardship we can barely imagine.
31 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Extremely well made and thorough
planktonrules15 October 2011
"Lewis & Clark: The Journey of the Corps of Discovery" is a very lengthy documentary that seems almost as long as the group's two year journey! This really isn't a complaint--more a comment about how incredibly thorough the show is. It's yet another exquisitely made documentary by Ken Burns--using the same wonderful and familiar style you'll see in his other PBS films. And, perhaps, it's made a bit better--very slow and lovingly rendered. The cinematography might just be the best thing about it--with wonderful vistas of the west and northwest United States. There were a few interesting surprises in the film--especially concerning Lewis' sad life due to debilitating difficulties which today would be diagnosed as a Bipolar Disorder. The interactions of the expedition with the natives was also an interesting surprise. All in all, a terrific film--just know that you'll need to devote a lot of time to it. However, IMDb indicates it's four hours long but the DVD was only about three and a half. I am not sure what this discrepancy is all about--I assume that the time listed on IMDb is just a simple mistake.

By the way, it's never mentioned in the film, but I wonder if President Jefferson sent OTHER expeditions as well but these were just never heard from again. Could this be the case? I do know that Zebulon Pike was soon sent on another western expedition--but there must have been others.

Perfect in every way--not to be missed.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An amazing story beautifully told
bootlebarth31 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
I'm writing this when there are only seven other reviews. Compared with the hundreds or thousands of reviews of popular cinematographic dross (the greater the dross, the more the reviews), is there any point?

The Journey of the Corps of Discovery is an amazing story, beautifully told. President Jefferson sends his secretary to find a route to the Pacific Ocean across thousands of miles of largely unknown territory. The adventure proves that truth can be stranger than fiction. This is an epic trip. Ken Burns has made some marvelous series, but none better.

There are so many memorable moments that it seems pointless to select a sample. I'll never forget Meriwether Lewis's diary entry on his 31st birthday, rueing his indolence and lack of achievement at what he thought would be the half-way stage of his life.

Everyone should see this wonderful series. Unfortunately, the bulk of the popcorn-eating, couch-potato viewing public prefer banality and fantasy to fact.

Treat yourself to one of the best series ever.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
so Apropos of 2021!
cintrat15 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I'm 70 yrs old! Lewis & Clark, along with Jim Bridger (after Roy Rogers/Annie Oakley, Lone Ranger and Tonto) were my highest esteemed heroes in K-12. In HS, I read a book of their voyage, all the documentation/observations demanded by TJ - afterwards I set off walking with a spiral notebook to document everything I saw along my walk (instead of riding my horse), which happened to be on Iliff street near Monaco in Denver when it was still a dirt road, (Monaco did not go through from Jewel to Evans) I remember sitting in a grassy ditch on a sunny windy winter/spring Saturday describing the scene (where is that journal?).

This week Jan 2021 - I was amazed to watch this documentary (flaws and questionable accuracies and all)! Coincidentally it had only 10 days ago occurred to me that what the whites did to the Indians is now happening to whites! Then I watched this doc! Gasp!

Listening to an audio book about the Oregon trails - all the deaths from Cholera because mankind didn't understand polluted water . . . nowadays >half US population taking script meds, >20% of those & others addicted to anti anxiety substances, + Costco quantities of food, alcohol, sugar - > half population unhealthy, unwell, sustained by B Pharm. Counter productive to mankind, enriching J&J Phizer etc. like RRs, industry & meat packing enriched the 1900's Robber Barrons. Now it's Pharm barrons.

  • - - presents such a shocking contrast to the future and the present that existed for L&C and Americans then! I am encouraging EVERYONE this doc is a MUST WATCH!
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Ken Burn's Story of the Lewis & Clark Expedition
gpeevers15 June 2009
Warning: Spoilers
Documentary by Ken Burn's about the expedition commissioned by Thomas Jefferson, and led by Meriwether Lewis and William Clark setting out from St Louis to explore the Missouri River and find a passage to the Pacific Ocean. The expedition would also provide; an invaluable map, details of new plants and animals including samples and the establishment of diplomatic relations for the United States with various Native American tribes.

The story of this expedition is quite interesting, although I did not find the presentation as dynamic as I would have liked. Fortunately there is considerable material from the expedition's journals that allows us to get a real feel for these men, their hardships and their discoveries in their own words.

One major limitation for me was that as a result of the time period in which this occurred, as there were no photographs from the era and the filmmakers were forced to rely on either paintings, present day footage of parts of their route (only those where signs of current civilization are not evident) and some non-specific usually distant recreations showing the keel boat or men in silhouette.

For those unfamiliar with the details of the expedition the story of Sacagawea, the young native American girl is fascinating.

The story is narrated by Hal Holbrook and features the vocal talents of Mathew Broderick, Sam Waterston and Adam Arkin.

This film is not nearly as good as Burn's masterworks on the US Civil War or Baseball, but this is still an interesting well told documentary on an interesting subject.

While Lewis and Clark were the first American's to cross the continent Sir Alexander Mackenzie a Canadian had already done so 10 years earlier.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Can't get past the awful music
suzysasse2 February 2019
This is what we would now all call a typically enjoyable film by Ken Burns, if one could only get past the gawdawful music accompaniment.
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Poorly researched
usaf4632 December 2005
Ken Burns and Dayton Duncan are excellent film makers, but their focus on relying on still photography and reenactors in this documentary left much to be desired.

The lack of research is obvious. Images used throughout the film are of the post expedition period, at times decades after the event. Why the lack of period images? Hundreds, if not thousands of artifacts from the era, including drawings and paintings were ignored.

Historical accuracy of the reenactors left much to be desired, they are not clothed in the accoutrements issued by the U.S. Army nor correct civilian attire of the time frame. This is clearly evident by anyone wishing to review documentation produced by The Company of Military Historians, who published information on the 1st U.S. Infantry back in 1951. Lewis and Clark reenactors are notorious for their lack of historical accuracy.

Interviews with some historians (friends of the film makers) left much to be desired and did much to lesson the impact of this film.

Overall, it was an interesting endeavor but one which suffered from too much emotionalism. If you want to learn about the U.S. Army's Corps of Discovery, read the original journals.

Nothwithstanding the celebrity endorsements and hype, the Lewis and Clark Bicentennial Celebration has become a monumental flop.
5 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Everyone should see this film, and appreciate that famous journey.
TxMike8 October 2003
Ken Burns' film is a landmark study of the 1804 through 1806 Lewis and Clark expedition, starting in St Louis, and returning there two years later, having found a route to the Pacific Ocean. Put your political leanings aside, this film does not judge whether the USA, Spain, and France *should* have been able to grab and trade the native lands occupied for centuries by various Native American tribes. Lewis and Clark, and the men that went with them, were true explorers. Their journey is almost unimaginable. When you fly west over the USA during a clear day, and can see the wide expanse of mountains, you can begin to understand what an ordeal it was for them to cross over to what we now call the Columbia River. This is not a dry historical film. Everyone should see it, for the historical significance of the journey. The city of St Louis built a high arch in commemoration of the journey, and it is called "The Jefferson Expansion Memorial."

I saw the DVD, and it is a really fine one. I got it as a free loan from my local library, maybe you can too!! Plus, one of the narrators is my old college friend Daniel von Bargen.
13 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Great Viewing Experience But May Be Hazardous To Health
wpbenson10 May 2014
I be an old fart of 60 years. I enjoy Walking Dead and GoT so I believe I have a pretty well rounded circle of influence.

That stated this film blows me away (far, far away). As I sit in my 3 BR 3 B AC'd and heated house, with a full fridge of nourishment, I finish watching this film desperately wishing I could have been one of the Corp. A deep melancholy settles into me. The only cure I have found for this morbid depression is to get my rig ready, and shoot up my medicine by hitting replay. Again, and again, and again,...... I fear for my sanity. I have tried exploring the wilderness around me, but I can only hike a few yards without meeting some other human or their waste. Alas.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed