On Our Selection (1932) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
3/10
Give it a miss!
JohnHowardReid13 April 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Producer: Bert Bailey. Executive producer: Stuart F. Doyle. A Cinesound Production in association with Bailey and Grant. Australian release through British Empire Films: July 1932. Sydney opening at the Capitol. U.K. release title: Down on the Farm.

SYNOPSIS: Dad Rudd, a typical Aussie outback battler, has to contend with drought, tight money, a grasping landlord, a wayward bull and an eager-to-help but slow-thinking and mishap-prone son.

NOTES: Eclipsed only by Palmy Days as the biggest ticket-seller in Australia in 1932. Counting revivals and re-issues up to 1980, On Our Selection has probably exceeded the Goldwyn picture's box-office takings four or five times over - though this comparison is a bit unfair to Palmy Days since that picture was never re-circulated in Australia after its original release.

Locations near Penrith, New South Wales.

COMMENT: This rural farce has some curiosity value as an example of primitive film-making, but it has little else to recommend it though it will probably still delight the yokel trade. The film editing is jerky, caused by the director's failure to shoot proper matching shots, there is no background music except under old silent-type titles, the continuity is abrupt, the acting over-ripe and directorial style almost non-existent except for a remarkably effective instance of double exposure. Location photography helps, though the technical quality is surprisingly variable.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Humour has moved on since the 30s, but this has its moments
PeterM2717 December 2021
This was not the first film version of Steele Rudd's popular book, but it was the most successful. It was particularly based on Bert Bailey's popular stage play version of the book. Bailey co-wrote the script with Hall and starred in the film. The film was the most successful Australian film up to that time, and enabled Hall to make a dozen other films over the next 15 years, including three Dad and Dave sequels.

Unfortunately the print available on Youtube is very fuzzy, which detracts from the experience today - I'd like to see a clearer version. The film also suffers from 1930s 'stageyness', perhaps because of Bailey's stage experience with the play.

However, parts of the film are comical and there are some very witty quips. Bailey is the best as Dad, Fred MacDonald overplays Dave as a retarded yokel, and the other characters are a mixed bag. It's good to see this as an important film and story in Australia's film development, but, like many films of the era, it doesn't really stand up as entertainment now. Ken Hall's movies got much better, but On Our Selection was the film that got him started.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed