I really love this movie, a hilarious story... To me, it is an asian version of The Naked Gun, with many totally unexpected turns (i.e. laughs)... The humor of this movie is different from most movies I have ever seen - maybe it is a typical eastern humor? I don't know, all I can say is that I have never encountered this kind of humor before or after. The movie is extremely high paced, throwing you from one unexpected situation to another.
4 Reviews
A Hong Kong cult classic
stanley202012 January 2003
Needless to say, it is the masterpiece. A cult comedy masterpiece Hong Kong have ever made. You know, it is a Jeffrey Lau's film, Hong Kong's Peter Jackson, or, probably, you say he is only Ed Wood, making lousy, nonsense and crazy things.
It is remarkable that Tony Leung(my hero) do his best performance as Lui Kei (a 60's famous star and 70's Russ Meyer -- pornography director) in the film.
It is remarkable that Tony Leung(my hero) do his best performance as Lui Kei (a 60's famous star and 70's Russ Meyer -- pornography director) in the film.
A comedic twist to the Black Rose legend!
OllieSuave-00713 April 2015
This is a sequel or spoof of some sort to 1965's The Black Rose, where a poet named Butterfly (Maggie Siu) and her friend Kuen (Teresa Mo) stumbles upon an illegal weapons operation and finding themselves the prime suspects in the case. To avoid the police, the two innocent witnesses reconstruct the crime scene, making it appear that the perpetrator was "The Black Rose." However, the apprentices of the Black Rose attempt to seek the truth in the matter.
What started off as a pretty goofy movie eventually led to an action-packed and suspenseful story, especially during the scenes where Butterfly and Kuen attempt to evade the police and when the Black Rose apprentices Yim-Fan (Wan-Si Wong) and Piu-Hung (Bo-Bo Fung) first appear on-screen. Yim-Fan's tough, eloquent, but hilariously funny personality steals the spotlight movie for me, from her chanting the Kung-Fu moves at the ring of the bell to her turning from tough to delicate to woo Detective Keith Lui (Tony Leung).
Although set in Hong Kong in 1992, the cinematography and atmosphere capture a classic ambiance of the '60s, particularly the grand mansion of the apprentices - a clear nod to the original 1965 Black Rose movie. I also especially liked the classic songs and the superb music score in the movie, which I think gives the modern story a more unique feel.
The plot is solid and pretty fast-paced and the acting was overall great. Lots of character development and chemistry as well, from the romance between Keith Lui and Butterfly and the frustrated partnership between Yim-Fan and Piu-Hung. Kwok Leung Cheung plays a tough villain and Teresa Mo gives the movie extra comedy relief.
It's an outstanding movie overall and one of the best action comedies from Hong Kong.
Grade A-
What started off as a pretty goofy movie eventually led to an action-packed and suspenseful story, especially during the scenes where Butterfly and Kuen attempt to evade the police and when the Black Rose apprentices Yim-Fan (Wan-Si Wong) and Piu-Hung (Bo-Bo Fung) first appear on-screen. Yim-Fan's tough, eloquent, but hilariously funny personality steals the spotlight movie for me, from her chanting the Kung-Fu moves at the ring of the bell to her turning from tough to delicate to woo Detective Keith Lui (Tony Leung).
Although set in Hong Kong in 1992, the cinematography and atmosphere capture a classic ambiance of the '60s, particularly the grand mansion of the apprentices - a clear nod to the original 1965 Black Rose movie. I also especially liked the classic songs and the superb music score in the movie, which I think gives the modern story a more unique feel.
The plot is solid and pretty fast-paced and the acting was overall great. Lots of character development and chemistry as well, from the romance between Keith Lui and Butterfly and the frustrated partnership between Yim-Fan and Piu-Hung. Kwok Leung Cheung plays a tough villain and Teresa Mo gives the movie extra comedy relief.
It's an outstanding movie overall and one of the best action comedies from Hong Kong.
Grade A-
Jumble of scenes
Leofwine_draca23 May 2020
Warning: Spoilers
92 LEGENDARY LA ROSE NOIRE is a truly oddball slice of Hong Kong comedy, a spoof of the hard-to-find '60s spy drama BLACK ROSE about a female Robin Hood-type character. This one assembles the usual bunch of dopey characters for a kind of thirty-years later follow-up, with Tony Leung as a suave '60s-styled cop and Bo Bo Fung as the original Black Rose, now sadly suffering from dementia. Questionable mental health comedy aside, prolific director Jeffrey Lau brings his custom energy to the production, but it's all a jumble of scenes rather than any cohesive narrative. Teresa Mo is as great as ever, and there are some fun bits of action and scenes involving gangsters and traps along the way, but I didn't really enjoy it overall.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
